159 posts jump | prev  1 ... 7, 8, 9, 10, 11  next
This is a feature request. Feature requests can be voted up by supporters.
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
12,613 posts
Offline
GhostFrog wrote:
no


Also, custimisable map-settings are a different request
User avatar
Beat Clicker
60 posts
Offline
Lybydose wrote:
There are a number of reasons for this:

1) The approach rate. This is the biggest reason. Most players, even new players, find faster approach rate easier than slower approach rate (to a certain point around 6-7 or so). Cutting the approach rate in half on harder maps is a HUGE change. Most Hard/Insane maps become completely unreadable because there are SO MANY circles on the screen at once.
It took me a while but I have learnt how to play EZ mod and I believe that the low AR is the main reason why I play it.

2) Increased circle size. This usually makes it easier, but in a lot of situations it causes really confusing overlapping. Coupled with (1), the map is even more difficult to read.
Once again once you adjust to it the notes do get easier to hit imo.

3) Decreased overall difficulty. Yes, really. In osu!, you can't hit a note until the previous note either been hit or missed. By "missed", I mean that too much time has passed that you are no longer in the hit window to get a 50 on the note. A massive decrease in overall difficulty on harder maps makes the hit window for a note overlap with the "exact timing" of the next note in many cases. What this means is that if you misclick a note, yet hit the next one perfectly, you often miss it too because the previous note is still "active" and the note you clicked just "shakes", even though you hit it perfectly. You end up missing an entire chain of notes because of one misclick.
Agree

4) 3 life system. This doesn't actually make it harder, but it isn't implemented very well. It's incredibly difficult to resume playing after starting on the next life. Why? There's a completely unrhythmic amount of time spent waiting for the life bar to fill up again; it's impossible to tell exactly when you're supposed to start playing again. I think there's a button to skip this, but I have no idea what it is. The only reason I think this is because sometimes it immediately starts playing again without a wait. I've tried just about every logical button to intentionally skip it, and I've never managed to trigger it. Usually if I "fail" a map with Easy the first time (which is common thanks to (1) (2) and (3), I just immediately fail another 2 times.
Agree but in most scenarios you dont use the 3 life system because of the low HP drain.

5) Changes Insane maps far more than Easy maps. The Easy mod divides all the difficulty statistics by 2. This means that on an Insane (with AR/Drain/OD 8+), it makes a huge change. On easier maps (which it's probably intended for), it barely changes it at all. OD 1 ==> OD Half? Might as well not do anything at all.
Don't really understand what point you are trying to prove. I think I understand the last 2 sentences. The OD and AR change won't be that noticeable, but the hit circle is definitely larger which makes it easier for them to hit it.

So why am I bothering to post this? The "Easy" mod is misleading to new players! It makes things more difficult!

Basically, my feature request is to do one or more of the following:

1) Remove Easy mod completely.
2) Rework Easy mod to actually make things easier. How about letting the player choose their approach rate when Easy is enabled? How about dividing all the difficulty settings by 1.4 instead of 2.0 so it isn't such a massive change, or maybe just subtracting a static number? Reworking the "3 life system" so that the song backs up a couple sections so the player can get back "into the beat" when they resume?

3) Make the current Easy mode a difficulty increasing mod with a score multiplier (lol). It would certainly be harder than Hard Rock, Hidden, and even Flashlight on a lot of maps.
4) Something else?!
I believe another option could be to create a new mod that halves the AR of the map with a score multiplier of x1.00 just call this 'new mod' cant think of a name.

5) A mix of point 4 and 5. Add the mod request I made in point 4 and rework work the EZ mod to let the player choose their AR. In that way people who can't read low AR don't immediately start with half their usual AR and instead can work their way down or work their way to reading high AR (this way EZ mod will literally become easier). Then EZ mod players can choose to continue playing EZ or go to the 'new mod' to give themselves more of a challenge. This is the best way I can think of for everyone to benefit from the change.If you got a better way pls tell me.

All the points I made is all my personal opinion and some of it may be different for other players.If I made any grammar mistakes ignore it. On a side note ignore my earlier post. My opinion has changed after learning EZ mod.
Last edited by Stickman92 on , edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Spinner Sage
127 posts
Offline
i agree with this
User avatar
osu! Alumni
2,193 posts
Offline
vitail wrote:
i agree with this


Same
User avatar
Tempo Trainee
11 posts
Offline
WHEN is this finally going to get changed?
User avatar
Whistle Blower
20 posts
Offline
Make "EZ Mod" give a score bonus.

And make a totally seperate mod like "BEGINNER Mod" which makes circle size that little bit bigger and allows the player to pick their ar.
(Begginer mod should have like a score deduction like the EZ Mod has currently)
User avatar
Cymbal Sounder
42 posts
Offline
I would say make EZ mod actually easy and make another mod doing what EZ does now, for people like -GN that can pass blue zenith +EZ
User avatar
Combo Commander
371 posts
Offline
Lybydose wrote:
This is perhaps the most misleading mod in this game. It claims to make maps easier and lumps a huge score penalty on the player for using it, and yet it does precisely the opposite: makes a great number of maps absolutely Insane.

There are a number of reasons for this:

1) The approach rate. This is the biggest reason. Most players, even new players, find faster approach rate easier than slower approach rate (to a certain point around 6-7 or so). Cutting the approach rate in half on harder maps is a HUGE change. Most Hard/Insane maps become completely unreadable because there are SO MANY circles on the screen at once.
I actually prefer it this way. It does indeed take a while to get used to it, but I now reached a point where the slow AR improves my reading. I can't even read TBB without EZ so no way I could play it NM

2) Increased circle size. This usually makes it easier, but in a lot of situations it causes really confusing overlapping. Coupled with (1), the map is even more difficult to read.
Again, just something you need to get used to. It's also dependent on the skin you're using. With the default skin this isn't that much of an issue. Further more, if it bothers you that much, you can just skin the circles smaller to prevent them from overlapping, it won't affect their actual hitbox

3) Decreased overall difficulty. Yes, really. In osu!, you can't hit a note until the previous note either been hit or missed. By "missed", I mean that too much time has passed that you are no longer in the hit window to get a 50 on the note. A massive decrease in overall difficulty on harder maps makes the hit window for a note overlap with the "exact timing" of the next note in many cases. What this means is that if you misclick a note, yet hit the next one perfectly, you often miss it too because the previous note is still "active" and the note you clicked just "shakes", even though you hit it perfectly. You end up missing an entire chain of notes because of one misclick.
This is actually the main reason why I am playing with EZ. you're reight, but this problem only occurs in streams and during streams you will also experience it without EZ so don't blame it on the mod

4) 3 life system. This doesn't actually make it harder, but it isn't implemented very well. It's incredibly difficult to resume playing after starting on the next life. Why? There's a completely unrhythmic amount of time spent waiting for the life bar to fill up again; it's impossible to tell exactly when you're supposed to start playing again. I think there's a button to skip this, but I have no idea what it is. The only reason I think this is because sometimes it immediately starts playing again without a wait. I've tried just about every logical button to intentionally skip it, and I've never managed to trigger it. Usually if I "fail" a map with Easy the first time (which is common thanks to (1) (2) and (3), I just immediately fail another 2 times.
Again, you just need to get used to it. They might add a countdown or remove the randomizer from the revive time but thats it. Though you could indeed use the already halved HP rate as an argument to remove the extra lives.
5) Changes Insane maps far more than Easy maps. The Easy mod divides all the difficulty statistics by 2. This means that on an Insane (with AR/Drain/OD 8+), it makes a huge change. On easier maps (which it's probably intended for), it barely changes it at all. OD 1 ==> OD Half? Might as well not do anything at all.
the difference between OD1 and OD0 is bigger than between OD10 and OD9 so halving the values instead of subtracting them by an absolute value makes perfectly sense in my eyes


So why am I bothering to post this? The "Easy" mod is misleading to new players! It makes things more difficult!
I agree with this

Basically, my feature request is to do one or more of the following:

1) Remove Easy mod completely. HELL NO!
2) Rework Easy mod to actually make things easier. How about letting the player choose their approach rate when Easy is enabled? How about dividing all the difficulty settings by 1.4 instead of 2.0 so it isn't such a massive change, or maybe just subtracting a static number? Reworking the "3 life system" so that the song backs up a couple sections so the player can get back "into the beat" when they resume? hmm maybe
3) Make the current Easy mode a difficulty increasing mod with a score multiplier (lol). It would certainly be harder than Hard Rock, Hidden, and even Flashlight on a lot of maps. yeah, "lol".
4) Something else?! Maybe create a new EZ mod and use the current one as a second option just like fade-in in mania?

Ok sure, it would break existing replays on Easy mod. Thing is, there aren't many to begin with because it just isn't worth using to make a map harder, only to give less points. Most of the time people just use it to pass TAG4 maps with the extra life system.
Breaking the scores would be avoidable if the current mod stays in the game
User avatar
Slider Savant
84 posts
Offline
Lybydose wrote:
So why am I bothering to post this? The "Easy" mod is misleading to new players! It makes things more difficult!

Basically, my feature request is to do one or more of the following:

1) Remove Easy mod completely.
2) Rework Easy mod to actually make things easier. How about letting the player choose their approach rate when Easy is enabled? How about dividing all the difficulty settings by 1.4 instead of 2.0 so it isn't such a massive change, or maybe just subtracting a static number? Reworking the "3 life system" so that the song backs up a couple sections so the player can get back "into the beat" when they resume?
3) Make the current Easy mode a difficulty increasing mod with a score multiplier (lol). It would certainly be harder than Hard Rock, Hidden, and even Flashlight on a lot of maps.
4) Something else?!


I think that 2 AND 3 are a great solution together. #2 should be reworked as explained. #3 should be renamed called "Annoy" or "Annoyance" or "ANNOYING(jk)", and should fall on the HR mod category. #3 will still be the same as today's easy, but the HP drain should be the same as "No Mod"(depending on the creator) or more unforgiving along with no extra life.
User avatar
Spinner Sage
149 posts
Offline
Does osu! actually need a mod that makes the map actually easier? I believe it's quite impractical as opinions about what is easy and what is hard are extremely broad. (especially when talking about AR and CS)
There are multiple ideas in this thread about how EZ mod could be reworked, but they seem quite complex and have many diversed opinions on it.

I think osu! doesn't need a mod that makes it practically easier, as it's quite hard to make such a mod.
Also, when you'd change/rework the mod, what about all the plays that already exist?

Quote:
should be renamed called "Annoy" or "Annoyance" or "ANNOYING(jk), and should fall on the HR mod category."

The one thing I would consider changing maybe is the name of the mod, as EZ is obviously very misleading. Annoyance is maybe somewhat unsuitable ;p.
I looked up synonyms for "hard to read" and found a few better suggestions.
"Enigmatic", "Perplex", "Abstract", "Cryptic", "Scrawled", other similar names.
User avatar
Slider Savant
84 posts
Offline
Swerro wrote:
Quote:
should be renamed called "Annoy" or "Annoyance" or "ANNOYING(jk), and should fall on the HR mod category."

The one thing I would consider changing maybe is the name of the mod, as EZ is obviously very misleading. Annoyance is maybe somewhat unsuitable ;p.
I looked up synonyms for "hard to read" and found a few better suggestions.
"Enigmatic", "Perplex", "Abstract", "Cryptic", "Scrawled", other similar names.



I have to agree with you...
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
1,566 posts
Offline
Swerro wrote:
The one thing I would consider changing maybe is the name of the mod, as EZ is obviously very misleading. Annoyance is maybe somewhat unsuitable ;p.
I looked up synonyms for "hard to read" and found a few better suggestions.
"Enigmatic", "Perplex", "Abstract", "Cryptic", "Scrawled", other similar names.

Why? Easy in theory makes the game easier. It lowers the AR and CS and the HP drain, just because some users find it harder to read at higher levels doesn't mean it should be called something else.
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
2,037 posts
Offline
All you have to do is have it decrease the AR by 1 instead of halving it. It's literally that EZ to fix.
User avatar
Spinner Sage
149 posts
Offline
Cawub wrote:
Why? Easy in theory makes the game easier. It lowers the AR and CS and the HP drain, just because some users find it harder to read at higher levels doesn't mean it should be called something else.

I agree. But we aren't talking about some users, we're talking about a huge amount of players. I can confidently say that 50%+ users in osu! find that EZ mod makes the beatmap harder. Maybe we should do a poll?
Anyhow, I myself don't mind the misleading naming, EZ has a funny ironic name. yes i change my view/opinions in things frequently

Quote:
All you have to do is have it decrease the AR by 1 instead of halving it. It's literally that EZ to fix.

An AR drop from 9 to 8 would still make the map harder for many people.
I'm still convinced that there is no fix for EZ mod as opinions on AR diverse so much. And that osu! doesn't need a mod that makes it practically easier, as it would involve changable AR which is a somewhat weird thing for a mod.
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
523 posts
Offline
I think EZ mod should allow the user to change CS, AR, & OD to whatever settings they want (still keep HP fixed so people don't just put everything to HP: 0) Also by doing it this way people could also use EZ as a practice mod to try and work on things they struggle at. Have a problem reading small CS but don't want maps being low difficulty or AR10 when Hr is added? Just put on a map with ez and practice your CS: 5 reading skills
Reply 159 posts jump | prev  1 ... 7, 8, 9, 10, 11  next

Users browsing this forum: None


Jump to: