1. Futsuu (2.07 stars, 87 notes)
2. Kantan (1.53 stars, 59 notes)
3. Muzukashii (2.52 stars, 136 notes)
4. Oni (3.34 stars, 197 notes)

1. 00:36:090 (52) - Change this note to d?
2. Consider SV 1.2 for the Kantan.

1. 00:37:582 (81) - You should remove this note because the player got used to a 3 notes pattern for this part, so it's a bit awkward (and notes on red ticks are awkward enough already).

Kurosanyan wrote:

Kantan

1. 00:36:090 (52) - Change this note to d? nah, was following the high pitch of the prominent instrument; the bass isn't really that prominent imo
2. Consider SV 1.2 for the Kantan. new ranking criteria has it as a guideline that SV should be 1.4 so this seems fine enough

Futsuu

1. 00:37:582 (81) - You should remove this note because the player got used to a 3 notes pattern for this part, so it's a bit awkward (and notes on red ticks are awkward enough already). okay, done! also changed 00:38:079 (81,82,83,84) - to kkdd for better consistency with other diffs

And that's all (I won't star until I know which mapset will be ranked).

Hamitsuka wrote:

Hi !

Kantan
00:00:281 (1) - I suggest you to begin by a big Don ! nope, would be inconsistent with other diffs.
00:07:906 (12,13) - A "D D" pattern would be preferable. pitch rises so it wouldn't really fit that well imo
00:14:206 (21) - A don relatively high pitch here so nah
00:14:869 (22,23) - "D K" pattern instead of "K D" whoops, fixed this
00:16:196 (24) - A don it's not really that hard-hitting, so it wouldn't fit too well
00:18:185 (27) - A don ^
00:25:148 (38) - A kat swapped these two for better following of the melody so both are fixed.
00:28:795 (42) - A don

Futsuu
00:00:612 (2) - A don ? pitch falls most at the next note, so I think this seems to be okay.
00:04:259 (9,10) - Don don don kat instead, didn't change the 2nd note.
00:08:238 (20) - Don again not really hard-hitting
00:11:719 (25) - Don nah, I think the melody suggests a kat.
00:12:217 (27) - Don swapped this and the note before so the pattern is simpler and it follows your suggestion.
00:15:201 (34) - Kat ^ and melody purposes
00:39:737 (85) - Don I think this is a bit different from the next note so no change.
00:42:058 (88) - Big kat nope, inconsistent with other diffs otherwise

game rock wrote:

Hi I'm noob in this but, I try .

d
k
D (Big d)
K (Big k)

So, my opinion is:

Kantan

00:14:206 - Change it to d. alright, but mainly due to there being no twang
00:28:795 - Change it to d. nah, pitch is rather high here, keeping as k.


Futsuu

00:02:933 - Add a d. mkay, done, there must've been a missing feeling somehow which is now fixed x3
00:06:580 - Change it to d. nah, pitch is quite high here too, keeping as k.
00:07:243 - Change it to k. wasn't really following the strings here so keeping as d

Good Luck

Nwolf wrote:

woof heyo

[Kantan]

00:24:153 - 00:32:111 - Remove a few notes in these 8 seconds to create one or two 6/1 breaks since the part is pretty calm. Preferably 00:25:148 (38) - 00:28:795 (42) - and maybe even 00:29:127 (43) - Did 1st and 3rd for consistency, done 2nd 'cause 1/1 stuff was apparently a bit too dense, this is all ok by me, deleted those 3.

[Futsuu]

Do the same as in Kantan, just between 00:28:132 - and 00:32:111 - especially since in the next part there are far less notes. okay, done, removed quite a few notes.
00:32:111 - 00:37:084 - Add... just a few notes. To avoid spread issues from F -> M here. Maybe do 4-plets instead. The section was totally reworked, it's 1/1s instead of 3/2s now; with a 4-plet, and 2 5-plets which should hopefully be ok.
00:39:405 - Add a note here cause hardly any difference to Kantan done

[Muzukashii]

And the same thing again as in Kantan. Made it a bit less dense, hoping this is alright also.

00:37:084 (128,129,130,131) - Don't get why you suddenly changed rhythm moved 00:37:250 (129) - to 00:37:582 - for more consistency I guess

[Oni]

00:02:104 (10) - Like mentioned in my last mod but this time no, 5 is not the same sound. removed kay
00:06:083 (32) - ^ removed also


no kd, call me back