forum

The Killers - A Great Big Sled

posted
Total Posts
12
Topic Starter
eee
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on Friday, December 25, 2009 at 1:29:45 PM

Artist: The Killers
Title: A Great Big Sled
Tags: Christmas
BPM: 128
Filesize: 9551kb
Play Time: 03:49
Difficulties Available:
  1. eeeasy (1.46 stars, 205 notes)
  2. EEeee's Sled (4.88 stars, 555 notes)
  3. Hard (4.84 stars, 546 notes)
Download: The Killers - A Great Big Sled
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
I Wanna Wish You Merry Christmas
deadbeat
nice storyboard..don't really like the start...but that's just what i think
GladiOol
- General / All diff's.
  1. LOL XD
- Hard.
  1. (nazi) 03:37:084 (5) - Move one grid level up.
I'm still lolling. Espescially Chuck Norris was awesome x'D.
Star plus extra Kudosu Star~
Larto
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
jockeytiyan
Just some comments. I don't see that much problem in the map, actually.


Easy:
I don't think Easies should be this long. It's too tiring for the newbie players, IMO.


Hard:
00:26:828 (11) - Start combo here. I think you're trying to map it with the vocals, so I recommend it.
00:51:906 (6) - Start a new combo here.

And for Hard, put some more breaks please. T_T It's too tiring to play it for one whole straight minute without rest, considering the sudden change in beat spacing and the slider velocity.
NotShinta
Easy is not long at all. Shortening it will make the storyboard incomplete and abruptly ended anyway.

Storyboard is epic anyway. Starred.
EEeee
James2250
easy:
00:34:328 (1) - add note?
00:43:000 (1) - might want to extend to 00:45:813?
01:57:063 (1) - might want to extend to 02:00:344?
02:13:000 (1) - nazi: up 1 grid to align with 2
03:18:625 (4) - new combo

Hard:
00:29:172 (7,8,9) - nazi: spacing looks slightly odd

EEeee:
End first kiai time where eee ends it..
very repetitive but seems ok

I normally like to see the highest star rating have the most points but thats not a big deal

nicely done map *star*
0_o
Sweet storyboard :)

eeeeeeasy
00:17:453 (4,1) - Make this into a slider instead? Switching to notes on the offbeat is a bit tricky for Easy (It screwed ME up :P)
00:34:563 (1,2,3,4) - Again, I'm not too sure if this rhythm is intuitive enough for the easiest difficulty. I would consider mapping to more of the white ticks, and map to the beat of the song instead of the lyrics.
00:43:000 (1) - Extend to the white tick? It sounds better ending on the beat imo
01:06:203 (4,5) - Felt weird to play. Taking these out and making 3 a repeat slider that repeats on 01:06:203 sounds pretty good to me.
01:28:703 (1) - THIS IS SO UGLY AHHH (and it appears later as well >_>)
02:13:000 (1,2,3,4,5) - It would be nice if this was symmetrical along the y-axis
03:20:500 (1,2,3) - Neaten this up
03:34:563 (1) - Symmetry?
03:38:781 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Alternating claps?

Hard
00:43:000 (1) - I would add a hitcircle here and move the spinner ahead a bit
01:13:000 (x) - ^
01:30:109 (1) - >______________>
02:15:344 (2) - This combo played a little awkwardly, I would extend this to the white tick for playabilty reasons
03:44:641 (6,7,8,9) - This is a little tough to read, and anyone who combobreaks here after playing through the whole thing is gonna be ticked :P

EEeeeee
01:48:156 (3,6) - I would unstack these just to make it more obvious they are on blue ticks (they are the first 1/4 notes in the whole map)
03:08:313 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - Adjust the stacking leniency so that this doesn't look screwed up in-game
03:17:688 (2,3,4) - Make these new combos? It drains quite a bit during this section

Have a CHRISTMAS STAR
Card N'FoRcE
- General:
  • Great job on storyboarding. It's great.
    I hope i didn't miss anything when modding, because i always had my eyes on SB xD
- eeeasy:
  • .Opinions:
    Good, but it was a bit... hard to read sometimes D:
- Hard:
  • .Suggestions:
    00:33:391 (4) - a clap here sounds great ^^
    00:41:359 (6) - ^
    03:41:828 (7) - oh god, try to make it better D:
- EEeee's Sled:
  • .Opinions:
    The use of Claps is really boring. Try to make them a bit more "variable" Some suggestions:
    .Suggestions:
    00:19:328 (13) - clap?
    00:22:609 (11) - ^
    00:26:828 (12) - ^
    00:41:359 (11) - ^
    00:45:109 (2) - ^
    00:56:359 (8) - ^
    01:11:125 (10) - clap at the end?
    01:14:875 (10) - ^
    01:22:609 (4) - clap?
    01:31:984 (5) - ^
    01:39:484 (4) - ^
    01:41:828 (4) - ^
    And so on...
Gogogo <3
Starrodkirby86
Fun storyboard. <33
Skyripper
I do believe hard is a little high on score, but I think since it's nearly 4 minutes it's within reason to allow.

merry christmas!
Please sign in to reply.

New reply