User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
6,611 posts
Offline
Just add some system about this on osu! ???
Not submission but technically...
Nah, I don't work just for position
User avatar
Beatmap Appreciation Team
3,661 posts
Offline
Until now, we added title extension for specifying its length easily, not for following the real title.
Maybe length shown in game can specify the music. But we don't know whether there exist Full ver. or not through the length.
I really don't see big problem with thing that we did until now.

As arken1015 said, adding some system might be a good solution.
Have any ideas?
User avatar
Beatmap Appreciation Team
4,221 posts
Offline
merchat7 wrote:
Overall, I'm still confused. I have seen countless time in official video and official album that the titles are different, which one should be followed? I also do not understand why only tv size is being kept, I don't think I've seen tv size in any anime opening/ending or in any ost yet except for maybe titles of some youtube video and that's it. Let's just say, the amount of time I've seen tv size is around the same amount as the times I've seen short ver.(ost/theme song/maxi single)

Basically:
-Why is tv size being kept?
-What is a real official title?
Please also make this more clear in the respective sections (osu wiki, this post...) for less confusion in the future.

for TV Size, it has been used for a long time in our history, and there're already many players choosing maps by this. as full version of OP/ED usually get mapped, it does be a effective way to let us tell the difference between them.

second point, if you find the title in PV and CD booklet different, they should be both acceptable. I'd suggest using the one which is different from other versions' though

about the system for this messed things, I think showing the length of the longest diff in the map list would help in searching, and even the titles are the same, it's still easy for players to get what they need
'Where's my apple?'

其实是老变态.
User avatar
Global Moderator
3,661 posts
Offline
From the wiki

Refrain from using Short, Full, or Cut Ver. in your map title unless the extension is listed in the song's original title. Refer to Wikipedia, Google, or the album track list to confirm.
Image
Image
User avatar
Beatmap Appreciation Team
3,661 posts
Offline
ztrot wrote:
From the wiki

Refrain from using Short, Full, or Cut Ver. in your map title unless the extension is listed in the song's original title. Refer to Wikipedia, Google, or the album track list to confirm.

According to its logic, also TV Size must be removed.

EDIT : OK, I understand what this means.
It seems the video(OP/ED) can't be supporting evidence.
Last edited by ykcarrot on , edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Global Moderator
3,661 posts
Offline
did you not read this part? unless the extension is listed in the song's original title almost every TV size has this in it's song title for real
Image
Image
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
1,866 posts
Offline
This map previously had the Short Ver. title until a MAT went in and asked that it be removed.

In actual fact the original title is "XXX half chorus Ver." http://vgmdb.net/album/30869
So what's the recommended action now?
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
4,742 posts
Offline
Okay, I have to ask about some example like for kors k vs. L.E.D. - SOLID STATE SQUAD
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/15630
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/27148

I never played beatmania, but how should we handle with them?

Another example is fripside - future gazer
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/23102
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/33575

There is also something with Yousei Teikoku - Kuusou Mesorogiwi, but it is the same as the second example.
They are already ranked, I know, but for the future if this happens again, what does the creator have to do?
User avatar
Beatmap Appreciation Team
3,389 posts
Offline
Honestly, the status quo was much better than this.
Too many grey area maps that arose from this change.
Image
User avatar
Beatmap Appreciation Team
7,716 posts
Offline
NoHitter wrote:
Honestly, the status quo was much better than this.
Too many grey area maps that arose from this change.


What's so hard about researching it in whichever source you have?, it's as black and white as if it's in the official title = yes, if it's not = no
These wounds i bear will never heal
and even if they do heal
the scar will remain
and nothing will ever be the same
User avatar
Beatmap Appreciation Team
3,389 posts
Offline
Grey areas:

NoHitter wrote:
So if I have a 2:30 version of a song, and a 4:30 version of a song, with this new rule, I can no longer differentiate between them?
Image
User avatar
Beatmap Appreciation Team
1,915 posts
Offline
NoHitter wrote:
So if I have a 2:30 version of a song, and a 4:30 version of a song, with this new rule, I can no longer differentiate between them?


Easy.

1. Add 'Short' to the tags to aid those searching for Short versions
2. Look at the Total Time / Draining Time information provided on the site.
Pending Maps
-> Big Giant Circles feat. some1namedjeff - Thunderstruck
Ranked Maps
Approved Maps
Check my user page for modding rules
If you liked my mod, don't forget to give me kudosu!
User avatar
Beatmap Appreciation Team
3,389 posts
Offline
Having it in the title is more convenient though.
The beatmap listing doesn't exactly have the draining time/tags listed.
Image
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
2,199 posts
Offline
NoHitter wrote:
Grey areas:

NoHitter wrote:
So if I have a 2:30 version of a song, and a 4:30 version of a song, with this new rule, I can no longer differentiate between them?

Good luck with submitting it.
User avatar
Global Moderator
3,661 posts
Offline
xsrsbsns wrote:
This map previously had the Short Ver. title until a MAT went in and asked that it be removed.

In actual fact the original title is "XXX half chorus Ver." http://vgmdb.net/album/30869
So what's the recommended action now?


then you would use what is in the legit title I'm not seeing the confusion here it is quite simple
Image
Image
Reply 88 posts jump | prev  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6  next

Users browsing this forum: None


Jump to: