Have you guys ever tried dancing on a song you disgustingly hate? Ya, that's how it felt like playing Aha! Great dancing moves, but terrible terrible song to dance on. I don't hardly call that a pleasant gaming experience.
Yes, I'm claiming that the game play is what determines the quality and this is why it's so subjective. I would not blame for people who enjoys the song Aha! (Sang by whoever it is) and votes for Aha!
But Aha! is one of the prime example of people's hatred for a bad song. The thread itself shows how much people really hated the beatmap. It's really hard for us to just accept that Aha! is voted for one of the best beatmaps, while we call that beatmap to be one of the worst beatmaps. So please don't try to argue us to just plainly accept the result. We hated it and we still hate it.
Even though I'm retardly late for this, but I just wanted to have my comment on the result.