YGOkid8 wrote:

modding at 4:13am ftw

Overall a pretty difficult mapset, but it's alright I think. Maniac was pretty fun, although, I personally would've liked to see more streams in, but that's a personal preference.

The only think that really should be changed is Maniac's hitcircle size. Make it smaller by 1, it's unnecessarily large atm. I also suggest increasing the OD by 1 as well.

soulfear wrote:

建議:
總體來說HITSOUND太小聲了...特別是MANIAC的那2段連打 加點鈴聲也好吧...加在紅線上

MANIAC:
00:17:564 (13) - 改成NOTE吧... 不想改了..
00:30:964 (3) - 結尾加鈴 added
00:31:264 (4) - 去掉鈴 done
00:58:364 (2,4) - 鈴改成紅線和白線...藍線取消掉... done
建議,用不用看你自己吧.

karenying wrote:

taken by #modreqs
Maniac
00:25:164 (6) - 头finish ?
01:05:564 (1) - 只是意見,01:05:464 (4,1) - 这里距離都x1.56了,不如干脆这串里每个NC渐加距離这样?(即是(4,1)加距離) no 不过改了点
01:05:964 (1) - 头finish k
01:20:364 (5) - NC k
01:50:764 (1) - 加finish如何? k

Hard
这难度的tick音是故意的?感觉不好听 oops忘记改回来了 fixed
01:18:764 (5) - finish k

没用的话不用给kd

Rukarioman wrote:

Easy:
- Okay Tick Rate 2 is way too spammy for Easy. I'd suggest using Tick 1 for Easy. Okay
00:35:564 (1,1) - Having notes so close after spinners in an Easy diff is difficult for beginners. Changed
01:29:964 (3) - The slidertick being in the hitcircle looks a bit ugly. lol

lF Style:
- Why is this Slider Velocity smaller than in Easy? Next time watch out with Guest diffs.
00:50:364 (5) - Maybe move this one 1/4 tick later? Nope

Hard:
01:10:964 (7,8) - Why use a different spacing for this all of a sudden? x.x fixed

Maniac:
01:04:364 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Why do you have a different spacing in all these streams? fixed
01:11:164 (3) - This slowdown is pretty hard to predict.It's a little longer than others..Though it's hard to read at playing

Kytoxid wrote:

[IF Style]

I assume this is Normal?

00:24:364 (1,2) - I recommend not having identical sliders with different speeds on any difficulty.
i understand, but the music leads me to map with a fast slider+a slow slider, so i really want to keep it.
00:40:564 (1,2,3,4) - For the first iteration, changing this to two sliders will help the player actually read the pattern.
i sacrifice readability here because the instrument stand out the most here so i think circles fit more (the similar paragraph at 43:764 and 46:964, that instrument is less obvious so mapped in different way)
01:09:164 (1,2,3,4) - Identical sliders shouldn't have different numbers of repeats consecutively either.
you're right, change (4) to 2 sliders
01:38:764 (1) - Dunno what this doublets part is following...
remapped a bit

other fix done:
01:37:164 (4) - left a grid
01:44:564 (1) - hitsound change to S:normal
Eh, it's a bit hard for a Normal, but not too hard that I'd be concerned, since you have an Easy.

Kytoxid wrote:

Taking over for the poor Rukarioman.

[General]

IF Style has a different source(fixed), and a random kiai fountain in the middle that the other diffs don't have.
Hard is missing mekadon in tags. fixed

The bright blue hurts the eyes a bit in kiai. Errr..

[Easy]

Can't say I'm a fan of the weird-shaped linear sliders.

00:09:964 (1,2) - I'd silence these two ticks, they're really loud. done
01:02:764 (3) - Make this symmetrical? Follow the rhythm so nothin change

It's structurally fine, but I didn't really like the looks.

[IF Style]

I assume this is Normal?

00:24:364 (1,2) - I recommend not having identical sliders with different speeds on any difficulty.
00:40:564 (1,2,3,4) - For the first iteration, changing this to two sliders will help the player actually read the pattern.
01:09:164 (1,2,3,4) - Identical sliders shouldn't have different numbers of repeats consecutively either.
01:38:764 (1) - Dunno what this doublets part is following...

Eh, it's a bit hard for a Normal, but not too hard that I'd be concerned, since you have an Easy.

[Hard]

00:06:764 (1) - This opener is really cool. :O
00:14:764 (1) - This part felt a bit messy, since the notes start appearing under hitbursts. fixed
01:09:164 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Space these out a bit, maybe even as jumps; this is really hard to read. fixed

This was a bit hard for a Hard too, at parts, but it played really well. I think it should be okay.

[Maniac]

00:16:364 (1) - I don't recommend having a stream like this. :P

Good, other than the fact that I can't FC it.

Kytoxid wrote:

lF style's source is still different. Please check over that.

Also, the maps in general are a bit too soft, especially sections at 30% or under, imo, since the hitsound blends into the music a bit too much.

Everything else looks okay.