Hello, sorry for the huge delay ...
[Song's Info]
- Source: Are you sure this doesn't come from anywhere ?
[General]
- Are you sure about the timing ? I'm not good at it so I suggests you to check it with someone who is an expert
[Skin]
- I'm sorry in advance but I'm going to be very picky with your skin and point all the things I dislike/disagree with but these are just opinions except for some that are a must
- Reduce cursor trail to a 1x1 png to save space
- Default numbers 6, 7 and 8 are not well centered, you can clearly see it when playing
- Default comma, dot, percent and x are not necessary and should be removed. This is because they don't affect the looks of the skin at all, only score ones do
- Reduce slider point 10 and 30 to a 1x1 png to save space
- I'm not very sure about that spinner circle, I mean yes it does give me something to look for to know if I'm spinning or not but I don't know if it is noticeable enough
- It would be nice if you added score numbers too
- It would be nice and it is highly recommended to add a pause overlay, fail background, pause buttons (pause-continue, pause-back, pause-retry)
- You have to add a play-skip too
- You mention that the map is better when you don't use combo burst, you can force this if you add a 1x1 transparent png image named comboburst.png to your folder. When you do this the combo burst will automatically be this 1x1 png
[Easy]
- Since this is such a slow song and the slider velocity is really calm I'd suggest AR -1, I feel like it suits the feeling that the song is trying to give more than the current AR but this is a suggestion so do as you like
- 00:37:805 >> Try using normal finish 20~30% volume, it sounds quite nice and fits
- 00:39:827 >> New combo
- 00:45:221 >> ^
- 01:04:097 >> I strongly suggest that you add a note but it's ok if you don't this too
- 01:16:906 >> Here too, a normal finish with 50~60% volume sounds very nice
- 01:30:389 >> New combo
- 01:38:479 >> Again, a normal finish sounds better in my opinion
- 01:43:872 >> Whistles should only go on the start and second reverse arrow in my opinion
- 01:58:704 >> Add a whistle
- 01:59:378 >> It may be good to use a normal finish here with 30~40& volume instead of the whistle
- 02:35:108 >> Normal finish 50~60% volume sounds awesome
[Star's Normal]
- 00:37:805 >> Same as Easy
- 01:02:075 >> I think you should delete this note, it plays and feels better this way imo
- 01:04:434 >> Add a note
- 01:16:906 >> Same as Easy
- 01:24:996 >> New combo
- 01:38:479 >> Same as Easy
- 01:59:378 >> A normal finish with 30~40% volume sounds better
- 02:05:783 >> New combo
- 02:11:513 >> ^
- 02:16:906 >> ^
- 02:21:962 >> ^
- 02:38:479 >> ^
- 03:06:550 >> Reduce volume to 10%
- 03:14:534 >> ^ and add a whistle
[Hard]
- 00:17:243 >> The slider should end here, you can clearly hear the sound of the piano (I think here) so it makes more sense to end the slider here
- 00:19:940 >> Start the slider here, same reasons as above
- 00:22:805 >> Add a note to follow the music more
- 00:37:805 >> Same as Easy
- 00:40:165 >> End the slider here
- 01:16:906 >> Same as Easy
- 01:23:479 >> Add a note
- 01:38:479 >> Same as Easy
- 01:43:872 >> Add whistle on the start
- 01:44:547 >> The whistle should go on the end
- 01:45:729 >> Add whistle
- 01:46:569 (1,3,5) >> Add whistle on the start
- 02:02:749 >> Reduce the volume to 20~30%
- 02:13:535 >> A normal finish with 30~40% volume would sound good
- 02:35:108 >> ^
- 02:44:378 >> Start the slider (3) here but end on the same spot as before
- 02:15:559 >> Use 15% volume
[Wmf's Taiko]
- I'm not very sure but aren't breaks in taiko difficulties not allowed ? Around 02:00:052 there's a break
Very nice overall
