Byakugan249's Mod
Byakugan249 wrote:
Alrighty let's get started. mod requested on my queue.
Bold: Unrankable/must fix.
Red: You should fix it, but it's up to you.
Italic: Suggestion. Feel free to ignore this if you don't like it.
Blue: Comment. Just putting this for fun
[General]
How about an orange/reddish, combo color to match the background of the characters? I thought of that too, but no change for now
If you have it, add a soft-sliderslide file where it's silent. you can't hear the sound of the sliderslide. if you don't have that file, take this one. I already got one, thanks !
hmm re-snap the green lines. they're off by 1ms. Fixed
[Normal]
The settings look like it'd be in an easy diff. Increase everything except the CS by 1. if this was an easy diff, i'd let it go. Fixed
00:04:040 (2,3) - make these notes curved sliders. for (2), you'll make a border for the previous and for (3), you'll blanket the previous slider. I think it flows a lot smoother during gameplay. Fixed
00:08:988 (1,2,3,4) - Instead of a square, how about a diamond? i think it'll be fun for beginners. i think the square pattern looks boring for the introduction to the song IMO. Fixed
00:21:359 (1) - add a whistle at the repeat arrow to match the piano. i'm guessing the whistles are not only for consistency, but it's to follow the piano. Fixed
00:23:834 (1) - same as above but at the end. Fixed
00:26:617 (2) - same as 00:21:359. Fixed
00:36:205 (1,2,3,4) - when i reached this pattern, i felt uncomfortable because of the direction it's taking. The way (2) is slanted in that direction made me feel uncomfortable. i don't feel the flow in this part at all. make this part curved sliders like this. it'll flow a lot smoother to the song, and i feel comfortable with the curved sliders in effect. Fixed
00:52:287 (3) - the finish seems too loud for me. add a timing point and reduce the volume to 35%. Fixed
01:25:844 (1) - extend the slider till 01:28:782. the long pause ends here. Fixed
hmm i think that if you can add a few more whistles, it'll go really nicely with the piano. go back to the song and add whistles to where the tone of the piano changes. I added some more.
[Hard]
Maybe increase the HP and OD by 1 to put a bit of a challenge for players? No change for HP
00:20:431 (5) - since you have a whistle at the end, extend the slider 1/4 more to follow the piano. Fixed
01:02:339 (4,5,6,7) - I think it'd be easier if you can replace the circles for 1/4 sliders to make it easier? No, due to the BPM, this shouldn't be hard to play
01:12:700 (5) - add a clap at the beginning for consistency purposes. Fixed
01:25:689 (6) - why did the spacing increase for this note? i doesn't make sense and this jump might surprise players. follow the DS for (3-5) and form a parallelogram so that it'd flow smoother during gameplay. Fixed
same comment about the whistles. Done
[TuInsane]
same as Hard about the diff settings. No change here for HP too
00:36:205 (1) - the finish is too loud and I find it unfitting to the song. reduce the volume to either 20% or 30%. so that it wouldn't be that much of a distraction during gameplay/ I decreased to 35%
00:24:761 (5) - make this slider look like the previous slider and Ctrl+R. i think it'll flow smoother during gameplay. Fixed
01:11:772 (4) - i see that you're blanketing the next slider, but make it symmetrical so that it'd blanket the next slider nicely. Fixed
01:15:483 (2) - hmm how about Ctrl+R and move the 2nd point to the left side? it should be like this. since this is an insane, it wouldn't hurt to add a jump here to challenge players. Fixed
same comment about the whistles, and do Ctrl+R on some parts of the 1/4 sliders like the one at 00:24:761. I think that it'll make the diff fun for players. Done again
I guess that's it. Overall the custom claps before the kiai sound too loud for me. i highly suggest that you reduce the volume so that it doesn't cuase that much of a distraction for me and other players. anyways GLThank you !
