-Bakari- wrote:

Yo, as requested.

[General]

1. kaichou wa maid sama ost main theme piano maeguchi wataru pjecoo remove it all from the tags. All these things are already mentioned and you shouldn't put them to the tags
   Note: add some names f the main characters / some tags related to the song, instead.
2. Do you REALLY need the countdown? It sounds kinda.. uh.. weird here, imo.
3. The offset feels a bit off, try to move the second red line a bit, something like -20-30 should work, imo.
4. I can not hear any hitsounds, they're really hrd to notice. o, I feel like clicking on air, rather than playing a beatmap. Make sure that ALL of your hitsounds are audible.
5. Most of your sliders could be improved a lot if you start using the new algorythm of making them. Just use 3 anchors (start - curve - end) and you'll see how easy it is to make your sliders prettier!
6. Make an easier version (like a Normal diff or so), in order to make the mapset playable for ALL kind of players!

[Misaki]
Won't go into the details. You can poke me again when you finsih with the changes mentioned in the mod.

1. 00:21:719 (1,2) - try to reduce OD by one tick. Sounds like a good idea to me,
2. 00:01:719 (1,2,3) - not a fan of such DS changes. They could be okay, but not for the beginning of the map
3. 00:12:307 (2,3) - replacing them with a slider would be a nice idea. It'll represent the music quite good, imo.
4. 00:21:719 (1,2) - nazi - it's a minor thing, but players prefer polished maps, so it's better if you avoid overlaps like this one. Overlaps do't look well and will bug players.
5. 00:48:576 (3,4,5) - do NOT overuse spacing changes. They're unpredictable and illogical from my point of view, also it's kinda makes me nervous and I can't enjoy playing the diff at all.
   
   So, yeah, try to make your spacing a bit more understandable and work on the appearance of your patterns!

Pretty much the same applies for the other diff, so you'll be able to figure ut the problems yourself.

So yeah. There's a lot of things to improve and I'll be glad to help you! poke me if you have any questions!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Best of luck!