This is a BSS beatmap submission. Click here to view full beatmap information.
None
User avatar
Star Shooter
211 posts
Offline
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 30 ноября 2017 г. at 10:58:07

Artist: Memme
Title: Geurida
Source: O2Jam U
Tags: lee eun jin seiyun korean missing you electronic oriental drumstep sing lowcombofc lcfc sulfur su1fu7
BPM: 180
Filesize: 4299kb
Play Time: 02:34
Difficulties Available:

Download: Memme - Geurida
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
Image

Thanks Sing for the mp3, bg and his diff <3

Also thanks LowComboFC and Sulfur for awesome GDs
Thanks to den0saur for source and tags
Banner by -halfy-

Source
https://soundcloud.com/parkmemme/150302a
meta prove by Doyak
Last edited by NeilPerry on , edited 20 times in total.
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
2,424 posts
Offline
No kudosu yet.
User avatar
Beatmap Nominator
3,343 posts
Offline
Earned 2 kudosu.
v1 modding (I don't like v2.. welp)

~Easy~

  • 00:05:679 (2) - You forgot to add Normal finish on this slider's tail, add it to be consistent with 00:03:679 (2) -
  • 00:12:679 (1) - Remove whistle from tail like the previous sliders (just apply the same hitsounding carefully please);
  • 01:11:679 (2) - Just make it curved? This shape is ugly to see and it ruins the flow, same for 01:19:679 (2) - ;
  • 01:22:679 (1,2) - Extend them by 1/2, the sound on the white tick is more intense than the one on red tick. Also, it would make the rhythm much easier to play and follow because of 2/1 rhythm;
  • 01:42:013 (1) - If you really want to keep this shape, make it symmetric, at least. This one is better than those mentioned before because new section is starting here and it doesn't break any flow you created on the previous section, so it's ok, but make it symmetrical;
  • 01:47:013 (1) - Make this blanket better;
  • 01:53:013 (1) - Well, you know.. this is the same for all next similar sliders;
  • 01:58:346 (4,1) - This kind of pattern is hard to control for newbies, so you should make something easier to play and read;
  • 02:27:679 (2) - Out of screen;
  • 02:32:679 (1,2) - Make a better blanket;

~Sulfur's Normal~

  • 00:10:679 (4) - There are some mistakes about comboing in this section. Add NC here, remove it on 00:11:679 (1) - and add it on 00:12:346 (2) - and so on. To be clear, just focus the comboing by checking the previous part where the NCs are set 1/2 earlier than downbeats;
  • 00:16:179 (2) - I would avoid to map this slider by skipping the white tick with that strong sound on it. I would just remove this slider and extend the 00:15:679 (1) - by 1/2 and add a circle on that white tick, following the same logic of 00:16:679 (3,4) - : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9570942
  • 00:18:679 (3,1) - Switch NCs;
  • 00:24:679 (1) - Mh.. This part is still calm, so it should follow the same logic of previous section by using a simpler rhythm instead than this 1/1 spam. Just make this part easier with some breaks and use 1/1 only on the next part at 00:34:679 (1) - that is kinda more intense;
  • 01:47:013 (2,3,4) - Hard pattern to read for a Normal diff, make it easier by unstacking the slider and fixing the spacing after applied it;

~Hard~


I will stop modding the mapset here, but I will give you general tips.
Rhythm you guys used isn't that bad but you should try to be consistent between parts and I gave you examples of what I intend with the points I mentioned above in the modpost. The reason I won't mod it all is: the flow. The mapset is poor of flow: weird sliders' shapes usage makes the flow just messy and not confortable to play and not enjoyable to see while playing the map. Focus more on blankets, on simpler sliders and on technical/intuitive patterns. All the sliders I saw (especially in the Hard diff) look just weird with waypoints placed randomly on the grid. So yea, this mapset needs more work on structure, patterns, but especially the flow. Try to focus your attention on the cursor movement while you are mapping and it will help you a lot to make flowing and intuitive patterns to play. I hope this will help you. Good luck homie!
User avatar
Star Shooter
211 posts
Offline
Chewin wrote:
v1 modding (I don't like v2.. welp)

~Easy~

  • 00:05:679 (2) - You forgot to add Normal finish on this slider's tail, add it to be consistent with 00:03:679 (2) -
  • 00:12:679 (1) - Remove whistle from tail like the previous sliders (just apply the same hitsounding carefully please);
  • 01:11:679 (2) - Just make it curved? This shape is ugly to see and it ruins the flow, same for 01:19:679 (2) - ; this fully structured 01:11:679 (2,1) - dont see anything non aesthetical tbh owo
  • 01:22:679 (1,2) - Extend them by 1/2, the sound on the white tick is more intense than the one on red tick. Also, it would make the rhythm much easier to play and follow because of 2/1 rhythm;ya i know, but wanted keep vocal emphazing as i doing whole map
  • 01:42:013 (1) - If you really want to keep this shape, make it symmetric, at least. This one is better than those mentioned before because new section is starting here and it doesn't break any flow you created on the previous section, so it's ok, but make it symmetrical; shouldnt be symmetrical it's just simple stuff cant understand cleary whats wrong with it D:
  • 01:47:013 (1) - Make this blanket better; the main idea of using thats kind of movement to keep it not perfectly blanket, just keep it perfectly symmetrical, that head and tail of slider 1 absolutely symmetrical and catch sliderend of previous slider in the middle
  • 01:53:013 (1) - Well, you know.. this is the same for all next similar sliders; ya i explained
  • 01:58:346 (4,1) - This kind of pattern is hard to control for newbies, so you should make something easier to play and read; saw stuff like this in 54904584375 kinds of easy diffs. hope it can work
  • 02:27:679 (2) - Out of screen;
  • 02:32:679 (1,2) - Make a better blanket; i explained my blanket conception for this kind of stuff

~Hard~

  • 00:01:846 (2) - Full covered reverse arrow is unrankable because unreadable;
  • 00:12:679 (1,2) - Why this sudden change of rhythm? Keep using the same sliders of before; jsut wanted make more impact on this
  • 00:54:346 (3) - Make the reverse arrow easier to read, same for 00:56:346 (2) - and all next ones I guess; it's well readable tbh
  • 01:26:013 (1) - This slider should be emphasized by a little jump and this stack just ruins it to be honest; im keeping that concept whole all map. tbh it's not reasonable to make jump cuz after this slider gameplay stops
  • 02:34:013 (1) - Same hereya

I will stop modding the mapset here, but I will give you general tips.
Rhythm you guys used isn't that bad but you should try to be consistent between parts and I gave you examples of what I intend with the points I mentioned above in the modpost. The reason I won't mod it all is: the flow. The mapset is poor of flow: weird sliders' shapes usage makes the flow just messy and not confortable to play and not enjoyable to see while playing the map. Focus more on blankets, on simpler sliders and on technical/intuitive patterns. All the sliders I saw (especially in the Hard diff) look just weird with waypoints placed randomly on the grid. So yea, this mapset needs more work on structure, patterns, but especially the flow. Try to focus your attention on the cursor movement while you are mapping and it will help you a lot to make flowing and intuitive patterns to play. I hope this will help you. Good luck homie! kinda disagree with that position cuz flow movements works well. mby it looks kinda weird of unnormal shapes which i used but overall it's works. Anyway thanks a lot <3


No reply - fixed
Thanks a lot!
User avatar
Star Shooter
210 posts
Offline
No kudosu yet.
Chewin wrote:
v1 modding (I don't like v2.. welp)

~Sulfur's Normal~

  • 00:10:679 (4) - There are some mistakes about comboing in this section. Add NC here, remove it on 00:11:679 (1) - and add it on 00:12:346 (2) - and so on. To be clear, just focus the comboing by checking the previous part where the NCs are set 1/2 earlier than downbeats; nah i think NCs are okay, since im doing NCs every two downbeats
  • 00:16:179 (2) - I would avoid to map this slider by skipping the white tick with that strong sound on it. I would just remove this slider and extend the 00:15:679 (1) - by 1/2 and add a circle on that white tick, following the same logic of 00:16:679 (3,4) - : https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9570942 make sense, fixed
  • 00:18:679 (3,1) - Switch NCs; alright
  • 00:24:679 (1) - Mh.. This part is still calm, so it should follow the same logic of previous section by using a simpler rhythm instead than this 1/1 spam. Just make this part easier with some breaks and use 1/1 only on the next part at 00:34:679 (1) - that is kinda more intense; fixed some stuff here and there, should be good now
  • 01:47:013 (2,3,4) - Hard pattern to read for a Normal diff, make it easier by unstacking the slider and fixing the spacing after applied it sure


Thanks for mod : )
This is a BSS beatmap submission. Click here to view full beatmap information.
View Discussion & modding

Users browsing this forum: None


Jump to: