1. Who is this "___"? (4.26 stars, 1218 notes)

1. plz remove "enable countdown"
2. And if you add storyboard in map, please check "Display epilepsy warning" when you added SB

1. I feel you should be same distance on 00:51:859 (1,2) - and 00:56:145 (5,6) -
2. 01:07:931 (4,1) - this distance is so far considering 1/8 interval01:21:645 (4,1) - ^ 03:43:931 (4,1) - ^
3. 01:13:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - why dont you same distances? and 01:13:288 (1) - start more upward then you can place 01:13:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - straightly. i think it's no problem about 01:13:073 (3,1) - distance cuz of kiai time. 03:49:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - ^
4. 01:34:716 (1,2,3) - why dont you change to below image? i recommend to avoid overlap on this part cuz it looks more clean
   
   SPOILER

   
5. 01:39:859 (1,2,3,4) - i think you should change to suit with next 01:40:288 (1,2,3,4) - . in my thought, you copy 01:40:288 (1,2,3,4) - and paste in 01:39:859 - , then more better about flow.
6. 01:46:716 (1,1,1) - wow that's great...

joker- wrote:

Hi from my Q

[General]

1. plz remove "enable countdown" K
2. And if you add storyboard in map, please check "Display epilepsy warning" when you added SB K

[Insane]

1. I feel you should be same distance on 00:51:859 (1,2) - and 00:56:145 (5,6) - 00:51:859 (1,2) matches with 00:50:145 (1,2)
2. 01:07:931 (4,1) - this distance is so far considering 1/8 interval01:21:645 (4,1) - ^ 03:43:931 (4,1) - ^ Ima take my chances and leave it as is.
3. 01:13:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - why dont you same distances? and 01:13:288 (1) - start more upward then you can place 01:13:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - straightly. i think it's no problem about 01:13:073 (3,1) - distance cuz of kiai time. 03:49:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - ^ I don't want to make it a complete straight line, that'd be too awkward looking imo, but i do agree that this part can be done better. I'll look into it.
4. 01:34:716 (1,2,3) - why dont you change to below image? i recommend to avoid overlap on this part cuz it looks more clean Fixed!
   
   SPOILER

   
5. 01:39:859 (1,2,3,4) - i think you should change to suit with next 01:40:288 (1,2,3,4) - . in my thought, you copy 01:40:288 (1,2,3,4) - and paste in 01:39:859 - , then more better about flow. Gonna leave it as it is for now.
6. 01:46:716 (1,1,1) - wow that's great...Thanks! spent a good amount of time to make it perfect

sry i dont bethink more mods anymore cuz i never have made DnB song yet. if you need more my opinions, plz poke me chat or forum PM, I'll mod your map.
GL!! Thanks for the mod!

KantanDez wrote:

from my queue w

Ram
00:00:431 - 00:13:716 - add whistle to all NCs in the section (sounds better imo) Hmm I agree. Done!
00:31:288 - you should add a hit circle here Waiting on further opinion
00:38:145 - ^ ^
01:13:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - the distance between these objects are too long and the sound it makes is very weak. try something like a stream that increases distance(and sound) over each hit circle(that will most likely be very fitting) I think it's fitting enough for now. May revisit if more people mention about it
01:22:716 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - do something like https://imgur-archive.ppy.sh/yLbSFXd.png instead, the pattern you used is bad I think my pattern is good. Sry
01:27:002 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - just like 01:13:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) Same as above
02:41:573 (1,2,3,4) - velocity change in each slider sounds good I'll consider it, but probably not cause i want them to be all the same to make the pattern look symmetrical
02:42:859 (1,2,3,4) - increase volume here Not necessary, also changing the volume of these cymbal hitsounds doesn't make sense realistically, these hitsounds should be kept at the same volume throught the whole song.
02:50:145 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - do this instead https://imgur-archive.ppy.sh/0cNFoQO.png (its the same as using a slider on a blue tick) Waiting on further opinion
03:04:181 (2,3,4,5,6) - ^ ^
03:49:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 01:13:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) Same as mentioned above
04:00:752 (2,3,4,5,6) - 02:50:145 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) ^
04:44:359 (1,2,3,4,5) - https://imgur-archive.ppy.sh/NMf1SbH.png straight stream pattern doesnt fit with the music Made it curvy!

good luck Thank you so much! Although I rejected most of your suggestions (As I usually do unless one's suggestion is really good/fixing my mistakes) I might change in the future if more people mention the same thing. Thanks again!

00:00:431 (1) - There is a lot of circles here, maybe you should put some sliders for recovery

00:03:645 (4) - Why skip that triple o.o

00:07:073 (4) - You can skip that object with a slider

00:20:788 (4) - same

00:27:216 (2) - Voice start earlier check again

00:31:288 (4) - Now when there is a downbeat you skip it aaaaaaaa ;-;

00:33:323 (3) - [FOR THE NEXT SAME PROBLEMS OF THE MAP] You skip a lot of downbeats, review your rythmics for this map, sometimes it's really
fuzzy.

01:04:931 (1,2,3) - Make the same DS than the first same pattern of the map

01:18:645 (1) - Same

01:23:145 (2) - This is overmapped D:

01:57:859 (1) - This is really hard to read even in editor !

02:50:466 (2) - This is overmapped too x.x

03:04:181 (2) - Same

04:00:752 (2) - Same

04:26:145 (1) - Why there is no kiai here, You put one for the first part and not now

Ponoyoshi wrote:

NM from my modqueue
Who is this "___"

00:00:431 (1) - There is a lot of circles here, maybe you should put some sliders for recovery No thanks, I don't think players need a recovery in a non jump section. If there's nothing in the song that would let me put a slider, then I won't put a slider.

00:03:645 (4) - Why skip that triple o.o Sorry, I don't understand what you mean

00:07:073 (4) - You can skip that object with a slider No, same reason as ^^

00:20:788 (4) - same ^

00:27:216 (2) - Voice start earlier check again I notice, but it starts on a yellow (1/8) tick, but i don't want to make it start on a yellow tick since it would be very weird, I don't want to map it on the blue tick either cause that'd be too early and would mess up the rhythem of the triangle pattern.

00:31:288 (4) - Now when there is a downbeat you skip it aaaaaaaa ;-; Originally wanted to just map to the piano and the vocal, but lots of people complained, so changed! Thanks!
00:33:323 (3) - [FOR THE NEXT SAME PROBLEMS OF THE MAP] You skip a lot of downbeats, review your rythmics for this map, sometimes it's really
fuzzy. Okay, gonna consider if more people complain

01:04:931 (1,2,3) - Make the same DS than the first same pattern of the map I'll consider, but for now, unchanged

01:18:645 (1) - Same ^

01:23:145 (2) - This is overmapped D:I'll consider remapping this later, I'm not very pleased with this pattern as a whole anyways.

01:57:859 (1) - This is really hard to read even in editor ! It's suppose to be hard to read in the editor. XD

02:50:466 (2) - This is overmapped too x.x Sorry I don't think it is.

03:04:181 (2) - Same ^

04:00:752 (2) - Same ^

04:26:145 (1) - Why there is no kiai here, You put one for the first part and not now The map is already over 1/3 kiai time, so i'm a bit hesitant on adding even more kiai time. Personally, I feel the song intensity is not as much as before.

The visuals of your map is well. BUT you have to REVIEW the rythms, he's really fuzzy and not consistent !
Good luck ! Thanks for the mod!

Hobbes2 wrote:

Hi, sorry for being late!

00:01:073 (4,1) - Just like there's a "jump" here to seperate these groupings, why not have one 00:01:931 (4,1) ? you seem to have one everywhere else. Maybe stack 00:02:145 (1,2,3,4) - so that 00:02:573 (3) - stacks on 00:01:288 (1) - Thank you for pointing that out! I changed to something similar to your suggestion.

00:08:788 (4,1) - ^ as a note, this isn't necessary at all, just a minor suggestion. Changed!

00:27:216 (2,3,4) - I know this isn't necessarily following the vocals but the fact that the vocal starts before 00:27:216 (2) - does really throws me off here. Not sure what the solution is, just figured I'd mention this. I know, it starts on a 1/8 tick, so i'm not sure how to fix it either XD

00:29:573 (1,2,3) - Better flow if you position it something like this - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6780037 Made it better hopefully

00:31:716 (3,1) - Fix blanket, 00:32:359 (2) - and im not a big fan of how this is overlapped by 00:31:716 (3), maybe you can try something like this instead? - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6780047 (ignore the timeline) Completely changed to something different. I didn't like the pattern either.

00:42:859 (1) - should just be a single repeat, making it a double repeat removes emphasis from 00:43:073 - Actually, i kinda agree with you there. Changed.

00:44:145 (4,6) - maybe put more space between these? They're almost touching which looks kinda ugly. Applies to most of the sliders in this area.Fixed

00:49:716 (2) - This slider's kinda ugly lol, something like this perhaps? - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6780058 Fixed XD

00:59:573 (4) - missing clap I think Fixed

01:02:145 (3) - NC for the SV change? It's pretty drastic Changed

01:07:931 (4,1) - this jump is huge, maybe you want it like that but it's frustrating to play due to the 1/8 gap (since you haven't used many of them for the player to get used to that timing) I made these jumps a bit closer, but I do kinda want to keep this pattern. It's playable for me, but I dunno.

01:12:216 - this is 1/8, there are 4 beats until the next slider, not 3 Changed to a buzz slider. Didn't want to make it into a 1/8 stream.

01:11:573 (1,2) - this is spaced like 1/4 but its only 1/2, so could cause some reading issues Fixed

01:12:752 (2,3) - use 1.1 spacing? Looks better if they dont touch. wont mention this more, but keep that in mindChanged

01:21:645 (4,1) - same as before K

01:26:038 - I can BARELY hear a tick here, let along these other notes. This is overmapping. At best, you could map this blue tick. I deleted the stream altogether, thanks for mentioning

01:29:573 (1,2) - Blanket? would look nice K

01:32:716 (2,3,4,5) - this should be 1/8 K

rest of this kiai is pretty neat. Thanks

02:17:895 (1) - is this NC intentional? No, woops. fixed

02:22:073 - There's a sound here you could map MM i'm gonna leave that part empty, don't want to map the guitar, since the rest i'm not mapping the guitar anyways,

02:31:288 (1,3) - make these not touch, looks ugly K
02:32:145 (1,3) - ^ you get the idea K

02:48:431 (1,2) - 02:49:288 (1,2) - these as well, use a DS so that these don't touch and it would look way better. Fixed

03:40:716 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - idk if you can really expect the target audience to be able to not only read this as 1/3 but then also tap it properly. Changed to buzz sliders

03:46:716 (2) - this SV increase isn't really justified by the music leaving as it is until more people mention it.

03:48:216 (3,4,5) - should be 1/8 Fixed

rest of this mod would just be me repeating stuff, so yeah

hope I could help, I like this map, it has some cool ideas.

Good luck! Thanks for the mod! It really helped!

1. i cover more about concepts in this mod in attempt you can improve the quality in general
2. only anime song i like
   

zev wrote:

General

1. i cover more about concepts in this mod in attempt you can improve the quality in general
2. only anime song i like

Who is this "___"?

00:03:002 (1) - make it 5.3x ds? why would there be less spacing if song keeps the same Fixed
00:06:431 (1) - not so sure about this being so close? why not make it stack so it flow stops, emphasizing the downbeat Fixed
00:14:788 (3) - early on the beatmap i would just first let the player accumulate to the rhythm before doing stuff like that, can you make the slider point in circle? Fixed. good point.


00:15:859 (1,2) - this might be a bit too close,I think you should be consistently putting these a bit spaced smilair to this 00:19:288 (1) - Fixed

00:32:145 (1) - players either think its 1/2 or 1/4, never inbetween, this looks like a inbetween, can you make it less spaced so it feels like a 1/4 just compare it to 00:30:431 (1,2) - I think the spacing is fine here
01:12:216 (3) - spacing is too large put it next to 01:12:431 (1) - you have to like hint the player that its a fast patternKeeping until more people mention about it

01:39:859 (1) - You don't need this timing point its a duplicate basically Fixed
01:57:002 (1) - ^ this one too, i think thats it checked them for ya Fixed thank you


04:32:145 (1) - its nice that you slowed the sliders on the clap, but if you bind idea's like that to the music you have to keep your promise and keep following them, so yah this should be slowed Changed to something different. Never intended to map the slider to he clap

04:37:931 (2) - overlaps delay reading and it comes a bit unexpected imo why x2 sv the snare sounds the same I wanted to completely overlap the previous slider. I'm keeping it unless more people don't like it.

Thank you for letting me mod your map! NP Thank you for modding!~

Gerar14x wrote:

Hi~ M4M from my queue

General

1. Delete "tv size" from tags , "rem revive by death" should be removed too in my opinion since its not related to the song, i dont know that much about metadata, so be sure to check this with someone with experience if you can. Okay I'll look into it. I'll probably delete revive by death, but i think i'll be keeping rem
2. Lower OD a bit Agreed.

Who is this "___"?

1. 00:09:859 (1,2,3,4) - you can make this pattern the same or similar to 00:03:002 (1,2,3,4) - the notes in the piano are similar, compare it with 00:06:431 (1,2,3,4) - for example, wich is clearly more quiet than those sections fixed
2. 00:59:038 (2,3) - overlap or stack would help reading there fixed
3. 01:00:431 (1) - Could be a better polished shape imo please give a screenshot of how i can improve a slider or a pattern. Don't just say "polish this" I think it looks fine.
4. 01:06:431 (1) - you could nc this (or figure something else) as a help to notice the SV change, you do this all the song, so check it, as its common in the map (04:23:573 (1) - and 04:25:288 (1) - are a good example of noticing the sv change) Umm, they are already NC'd? You even said 01:06:431 (1), the (1) being a new combo.
5. 01:12:216 (3,1) - i feel that quite "big" because of the 1/8 gap there Made it closer
6. 04:18:216 (3,2) - A little overlap there I meant to overlap, but i overlapped it better this time.
7. 04:37:931 (2) - this one feels wierd while playing since its the only one like that I'm keeping this until someone else or I figure out a better pattern
8. 04:45:002 (1,3) - overlap, you can change the angle of (1) to avoid it I would ruin the pattern if i rotated (1) to avoid the overlap.
9. 05:28:716 (1,2,3,4) - like i said before in the beggining of the song, you can make this pattern the same as 05:21:859 (1,2,3,4) - for the notes of the piano Fixed
10. 05:32:145 (1,2,3) - a triangle pattern there could be better imo No thanks

Good luck with ranking Thank you for the mod.

WISPG_G wrote:

hello, Light mod from my queue

• 
  General

1. Looks like offset little wrong here, while I playing it I have very much 100 on circles at start, this also very noticeably on drums here 00:14:164 -
   Try offset ~450 sounds much better imo The current offset seems fine by me. I'll change if more people mention it.
2. Try set Slider Tick Rate 2 to make slow sliders like this 00:41:164 (3) and this 01:08:164 (1) - more readable also emphasize sounds on middle of this 00:49:307 (1) - sliders Hmm okay!

• 
  Who is this "___"?

1. 00:03:021 (1,2) - big jumps like this must be between 00:03:235 (2,3) - 3 stronger than 2 Fixed
2. 00:09:878 (1,2,3,4) - should be similar pattern ^ ^
3. 00:20:592 (3,4) - this jump unnecessary 4 note is weak you should make notes in pairs and jump only between them 00:20:378 (2,3) - (there more similar moments) Deleted the jump
4. 00:27:878 (1,2,3,1) - um pretty strange spacing, huge for 1/4 and small for 1/2, try at least stack 00:28:307 (3,1) - this Fixed the spacing
5. 00:36:878 (3,1) - before you always made small spacing, but here its different? Fixed
6. 01:57:021 (1,2,1,2) - fix stacks Dunno why but I can't perfectly stack them
   
7. 01:59:378 (3,4,5,1) - fix spacing, here 01:59:485 (5,1) - 1/4, but you still follow 1/8 spacing You mean 1/6.
8. 02:39:878 (1,1,1,1) - little idea for you, make similar pattern as here 02:36:450 (1,1,1,1) - but with growing SV instead and in different way example and add NCs here 02:40:307 (2,3,4) - because of SV changes Hmm no thanks. Thanks for the suggestion though! NC'd the sliders though
9. 02:52:735 (5) - another SV changes NC please K got it
10. 04:37:950 (2) - NC K

That's it from me
Good luck! o/ Thank's for the mod!

DivineEnigma wrote:

Hello! M4M~

Who is this "___"?

1. Places like 01:07:931 (4) - , 01:12:216 (3) - , and 03:53:145 (2) - should have an NC because of the SV change that is there. I don't see any SV changes, just volume changes.
2. 01:13:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - I believe this straight pattern should start at 01:13:609 - because of the sound that's there. I'm not sure what instrument produces that sound. The little "water drop" sound (best i could describe it) starts at 01:13:288 - if you listen closely. I'm mapping to that sound.
3. 01:27:002 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Similar to ^, I believe that sound is on 01:27:216 - so the circle pattern stream should appear on there. No it doesn't. Listen closer.
4. 01:34:073 (1,2) - You can choose to ignore this but I just wanted to let you know that I feel like on a 4* map, some players can get this confused and be like, is (1) a slider and believe (2) is the note that comes after it. If you do ignore it, maybe just NC it or something like what you did here 03:02:788 (4,1) - . I don't think they are going to misread that.
5. 01:40:181 (4,1) - Why is there a space in DS here? There's a louder sound on 01:40:395 - . DS is not emphasizing the sound, but the whole pattern is emphasizing the irregular melody that occurs there. If I made it a normal stream with no zigzags and no split, then it would be a kinda dull stream for that part. And putting DS on 01:39:859 (1,2) and 01:40:288 (1,2) - would be too weird. Putting DS after the 4th note is used in some other maps as well.
6. 03:49:288 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Same as 01:27:002 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - . Same
7. 03:01:609 (2,3) - Spread (3) away from (2) a bit like you did here 04:33:538 (3,4,5) - and in other places of the map. No thanks, I kept that stack consistent on similar parts of the map.
8. 03:58:181 (2,3) - ^^
9. 04:25:073 (3,1) - Maybe do something like this for better flow? Nope, I want to keep 3 & 1 perpendicular.
   
   SPOILER

   

Interesting song and map, good luck on ranking!!!
If you have any questions, feel free to message me in-game or forums. Sorry, didn't take any of your suggestions, but hopefully your storyboard mod is some help! Thanks for the mod and I will mod your map shortly.

TheKingHenry wrote:

mfw ar 9,2 in 4,31* 140 bpm map

Memes aside; hello, mod from my queue~

General

1. okay so that AR is real point. This is low bpm map of not so high difficulty lvl. While it sure has some gimmicky patterns, which I will talk about more later on, it's too high AR for this imo, max AR 9, perhaps smth like AR 8,5, since from my experience lower AR fits low bpm gimmickes Changed to AR 9
2. you have

Who is this "___"?

1. most of the "problematic patterns" I list here are widely used across the map and I'm not linking them all here. If you consider smth change-worthy, check if there are similar ones to be changed
2. 00:32:573 (3,1) - fix stack K
3. 00:34:716 (1,2,3) - slider leniency and all that shit aside, still hella high spacing for 1/4 on not-so-intense part in the music. Fixed
4. 00:35:145 (3,1) - fix stack K
5. 01:07:931 (4,1) - 1/8 between and this kind of spacing, maybe little closer It's the closest I can get without overlapping
6. 01:44:466 (3,4) - 1/4 or smth, plays badly, especially since the slider isn't abused in this transition Okay fixed
7. 01:45:859 (1,2,3,4) - what are these mapped to? Only number 4 actually has that kind of stuff Umm, the electric melody? I think it's pretty clear...
8. 01:50:788 (3,4,5,6) - this aint 1/3 but 1/4 + 1/8 in the end, agreed it plays better the current way I actually changed it to a 1/8 buzz slider.
9. 02:42:216 (4,1,2,3,4) - this could flow better. Currently the slider 4 leads circular flow upwards somewhere towards sliderend 3, you'll have to break it for the streams in the bottom, and stream ain't too lenient pattern for this either Imo the song allows the flow to break here. and the stream is fine.
10. 02:50:466 (2,3,4,5,6) - these kind of patterns aren't too good in this lvl of difficulty I'm keeping them, sorry.
11. 02:54:859 (1,2,3,4) - again sounds more like 1/8 (and actually there isn't rly anything audible during the slider). Although, current prob plays better here as well It actually doesn't sound like 1/6 or 1/8. The piano sounds mushed here.
12. 03:02:145 (1,2,3) - the big spacing should be from the slider to the circle, not vice versa. As earlier, plays badly Fixed
13. 04:26:145 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - what do these base on? Lots of similar ones in the following section Same as above.
14. didnt tackle on the visual aspect too much this time, just check out all patterns similar to what I mentioned.

also emilia > rem :^)
Good luck! Thank you for the mod!