neonat wrote:

Allure

00:14:679 (1,2) - the start of (1) and end of (2) overlapping each other's head ever so slightly didn't really look that nice, and having more curve to 00:15:179 (2) would feel better from the transition from 00:14:679 (1) fixed

SPOILER

00:15:679 (3,1) - to make the touch look more pleaing and also to make it move easier from 00:16:013 (1) to 00:16:513 (2) fixed

SPOILER

00:21:679 (2,3,4) - make it such that emphasis can be given to 00:22:013 (4) - ? By making it more of a jump compared to the previous one, like how 00:23:179 (2,3) jumps more than 00:22:679 (1,2) fixed
00:25:346 (1,2) - could still blanket better fixed
00:30:513 (6,2) - stack pls nah not same combo -3-
00:40:096 (1) - for the first 4 beats I can't see the spinner length on the timeline LOL (if you don't click it)
00:58:346 (4) - facing it down would be more suited some flow variation pls

SPOILER

01:00:513 (3,5) - more spacing between them, make spacing between 01:00:513 (3,5,1) equal then fixed

Hard

00:19:179 (2,3) - blanket can be improved fixed
00:23:346 (3,4) - swap positions, slider before circle, to highlight the drum beat fixed
00:24:679 (5,1) - avoid the overlap fixed
00:40:096 (1) - spinner goes poof too

Normal

00:27:679 (2,1) - not stacked fixed
00:29:346 (1,1) - disappears

Lols disappearing stuff, good luck not my fault -3-

Gaia wrote:

the map i have right now https://osu.ppy.sh/s/186773 has a really abrupt ending and I was wondering if you could possibly extend the last note by a bit and fade it out?

I asked my friend for help but he didn't know how to extend the note so he just faded it out , but it sounds kinda too sudden to me s:
what he did: http://puu.sh/c98f8/cdaec48c62.mp3

and here's my original .mp3 : http://puu.sh/c97YX/8ace26a6b8.mp3

1. "Game" is already in the Genre so consider removing it in Tags. you won't need it. like this
   
2. Did you use "soft-hitnormal" file ? I couldn't confirm it orz

1. 00:13:346 (1,2) - As you can see these sliders overlap, so if you can, please make these sliders not overlap~
2. 00:52:679 (3) - It's enough to use 1/1 rhythm for this difficulty. So you won't need 1/2 repeat slider at here.
3. 01:06:679 (1,2) - Same as above.

1. 00:04:013 (3,1) - Same as Easy diff about overlap~

1. 00:50:846 - add a note here? you made the 1/1 rhythm in other parts 00:43:679 (3,1) - ,00:45:012 (3,1) - and 00:47:846 (5,1,2) - . So consider using same rhythm to here. It prevents the player from misreading.

1. 00:10:179 (4,5,6) - fm, I can't hear sounds on blue line and you used silence section o_o well , i don't agree "Overmapping". please give it another thought.
2. 00:19:179 (2) - flow suggestion: try to use a curve slider instead of a straight. It will be more natural flow.
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:47:179 (1) - no need to add a new combo here. It's better to remove it for players.
4. 00:46:679 (1) - ^ Same.

alacat wrote:

Hey ~ from my queue ~ https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/t/86607/start=489

[General]

1. "Game" is already in the Genre so consider removing it in Tags. you won't need it. like this yup, fixed
   
2. Did you use "soft-hitnormal" file ? I couldn't confirm it orz yeah i am actually, it's so people with a custom soft-hitnormal skin sound will have the default soft-hitnormal sound // I'll remove if it's redundant tho :S

[Easy]

1. 00:13:346 (1,2) - As you can see these sliders overlap, so if you can, please make these sliders not overlap~ i actually got this from a recently ranked easy so i think it's fine
2. 00:52:679 (3) - It's enough to use 1/1 rhythm for this difficulty. So you won't need 1/2 repeat slider at here. changed to 1/1 slider~
3. 01:06:679 (1,2) - Same as above. same

[Normal]

1. 00:04:013 (3,1) - Same as Easy diff about overlap~ same as easy s: nvm i dont like this look anymore xD

[Hard]

1. 00:50:846 - add a note here? you made the 1/1 rhythm in other parts 00:43:679 (3,1) - ,00:45:012 (3,1) - and 00:47:846 (5,1,2) - . So consider using same rhythm to here. It prevents the player from misreading. True, but there also isnt any sound at 00:50:846 so i think its better to leave it blank

[Allure]

1. 00:10:179 (4,5,6) - fm, I can't hear sounds on blue line and you used silence section o_o well , i don't agree "Overmapping". please give it another thought. yeah after like 4-5 people ill change these to circles
2. 00:19:179 (2) - flow suggestion: try to use a curve slider instead of a straight. It will be more natural flow. done~
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:47:179 (1) - no need to add a new combo here. It's better to remove it for players.
4. 00:46:679 (1) - ^ Same. no nc for both!

I'm worry about the difficulty spread between Hard and Allure diff. Because of many jumps in Allure diff. try to make a jump in Hard diff or reduce a jump part in Allure diff! So please try to think about it again :3 ahh I'll try to nerf some jumps in my insane and buff hard ~ i dont want to change too much tho, ive already had the spread discussion with someone before so ..
orz

Well, That's all for now. Check these and let me know.

1. There's 10 ms delay for both soft-hitfinish.wav and soft-slidertick2.wav, fix it please as it's unrankable now. http://puu.sh/cIfKe.png
2. What's the difference between default soft-hitnormal and S:C1 one? ;w;
3. Any confirmation on metadata and tags? Why not all capital for the company name? http://puu.sh/cIhB8.png Also, for the source, it should be all capital according baka Habi and http://puu.sh/cIida.jpg
   >_> http://bgmstore.net/view/FRDMw what? cant read even a word, can u please find a Korean to check the metadata

1. 00:26:012 - 00:30:012 - 00:31:512 - Snap these green lines if you have free time lol.
2. 00:08:013 (1) - Slider end lands on nothing. 00:09:346 (2) - too. This sounds much better. http://puu.sh/cIdhb.jpg
3. 00:56:012 - The rhythm is a bit weird in my point of view as you miss the stress at 00:57:346 - Maybe something like this? http://puu.sh/cIcVE.jpg
4. 01:12:013 (1) - It would be nice if you can do something similar as 01:13:346 (2,1) - and remove the NC and whistle on 01:14:346 (1) -

1. 00:30:012 - 00:31:512 - Snap these green lines.
2. 00:50:846 - Circle for the string? And avoid the polarity issue?
3. 00:48:179 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6) - I don't know why the density soars so much for this stanza but nvm. We need a harder Normal.
4. 01:12:012 (1,2,1) - No 1/2 rhythms? Now it's no difference from Easy. http://puu.sh/cIdXW.jpg It would be nice too if u can arrange 01:01:346 (1,2) - to 1/2 rhythm to raise the difficulty (not star rating) as of the spread concern.

1. 00:30:012 - Snap this green line.
2. 00:50:846 - Missing a circle here if ur following the string.
3. 01:06:346 (3) - 01:09:013 (3) - 01:11:679 (3) - http://puu.sh/cIeSU.jpg This distance is really misleading, either reduce that of (2) & (3) or increase that between 01:11:679 (3,1) - or make them like what u did in the prelude - stacking.
4. 01:13:346 (1,2,3,4,1) - Idk what ur following tbh ;w; Please explain a bit.

1. 01:13:346 (1,2,1,2) - Same as Hard, elaboration is needed in order to help me understand your intention.

IamKwaN wrote:

seems like i can speak chinese but anyway
[General]

1. There's 10 ms delay for both soft-hitfinish.wav and soft-slidertick2.wav, fix it please as it's unrankable now. http://puu.sh/cIfKe.png aa time to whoop out my mp3 slave :>
2. What's the difference between default soft-hitnormal and S:C1 one? ;w; no difference, i explained why i kept in there in alacat's mod but looks like its unnecessary so removed
3. Any confirmation on metadata and tags? Why not all capital for the company name? http://puu.sh/cIhB8.png Also, for the source, it should be all capital according baka Habi and http://puu.sh/cIida.jpg
   >_> http://bgmstore.net/view/FRDMw what? cant read even a word, can u please find a Korean to check the metadata all caps on ZEONIX// the source i believe would be SWORD GiRLS in that sense which I find unlikely so keeping it as Sword Girls for now (I checked with 2 native korean speakers)
   Edit: Source should be all caps like it says right on my BG LOL :p
   SPOILER

   

[Easy]

1. 00:26:012 - 00:30:012 - 00:31:512 - Snap these green lines if you have free time lol. done!
2. 00:08:013 (1) - Slider end lands on nothing. 00:09:346 (2) - too. This sounds much better. http://puu.sh/cIdhb.jpg yaaa i agree fixed
3. 00:56:012 - The rhythm is a bit weird in my point of view as you miss the stress at 00:57:346 - Maybe something like this? http://puu.sh/cIcVE.jpg aa im following the violin afterall, i think it's okay
4. 01:12:013 (1) - It would be nice if you can do something similar as 01:13:346 (2,1) - and remove the NC and whistle on 01:14:346 (1) - the NC+whistle is something ive done throughout my diffs so i'd like to keep that o: as for the pattern i see where you're coming from but i like it this way more gomen >.<

[Normal]

1. 00:30:012 - 00:31:512 - Snap these green lines. done~
2. 00:50:846 - Circle for the string? And avoid the polarity issue? mmm tbh i dont hear anything there, and sounds like overmapping if i do put sth ;; whats the polarity issue tho o-o?
3. 00:48:179 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6) - I don't know why the density soars so much for this stanza but nvm. We need a harder Normal. lol shhhhhhhhhh :]
4. 01:12:012 (1,2,1) - No 1/2 rhythms? Now it's no difference from Easy. http://puu.sh/cIdXW.jpg It would be nice too if u can arrange 01:01:346 (1,2) - to 1/2 rhythm to raise the difficulty (not star rating) as of the spread concern. yeah cool i've changed it up

[Hard]

1. 00:30:012 - Snap this green line. done!!
2. 00:50:846 - Missing a circle here if ur following the string. same as normal s:
3. 01:06:346 (3) - 01:09:013 (3) - 01:11:679 (3) - http://puu.sh/cIeSU.jpg This distance is really misleading, either reduce that of (2) & (3) or increase that between 01:11:679 (3,1) - or make them like what u did in the prelude - stacking. okie, i increased distance (for spread??) but yaa
4. 01:13:346 (1,2,3,4,1) - Idk what ur following tbh ;w; Please explain a bit. see insane

[Insane]

1. 01:13:346 (1,2,1,2) - Same as Hard, elaboration is needed in order to help me understand your intention. I'm following the harp-ish instrument that i have no idea the name of haha, i thought this part was relatively straightforward and ive asked for opinions and they think it's alright so i think im good?

Hopefully this spread won't be unranked, good luck alaQAT and IamBaka >_> wwwwwww i hope soo toooooo

IamKwaN wrote:

this is non-scientific