1. Easy (2.01 stars, 101 notes)
2. Hard (4.86 stars, 215 notes)
3. Insane (5 stars, 279 notes)
4. Net's Taiko Oni (4.83 stars, 448 notes)
5. Normal (4.01 stars, 165 notes)
6. Sp3's Taiko (4.83 stars, 515 notes)

SPOILER

Marcin wrote:

[General]
Delete audio from video. no, actually the audio are not there at all, it was because i'm using the same name for both the audio and video,and because i'm using avi, the audio file are also played along with video when you play the video
Consider using .jpg instead of .png, picture quality is not that high to keep in *.png file. will cnahe it later
Slider tick - use 2 instead? thanks for reminding, i forgot to fix all tick into 2
[Easy]
00:11:926 (1,2,1) - how about, removing (1,2) and making spinner longer to first (1) position ? hey this is good
01:28:547 (1) - Too loud spinner? fix'd that last part by lowering the volume step by step
Looks really fine ~~
[Normal]
01:28:547 (1) - Too loud spinner? fix'd too
Looks good....
[Hard]
00:46:791 (6) - remove clap at the end? ~~suggestion yeah, also add it on the fifth hit
01:14:358 (7) - add clap at fifth hit? ~~suggestion yeah
WHY SO GOOD DIFFS, I CAN'T MAKE LONGER MOD POST... good...
[Insane]
Why start looks almost the same as Hard one ? Consider using other pattern at start. i'm do this since i think it would be ok to make a similar opening pattern for both diff, afterall the pattern are really match for the opening part with 1/4 beats :3
01:27:737 (9) - clap here? yes
01:27:939 (11) - ^ yes
01:28:142 (13) - ^ no, since im prefer that this part is better with just the finish hitsound :3
GOOD MAPSET 2 stars /o/

Bassio13 wrote:

RANDOM MOD!!

[General]
None...

[Easy]
00:26:520 (2) - Weird spacing! 0,61? fix'd the position, thanks for reminding :3
00:43:953 (3;1) - Add a note sure

[Normal]
00:11:926 (3) - Remove the slider and starts the spinner at this point yeah, i'm already think the same thing too since yesterday and i think that way is better.
00:58:345 (2) - Slider-waypoint at x=416/y=352 no, since i'm inted to make all slider shape in the neat form, i dont think if make the waypoint into the different position will make it better, instead, im fix'd the position of the next 3 notes after that slider :3

[Hard]
00:09:899 (4) - Distance spacing like the others OR new combo? ok, distance spacing
00:20:338 (5) - x=256/y=192 (²)
00:20:642 (6) - x=100/y=101 (²)
00:20:946 (7) - x=256/y=12 (²)
thanks for the notes position, been looking for the good position from the time i'm make this pattern T_T

[Insane]
Nothing... mmkay :3


(²): This change isn't required, but the this jumps confuse me @.@

A real good map! Hope it will get ranked! i'm glad you like it

145,205,575,1,2
102,272,777,1,0
152,334,980,1,0
225,304,1183,1,0
224,224,1385,1,2
367,179,1791,5,2
410,112,1994,1,0
360,50,2196,1,0
287,80,2399,1,0
288,160,2601,1,2

Loli Cjj wrote:

Oke

=Easy=
1. 00:52:466 (3,4,5,6,1) - Why not star pattern (wTTATT)w already tried, but cant find best position bro
2. 01:21:656 (1,2,3) - Surely needs fix because (3) has a longer distance to (1) than (2). Move to (332,104) i think it should be on 124 not 104
3. 01:23:277 (1,2,3) - Again, move (3). For now move it to (132,144) 244 bro =3=

=Normal=
1. 00:03:818 (1,2,3,4,5) - Star pattern should be neat (wTTATT)w Use create polygon circle. Look at the example, notes with blue border is the neat one, seriously. http://puu.sh/IBZJ d
2. 00:07:061 (1,2,3) - Again, make a neat triangle. Move (3) to (172,140) d
3. 00:08:683 (1,2,3) - And again. (3) to (408,240) d
4. 00:11:926 (1,1) - Not sure about it. I mean, honestly it was too fast! DX I prefer something like this, but this is only suggestion. http://puu.sh/IC3M fixd
5. 00:37:872 (1,2,3) - Why not create a slider pattern like this? http://puu.sh/IC8v I mean, even though this is normal, doesn't mean it doesn't have any sexy pattern, does it? Keep in mind that this is only suggestion, so you can leave it dead. Don't forget t remake the next notes if you change it to something better. ]because i'm lazy ass as you wish[/color]
6. 00:55:710 (3,4,5,6,1) - Again, neater >_< Use create polygon circle. It always helps. http://puu.sh/ICc3 mmkay
7. 01:08:683 (1) - Last point to (348,348) to make a curve based on approach circle. 348 330 bro

=Hard=
1. 00:00:575 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - What's that overlap DX This, I said, is better. http://puu.sh/ICgQ ah it's true

145,205,575,1,2
102,272,777,1,0
152,334,980,1,0
225,304,1183,1,0
224,224,1385,1,2
367,179,1791,5,2
410,112,1994,1,0
360,50,2196,1,0
287,80,2399,1,0
288,160,2601,1,2

2. 01:02:196 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - Nice concept but you may want to make it neater. Yeah, create polygon circle. mmkay
3. 01:06:047 (2,3) - How about pattern like this? http://puu.sh/ICxo i'll try this pattern for now
4. 01:13:953 (5,6,7,1) - Remake with help of create polygon circle. k

=Insane=
1. 00:00:575 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - First, neat this star pattern. Second, do something like hard, but with larger distance. You can try another variation, though. i'm intended to make the the first pattern similar with hard, also, since the intro are the calm part, i think make the spacing more far isn't really good for this pattern
2. 01:09:493 (3) - If you're not planning to make a blanket, make something like this. http://puu.sh/ICDq nice position
3. 01:14:662 (4) - Clap? Sounds better because there are a clap on 01:14:966 (7) - Another pattern is by putting clap at 01:14:358 (1,5) - im more prefer 1,4 and 7

Good luck.

Regou wrote:

Hi~ Request from In-Game PM~

[Modding guide]
Red: Unrankable stuff, you must fix it!
Black: Just suggestions.

[General]
Please full summit once, your preview BG is not showing right. im already did it several times, looks like it was the server problem not mine :O
Try to get some custom hitsound? not for now, since i wanna use the available hitsound from the default one to this mapset
Considering using tiny grid size when you map, it looks tidier sorry for that, since i'm not using it because usually i'm turn off the grid snap for the distance purpose, and also for the better hand movement while play because sometimes i dont like the current position from the grid snap feature

[Insane]
00:00:575 (1,2,3,4,5) - Not perfect Pentagon fix'd already
00:01:791 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ ^
00:03:818 (1) - Remove NC d
00:16:183 (4) - 1 grid left d
00:17:804 (4) - 2 grid up? d
00:20:338 (2) - 1 grid up? d
00:28:142 (1) - Add finish hitsound at start d
01:28:345 (1) - OMG Please slient this spinner >< already do that from the previous mod :O
Considering getting a harder one, this Insane diff is too easy i'm intended to make it this way (easy insane if ppl will say), since i don't wanna make something more hard while the song itself are not really the "rush" type/not suited with the "hard" insane

[Hard]
00:00:575 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - Same as Insane diff.fix'd already from the previous mod
00:01:385 (5) - Don't let this overlap 00:02:399 (4) too much, looks quite ugly >< same as above
00:08:480 (1) - Make this Blanketing the end of 00:07:872 (3)? [color=#0000FF]not for now, since i saw that both the pattern are overall good :3[/color]
00:16:791 (4) - NC? d
00:20:034 (4) - ^ d
01:03:412 (1,2,3,4,5) - Once again, Ugly pentagon fix'd from the previous mod
01:05:439 (1) - Add finish hitsound at start and remove this NC :/ done
01:07:061 (1) - NC? d
01:10:304 (5) - ^ d
01:09:088 (2) - Remove finish yeah
01:10:304 (1) - NC? d
01:16:791 (5) - ^ d
01:20:034 (6) - ^ d
01:23:277 (5) - ^ d

[Normal]
00:22:061 (2) - Clap
00:23:277 (4) - Add Clap on the reverse
00:24:899 (1) - Add Clap at the end
Please add more clap hitsound, not enough atm i know what you intended to, i'll work for it now
00:58:953 (1) - NC? d

[Easy]
00:11:926 (1) - Finish? d
01:00:980 (1) - It maybe too short for easy diff...remove this spinner? i dont think so, since the score of that spinner are already reach 4000 with auto, i think this spinner are already long enough (around 2-3 times spin for the normal people)
Same, please add more clap hitsound :< done

My mod may not be useful ><
Anyway good luck!

1. The video still has the audio element in it. Are you sure you want to keep it? Stripping the audio will reduce the filesize, so it's recommended to do this, but the decision's up to you.
2. ...Don't you think you're overusing Finish around the kiai time? Using a Finish every stanza should be fine there, since this song is pretty intense, but there's a lot of 1/1 and 2/1 Finishes going here...

1. 00:28:142 (4) - NC? I'm sure enough the song 'demands' it (new stanza, y'know), and there's not really any reason to make a combo this long here, anyway.
2. 00:43:953 (4) - Add Clap so 00:42:737 (3,4) will be similar with 00:41:115 (1,2)? It sounds far better anyway.

1. 01:21:656 (1) - Clap at the end? It feels empty without one.

1. 00:00:575 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - Only three polygons? I would prefer to simply use a linear snaky pattern here since I think it'll fit better, but eh, whatever.
2. 00:07:466 (2) - Whistle to emphasize the vocal?
3. 00:09:899 (4,1) - Swap NC? This is according to the vocal, yeah, but following the vocal seems to be the best bet for this spot.
4. 00:50:845 (1) - I'm sure enough this is supposed to be 1/1 instead of 3/4.
5. 00:57:331 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Use 1.3x DS for the 3/4 parts? Well, since this song mainly runs in 1/4s and 1/2s, the sudden appearance of 3/4s has a good chance to trip players if the DS is consistent (weird, I know, but this happens most of the time), and using a bigger DS would be better to handle that and will ensure better playability. I'm sure enough it's already explained somewhere on this forum...

1. 01:00:372 (6,7) - Can't you just simply stack them? I'm sure this spot would play better with that.

Hinsvar wrote:

Yo.

Let's get to mod this.

*Bolded = Unrankable/strongly suggested; red = Highly suggested/questionable (still weaker than the bolded ones); black = Minor suggestions/rants.

>General

1. The video still has the audio element in it. Are you sure you want to keep it? Stripping the audio will reduce the filesize, so it's recommended to do this, but the decision's up to you. as i said on the previous mod, it not because i dont delete it, but since the file is avi and it has the same filename with the mp3, the audio will be played along if you play the avi with media player
2. ...Don't you think you're overusing Finish around the kiai time? Using a Finish every stanza should be fine there, since this song is pretty intense, but there's a lot of 1/1 and 2/1 Finishes going here... i'm putting the finish like this since i'm intended to make it like that, to replacing the hitwhistle voice since it was pretty awkward if i put it on this kind of song, and also i found that using the finish patter like this also work welll (at least to me), so i'll keep it like this

>Easy

1. 00:28:142 (4) - NC? I'm sure enough the song 'demands' it (new stanza, y'know), and there's not really any reason to make a combo this long here, anyway.
2. 00:43:953 (4) - Add Clap so 00:42:737 (3,4) will be similar with 00:41:115 (1,2)? It sounds far better anyway.
   done both

>Normal

1. 01:21:656 (1) - Clap at the end? It feels empty without one. no, since i wanna make it consistent with the previous pattern with a similar form on this 01:08:683 (1,2,3,4) -

>Hard

1. 00:00:575 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - Only three polygons? I would prefer to simply use a linear snaky pattern here since I think it'll fit better, but eh, whatever. nah, i found this pattern are already attractive for the starter part, so i think this way is fine already
2. 00:07:466 (2) - Whistle to emphasize the vocal? no, since i'm wanna emphasize the instrument here rather than vocal
3. 00:09:899 (4,1) - Swap NC? This is according to the vocal, yeah, but following the vocal seems to be the best bet for this spot. mmkay
4. 00:50:845 (1) - I'm sure enough this is supposed to be 1/1 instead of 3/4. it can be work too that way, but since 00:51:149 - are already on the end slider part and 00:51:656 (3) - is using 3/4, i think use 3/4 for 00:50:845 (1) will form more actual consistency
5. 00:57:331 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Use 1.3x DS for the 3/4 parts? Well, since this song mainly runs in 1/4s and 1/2s, the sudden appearance of 3/4s has a good chance to trip players if the DS is consistent (weird, I know, but this happens most of the time), and using a bigger DS would be better to handle that and will ensure better playability. I'm sure enough it's already explained somewhere on this forum... 1,2DS for me

>Insane

1. 01:00:372 (6,7) - Can't you just simply stack them? I'm sure this spot would play better with that. a bit boring/unactractive if i stack it, so i keep it this way

...Okay, maybe just that.

Also, the song disappointed me, actually. I expected ALTIMA to at least make a song as epic as ONE, but this... *sigh* THIS IS A GOOD SONG DUDE D:

Good luck on the way

1. really great map!
2. 00:02:601 (5) - whistle..?
3. 00:50:439 (8,1) - symmetry..? maybe
4. 01:07:872 (7) - I think move to x:176 y:336 looks better...
5. 01:22:061 (2) - add clap?
6. 01:22:466 (3) -move to (40,112) to make the slider ends look better,,?
7. 01:23:683 (3) - add clap..?

1. 00:57:331 (1,3,5) - sounds better for clap on slider ends~
2. 01:06:453 (7,8) - why not like this o.o http://up.ppy.sh/files/screenshot987.jpg
3. 01:22:061 (2) - clap on head?
4. 01:23:683 (2) - ^
5. 01:24:899 (1,2) - add claps >_>

1. 00:46:994 (3,4) - remove claps o.o
2. 01:14:561 (6) - remove clap o.o don't think 3 claps in a row sound good

1. nice o.o

[CSGA]Ar3sgice wrote:

hi~


Insane

1. really great map!
2. 00:02:601 (5) - whistle..? if i do it, i need to remove the whistle on 00:02:196 (3) - , since i'm wanna make it consistent with put it each the downbeat, so i'm not changing this :3
3. 00:50:439 (8,1) - symmetry..? maybe fix'd
4. 01:07:872 (7) - I think move to x:176 y:336 looks better... yeah
5. 01:22:061 (2) - add clap? no, since i wanna emphasize this part, so if i'm putting more than 2 kind of hitsound there, it would be ruined the emphasize factor
6. 01:22:466 (3) -move to (40,112) to make the slider ends look better,,? done
7. 01:23:683 (3) - add clap..? no, for the same reason as above

Hard

1. 00:57:331 (1,3,5) - sounds better for clap on slider ends~ ah it's true sorry byakugan but i must agree with this, it was so much better on my ear T_T
2. 01:06:453 (7,8) - why not like this o.o http://up.ppy.sh/files/screenshot987.jpg agree
3. 01:22:061 (2) - clap on head? no with the same reason as on insane
4. 01:23:683 (2) - ^ same
5. 01:24:899 (1,2) - add claps >_> actually im already did so, but some player feels that it was a bit weird to put the clap with the beat on that 2 slider, so i'm remove it, maybe i'll put it back after some other mods later

Normal

1. 00:46:994 (3,4) - remove claps o.o only on 3, since i think with the way the rapper sang on that part, it was better if i do it clap-none-clap
2. 01:14:561 (6) - remove clap o.o don't think 3 claps in a row sound good agree

Easy

1. nice o.o okay :3

really great map, can't mod much >_< star, just rank it >_< yea if i have a big connection with everyone in this community, i think i would do that already >_<

Accel world <3 <3

1. Red text means that the issue is unrankable.
2. Blue text is a strongly recommended suggestion.
3. Black text is a regular suggestion.

1. Good

1. You have a lot of finishes in the chorus, which makes my ears go ><. You should reduce them a bit.

1. Same about the finishes here as in easy.
2. 00:16:385 (4) - Move this 1 gridlvl3 to the right.

1. 00:07:061 (1) - Remove whistle from end.
2. 00:07:466 (2) - Add whistle on start.
3. 00:10:304 (2,3) - Whistles on repeats?
4. 00:59:764 (7,8) - Just my preference, but maybe have the claps only at 01:00:169 and 01:00:372?
5. 01:14:764 (8,1) - This is a bit hard to read, and it's also a small 1/4 jump. You could try something like this http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/372732
6. 01:28:446 (1) - Spinner should start at 01:28:243 imo.

1. 00:20:642 (3) - Move the endpoint to x:48 y:224 is better imo.
2. 00:35:034 (2) - ctrl+shift+R. Choose selection center and put it at -15. Then move the slider to x:88 y:224.
3. 00:38:277 (2) - You can do the same type of this as above, although, if you want to keep these, do that. I wont point them out anymore. i just like when stuff changes gradually xD.
4. 00:47:602 (1) - Finish on start.
5. 01:09:088 (2) - Move to x:240 y:176?
6. 01:27:331 (5) - Optional, but you can add a new combo here if you don't want long combos.
7. 01:28:446 (1) - Same as Hard.

CXu wrote:

Hi~
Accel World >_<~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

I'd prefer that you quote my post and state which changes you make, and which you have not. Thanks~
If you have any problems understanding what the hell I'm talking about, feel free to poke me in-game!

[Color guide]

1. Red text means that the issue is unrankable.
2. Blue text is a strongly recommended suggestion.
3. Black text is a regular suggestion.

[General]

1. Good

[Easy]

1. You have a lot of finishes in the chorus, which makes my ears go ><. You should reduce them a bit. for that huge finish sound, i'm intended to make it like that from the start to make the song have more vibrancy on the chorus part, since i think putting another hitsounds are not really stand much like the finish sound provided yet.

Other than me disliking that many finishes in the chorus, the map itself is great, and I don't really have anything to say. Good job! thanks!

[Normal]

1. Same about the finishes here as in easy. [/color]
2. 00:16:385 (4) - Move this 1 gridlvl3 to the right. done

Just one nazi spacing. Stop making good maps I can't mod xD lol

[Hard]

1. 00:07:061 (1) - Remove whistle from end. [/color]
2. 00:07:466 (2) - Add whistle on start. [color=#0000FF]no, since in this part, i wanna follow the instrument voice rather than the singer, which is "high-low-high" from 00:07:061 (1,2,3) - if you hear it carefully[/color]
3. 00:10:304 (2,3) - Whistles on repeats? actually it was already on there b4, but some modders say that it was kinda awkward to put it on that tick, so i remove it. But looks like i'm prefer to put the whistle there afterall
4. 00:59:764 (7,8) - Just my preference, but maybe have the claps only at 01:00:169 and 01:00:372? sounds good
5. 01:14:764 (8,1) - This is a bit hard to read, and it's also a small 1/4 jump. You could try something like this actually it was from byakugan's suggestion to make the pattern like that, but i kinda like the one that you suggest here http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/372732
6. 01:28:446 (1) - Spinner should start at 01:28:243 imo. no, since the vocal voice are still going until 01:28:446 - , so i think that make the spinner start from that timing would be more match with the song itself

That's it, mostly just a few hitsound suggestions.

[Insane]

1. 00:20:642 (3) - Move the endpoint to x:48 y:224 is better imo. fix'd
2. 00:35:034 (2) - ctrl+shift+R. Choose selection center and put it at -15. Then move the slider to x:88 y:224. done
3. 00:38:277 (2) - You can do the same type of this as above, although, if you want to keep these, do that. I wont point them out anymore. i just like when stuff changes gradually xD. i'm agree with you for this part, rotate the slider to clockwise a bit
4. 00:47:602 (1) - Finish on start. thanks for noticing^^
5. 01:09:088 (2) - Move to x:240 y:176? done
6. 01:27:331 (5) - Optional, but you can add a new combo here if you don't want long combos. add it there for now
7. 01:28:446 (1) - Same as Hard. no changes for the same reason :3

Yeah, it played perfectly when I tested it, so you can probably treat everything here as suggestions xD

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Sorry for kinda useless mod Good luck! nah, it's quite helpful^^
Bad modpost is bad

L_P wrote:

hello

Insane
seems like you dont have unrankable issue o.o so...suggestion only

why not try using slower velocity for front part? (calm moment there) 0.75 or 0.8 is fine for me .. i can do that, but, since i'm already make the spacing on the opening part with 0,8, i think that alone can cover the slow speed movement to give the calm moment more feel

00:03:007 (1,2,3,4) -

http://puu.sh/IXIq

as you see, 1 stack with last note 5 (just to emphasize the change in melody, and create some stopping feel for note 1) forthis pattern, i can see that it was quite intuitive, but i'm a bit don't like pattern direction when played, also since i still cant find the better position for that pattern, so i think i'm not change that part for now :3

00:08:683 (1,2,3) - ctrl + J and adjust the angle / shape a bit ? (because the tone goes down ↓↓↓) aah, for this part, i'm following the instrument rather than the vocal, and as you hear on that part, the instrument volu8me are getting louder step by step on that part (reversed with the vocal voice. And also i find that the flow on that part are quite better if i make it go up than down

00:41:926 (2) - head clap? no, since i feel that it was quite awkward when i hear that slider with both of the point with clap

01:23:987 - add note?? no, because i wanna make more emphasize with the vocal rhythm there

01:26:824 - ^ no, because i wanna make it a tap pattern, for the preparation from the longstream after that.

01:27:331 (5) - NC already do that on cxu's mod :3

Hard

00:41:926 (2,8) - i think these finishes are noisy..maybe 40 %? (just thinking that these 2 are unnecessary in hard diff, because when rhythm is slow, it is very obvious.. i don't that the finish sound are really noisy at all, since i'm set the finish on the same position as the others diff, to make it more consistent for each diff

01:27:331 (7) - NC ok

Normal
00:11:115 (2) - swap whistle from head to tail? it sounded a bit too regular in 2/4 pattern... sounds good

00:33:818 (4) - NC? (123 is the vocal orz) yeah

Easy

00:27:737 (3) - clap?

00:37:466 (4) - ^

00:40:710 (3) - ^

00:47:196 (4) - swap clap to finish?
done all

thats o