1. Futsuu (2.67 stars, 120 notes)
2. Kantan (0.83 stars, 88 notes)
3. Muzukashii (4.42 stars, 200 notes)
4. Oni (4.94 stars, 388 notes)
5. urane's Catch Platter (4.93 stars, 255 notes)
6. Wmf's Taiko (4.89 stars, 571 notes)

Your message is too short. Please do not post messages like "star", and make sure you are constructively adding to the thread in question.

wmfchris wrote:

~

Your message is too short. Please do not post messages like "star", and make sure you are constructively adding to the thread in question.

._______.

spboxer3 wrote:

Hi~best Taikosu mapper >_<~
I like this song~I like Naruto. so I hope I can help you mod some~

[general]

• 
  

1. letterbox during break need disable

[Kantan]

1. 00:52:576 (4) - maybe use clap is better Normal ((and I really think k is fit in this way
2. 01:04:283 (5) - ^
3. 01:07:210 (5) - ^

[Futsuu]

1. 00:17:820 (6) - maybe let it like ↓ can be more pretty
   
   photo

   
   If you think yes~ then I give some code
   

   392,120,17820,2,0,B|392:40|256:16|128:40|128:120|128:120|128:304,1,504

2. 00:22:027 (3,4,5) - uneven spacing [nazi]
3. 00:37:210 (2) - clap ?
4. 00:40:137 (2) - ^
5. 00:43:064 (2) - ^
6. 00:59:161 (1,1) - too close rhythm in normal
7. 01:04:283 (5) - clap ?
8. 01:05:747 (2) - projectin hitsound~ maybe change another one will be better
9. 01:15:990 (6) - maybe use newcombo 0.0? because 8 combo is too high for Normal...

[Muzukashii]

• 
  

1. use unnecessary line: 00:51:844 - ((BPM:328 but you can use green line x2.0

1. 00:50:747 (2) - stack on 00:50:015 (9) - look be better ;_;
2. 01:04:648 (10,1) - change combo~ [(10) add combo (1) remove new combo]
3. 01:07:575 (10,1) - ^
4. 01:13:794 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - maybe it's not good pattern it's too stright...

[Oni]

• 
  

1. 01:17:637 (5,4) - It's tap to HPBar~ need fix it

[wmf's Taiko]

• 
  

1. Remove
   [Events]
   //Background and Video events
   Video,-100,"whatrob.avi"

1. 00:34:100 (222) - use k ?

red is unrankable issue. bule is need to discuss. Black is just suggest.

That's all~
good lucky
star~

Wiinter wrote:

ohai~ modding as requested

[Futsuu]
00:17:454 (5,6) - remove (5) and start the slider at that point? sounds better imo D: On (5), there's no sign for long voice but just vocal cut ;_;
00:49:283 (5), 00:52:210 (5), 00:55:136 (5) - they all sound a bit.. weird idk @_@ i'd suggest adding a note 1/2 earlier in all of them, but it'd still sound a bit odd due to the "silence" after the slider, so yeah. These are just for vocal handling sliders and they would work for vocal ;_; And adding 1/2 note might be little hard for some people orz

[Muzukashii]
00:49:283 (7,8) - imo, sounds better if you add a note at 00:49:466 and instead of the slider at 00:49:649, just placing a note at 00:49:832 (or removing the note at 00:50:015 and moving the slider to 00:49:832 (aka like http://puu.sh/cmzR or http://puu.sh/cmA1) (8) is just for drum beats away from vocal orz so sorry orz
01:09:588 (7) - add a repeat here? Long voice on (7) ends without repeat length so sorry orz
01:22:026 (x) - add a note here? Okay, there's no rejection from me so okay :3

[Oni]
00:36:478 (4) - *nazi* align with the previous note? Oops! thanks :3
00:48:003 (x) - add a note here? Oni is generally based on drum beats and there's no beat for this part so sorry orz

that's all~

BeatofIke wrote:

Request from my modding queue.

[General]
- Your offset is off. Should be 595. Actually if do this, offset would be more off orz. Tested and orz
- Re-size both of your BG (test_789.jpeg and llllllllll.jpeg) to 800 x 600. There's too many ranked mapsets with 640*480 BG so it doesn't matter I think orz

[Kantan] Okay

[Futsuu] Okay

[Muzukashii] Okay. I can see why the OD is 4 because of that short spinner.

[Oni]
-Reduce Drain Rate to 7? Yup :3

-To be honest, this map is already good enough for a bubble. I could not find anything wrong with your map in any difficulty. This map
deserves a STAR!

1. >.mp3 filename: damn love
   
   Can I laugh over this? Everything else is fine, though.

1. I know, you have told us (the modders) to not tell you to add notes... but there's just too much place that feels too quiet without them for this particular beatmap. Maybe add one or two for each fitting place? If you don't want though, I don't really care. You're the mapper after all (Fun fact: Even after I played this with HR+DT, I still think that this beatmap is easier than most Easy maps without those mods )
2. 00:29:893 (1,2) - Uh... can you explain why is the notes' pattern designed like this?

1. Fine.

1. This one's fine, too.

1. 01:10:685 (8) - Move to 01:10:594?
2. 01:14:801 (7,8) - Move by one 1/4 tick to the left?

Hinsvar wrote:

"Lovers"? Do you know how much I love this song?

Fine. I'll just start the mod.

*Usual note: Gold ones are a must-do. Yes, I'm playing with my avatar. Everything in red are things that look awkward to me (subjective suggestions; you can follow my lead here or not); everything else are rants and minor suggestions to make things look cooler.

>General

1. >.mp3 filename: damn love
   
   Can I laugh over this? Everything else is fine, though.

>Kantan

1. I know, you have told us (the modders) to not tell you to add notes... but there's just too much place that feels too quiet without them for this particular beatmap. Maybe add one or two for each fitting place? If you don't want though, I don't really care. You're the mapper after all (Fun fact: Even after I played this with HR+DT, I still think that this beatmap is easier than most Easy maps without those mods ) Actually, current of [Easy] diffs are not felt like easy diffs for beginners orz So, that's why I made like this orz
2. 00:29:893 (1,2) - Uh... can you explain why is the notes' pattern designed like this? Ahh, fixed :3

>Futsuu

1. Fine.

>Muzukashii

1. This one's fine, too.

>Oni

1. 01:10:685 (8) - Move to 01:10:594? As sync'd as lyric ;_;
2. 01:14:801 (7,8) - Move by one 1/4 tick to the left? As sync'd as lyric ;_;

'Kay, that should be enough. Might be able to get ranked pretty fast. (The mapper's a MAT anyway; this should be expected )

Good luck on the way

Tanmak wrote:

I can't find any problem..

But, In [Muzukashii]..why set volume down there in middle?

arien666 wrote:

DO NOT SUGGEST NOTE ADDING OR HITSOUNDS except non-authentic issues

1. 00:16:722 (2) - This note should be at 00:16:539 because not following the music. But if moving this note to red line, it's difficult for newbie to hit. So It's better to put a slider at 00:16:539 and end it at 00:17:088 if you'll fix this.
2. 01:15:258 (2) - ^
3. 01:21:112 (2) - ^

1. 00:17:820 (6) - Hmm...this end is...kinda weird. Should be ended at 00:20:764. If you think there aren't enough time to next note, 00:20:198 fits the music too because of guitar sound.
2. 00:58:612 (7) - This formation looks not so beautiful. How about the one like below?
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 01:00:624 (1,2) - I think normal-player will misread as there is only 1/4-beat-time between these two notes. Try not to stack them.
4. 01:10:868 (1) - Same suggestion on this slider as Muzukashii's.
5. 01:26:782 (x) - I heard a sound here too in the back. Try to add a note if possible. (If you fix this, I think hitting five circles is difficult to normal-player so need to change a pattern.)

1. 00:06:112 (9) - Add a repeat to follow the vocal? I think it won't break the sound in taiko mode. If you fix this, also have to change the formation, maybe.
2. 00:09:039 (9) - ^ please consider about same stuff after this too as well.
3. 00:12:332 (1) - Yeah I know why you put this slider. But, it doesn't follow the music. A repeat on 00:13:612 is weird, and a sound should be added at 00:13:795.
4. 00:17:820 (3) - ^ same problem here. By the way, this overlapping looks not so good. How about the one like below? (Ctrl+Shift+R then rotate by 22°)
   
   SPOILER

   
5. 00:35:381 (x) - Can't put a stream from here to (1)?
6. 01:10:867 (1) - Same stuff here as 00:12:332 (1).
7. 01:16:721 (1) - Oh, this one follows the music well!
8. 01:26:782 (x) - I heard a sound here too in the back. Try to add a note if possible.

• 
  Just one stuff.

1. 01:27:149 (2,3) - Since this jump is wide, it makes reading the timing of next note(01:27:881 (1)) very difficult. Try to stack with 01:26:417 (1).

Suzully wrote:

From my modding queue.

arien666 wrote:

DO NOT SUGGEST NOTE ADDING OR HITSOUNDS except non-authentic issues

Yeah, you can ignore the points of my mod about these if they don't fit in taiko mode.

[Kantan]

1. 00:16:722 (2) - This note should be at 00:16:539 because not following the music. But if moving this note to red line, it's difficult for newbie to hit. So It's better to put a slider at 00:16:539 and end it at 00:17:088 if you'll fix this.
2. 01:15:258 (2) - ^
3. 01:21:112 (2) - ^

All fixed as moving into red orz

[Futsuu]

1. 00:17:820 (6) - Hmm...this end is...kinda weird. Should be ended at 00:20:764. If you think there aren't enough time to next note, 00:20:198 fits the music too because of guitar sound. Followed as 2nd thing :3
2. 00:58:612 (7) - This formation looks not so beautiful. How about the one like below? Okay :3
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 01:00:624 (1,2) - I think normal-player will misread as there is only 1/4-beat-time between these two notes. Try not to stack them. Moved :3
4. 01:10:868 (1) - Same suggestion on this slider as Muzukashii's. Done :3
5. 01:26:782 (x) - I heard a sound here too in the back. Try to add a note if possible. (If you fix this, I think hitting five circles is difficult to normal-player so need to change a pattern.) It is just for guitar base sound, not for minimum volume so sorry orz

[Muzukashii]

1. 00:06:112 (9) - Add a repeat to follow the vocal? I think it won't break the sound in taiko mode. If you fix this, also have to change the formation, maybe. It breaks the sound on Taiko mod ;___; If add 1 more return, it would be shown as +1 circle note
2. 00:09:039 (9) - ^ please consider about same stuff after this too as well. ^
3. 00:12:332 (1) - Yeah I know why you put this slider. But, it doesn't follow the music. A repeat on 00:13:612 is weird, and a sound should be added at 00:13:795. Adjusted volume so 13:612 one is silenced :3
4. 00:17:820 (3) - ^ same problem here. By the way, this overlapping looks not so good. How about the one like below? (Ctrl+Shift+R then rotate by 22°) Re-shaped and moved :3 Also, adjusted sound :3
   
   SPOILER

   
5. 00:35:381 (x) - Can't put a stream from here to (1)? No sorry, it is just Hard difficulty ;___;
6. 01:10:867 (1) - Same stuff here as 00:12:332 (1). Done :3
7. 01:16:721 (1) - Oh, this one follows the music well! meow :3
8. 01:26:782 (x) - I heard a sound here too in the back. Try to add a note if possible. Same as [Futsuu] sorry orz

[Oni]

• 
  Just one stuff.

1. 01:27:149 (2,3) - Since this jump is wide, it makes reading the timing of next note(01:27:881 (1)) very difficult. Try to stack with 01:26:417 (1). Actually, it is tended but whatever :3 Fixed

That's it!
Oni is well mapped but others still need more works imo. Try to get more mods and then call me back to recheck.
Anyway support TaikOsu +1.