Thanks alot, you deserve your kudos, as well.wmfchris wrote:
here we go.
[general]
I think you'll need an audio lead-in of 2000 - 2500. Fixed.
The avg bitrate is~93kbps which is unrankble. Try to find a source with 128~192 kbps. (if it exceeds 192 you can compress it, but it's not recommend to change song with 9x kbps to 128 kbps because the quality's still poor. This is not possible, since it's directly copied from the game's directory, which only provides this quality of audio. You won't find any better, unfortunately.
make sure you full submit after this ^.
The audio lead-in time's not unique. At least it should be the same for collab and taiko because they start at the same time.
[Taiko]
00:13:990 - k?
00:23:265 - ^
00:39:490 - no problem here, just to say that the trill in music's not exactly on tick. It's about 1/8 beat eariler, same for the coming positions.
00:54:115 - k---d---k?
00:57:302 - a transitional section of the song, it would be nice if you continuously put a waltz beat ( k d d k d d) there. So either d k or k d here?
01:06:490 - add a d ( <- a red note) here?
beautiful piece and nice taiko diff.
8/10
Skipped and redirected.
[Collab]
00:21:865 (2) - whistle? Ok.
00:35:365 (4,5,6) - whistle finish on (4,5), nothing on (6) would give a nice sudden muting effect Sounds great.
01:18:677 (2) - I prefer whistle here only Ok.
01:51:302 - make a gradual change on hitsound.
01:53:365 (4) - whistle Ok.
02:09:865 - same treatment as 0:35. Ok.
[Normal]
Spacing isn't so stable? 00:01:802 (2,3,4) 0.9x, (4,5) 0.95x, (5,6) 1.02x, 00:09:865 (6,1) - 0.85x ...
In the easiest diff a constant spacing is quite important so I think you can fix them with grid lv4. Fixed.
00:35:365, 02:09:865 - same as hard collab Ok.
deserve a star here.
Thanks alot! Also you deserve your kudosu.fartownik wrote:
General:
- Add 0,5 of the lead-in time in Taiko difficulty so it's consistent with Collab. See above.
- 00:19:240 - Not the best place to put kiai time on. I'd just delete it and save it for the last part only. Ok.
- Your mp3 has quite poor quality (96kbps). Find another one if possible? See above.
[Hard Collab]
00:49:615 (7) - New slider speed = new combo. Ok.
00:52:615 (1,2) - Swap new combos. Ok.
01:07:615 (3) - New slider speed = new combo. Ok.
01:48:115 (6) - ^ Ok.
01:53:740 (1) - Add a Finish here? Seems like a good place. Ok.
Some of these speed changes are really confusing. Same goes to the sudden 1/6's.
However, it's pretty good mapped and plays fun. Those triplets are actually 1/6 timed. If you playback them on slowmote, you'll realize that. We also were confused at first and then recognized that this is matching the songs melody at most.[Normal]
01:10:802 (1) - Start this spinner at the next white tick. Sounds better. Ok.
01:53:740 (1) - Same suggestion with adding a Finish. Ok.
Didn't mod taiko.
Pretty nice Collab there.
star
Thanks for your support.