1. Futsuu (3,71 stars, 193 notes)
2. Inner Oni (4,94 stars, 450 notes)
3. Kantan (1,59 stars, 121 notes)
4. Muzukashii (4,44 stars, 243 notes)
5. Oni (4,81 stars, 337 notes)

• The timing feels like its a teeny tiny bit too slow. Try using Offset 745. Sounds more correct to me.
  There are two mp3 files in the song folder, although all diffs use the same mp3.

• 00:11:654 (1,1,1) - Flip the hitsounding on these, so that it keeps a consistent pattern.

• Looks good to me.

• Muzukashii to me seems like a 7☆ to me.
  01:05:522 (2) - k, it fits the melody of the vocals a lot better.

• Use OD5 and HP5 please. On Taiko Oni, Song Setup Settings should be on the middle.
  00:47:795 - Add a k here, to follow the synth instrument thing that you're mapping after.

NormalChief wrote:

SPOILER

Muzukashii:

01:20:068 (3) - Change to blue note Good idea, but not the time for it yet. next triplet part starts later.

00:36:432 (2,1) - Add a red note between them to make a triplet I used oox patterns just in the kiai part.

Oni:

Add a red note between 00:44:614 (1,1) and 00:46:432 (1,1) Intension. Using now a note would make the connection to 00:46:659 (1,1,1) - lose.

00:36:432 (1,1) - Add a red between them to make a triplet Same reason as above

00:54:500 (1,1,1,1) - Change patter to b,b,r,b I would miss the consisten to the other oxox patterns.

Dolphin wrote:

SPOILER

Hello! Taiko Mod via My Queue.

Normal Text means Suggestions, Bold Text means that you should really fix it.

[General]

• The timing feels like its a teeny tiny bit too slow. Try using Offset 745. Sounds more correct to me. I will try it later.
  There are two mp3 files in the song folder, although all diffs use the same mp3. Oh, ture. lol

[Kantan]

• 00:11:654 (1,1,1) - Flip the hitsounding on these, so that it keeps a consistent pattern. I want to keep the alternating of red to blue. But I will keep that in mind, since it dosen'T sound bad at all.

[Futsuu]

• Looks good to me.

[Muzukashii]

• Muzukashii to me seems like a 7☆ to me.
  01:05:522 (2) - k, it fits the melody of the vocals a lot better. I'm not following vocals in the beatmap.

[Oni]

• Use OD5 and HP5 please. On Taiko Oni, Song Setup Settings should be on the middle. That's a rumor I hear the first time. Onis can go up to OD 7(+) and HP if you like to 10.
  00:47:795 - Add a k here, to follow the synth instrument thing that you're mapping after. If I would do so, the consistency to the other gaps would be gone.

Short songs give little room for mistakes.
I hope I was able to help!
Good Luck!

OnosakiHito wrote:

[list]Use OD5 and HP5 please. On Taiko Oni, Song Setup Settings should be on the middle. That's a rumor I hear the first time. Onis can go up to OD 7(+) and HP if you like to 10.

kazukisinx wrote:

SPOILER

Taiko Mod that i had to do like weeks ago lol

Kantan
-Circle size 5
00:18:022 - add k ( consistency with 00:21:659 - ) I made a rise of notes.
00:25:295 - ^
01:24:386 (1,1,1,1,1) - dkdkK? Intension, to have an alternaiting between don and blue
01:28:022 (1) - K? I want to keep the alternaiting.

Futsuu
-Circle size 5
00:33:477 (1) - move this to 00:34:386 - okay
00:40:750 (1) - ^ (to 00:41:659 - ) okay
00:56:886 (2) - I feel this note isn't necessary,maybe you can delete it for simplifying the pattern okay
01:28:022 - K? No

Muzukashii
-Circle size 5
00:20:295 - use this > http://puu.sh/3DOdb.jpg I will consider it
00:27:568 (1,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,1,2,3) - ^
00:53:250 (1) - k No
00:56:432 (2,3,4,5,6) - Maybe ddkkd k is too hard for a muzukashii,but i still think it sounds better in that way. As you said, kinda too hard.
01:28:022 (1) - K? No

Oni
00:15:295 - use this > http://puu.sh/3DOof.jpg Good pattern, but just beat following. I made my own one.
00:27:909 (1) - i think that note should'nt be there unless you use a 2-plet/4-plet before ( I mean,dont do a ddk kddk pattern,is better a dk kddk) So,put a d here 00:27:682 - I had already one before: 00:26:432 - but I will consider it.
01:28:022 (1) - K? No

That's all :3 sorry for doing too late
Also.

OnosakiHito wrote:

[list]Use OD5 and HP5 please. On Taiko Oni, Song Setup Settings should be on the middle. That's a rumor I hear the first time. Onis can go up to OD 7(+) and HP if you like to 10.

That's true. I seen ranked maps up like OD8

Frans Niko wrote:

SPOILER

#taiko mod request

General
Looks better

Oni
00:44:386 - add a finish here because i hear a drum here I try not to add finishers in middle of a pattern section.
00:58:932 - ^
01:05:750 - the finish isn't fit maybe you can remove finish? That's my own constallation. Putting finisher at the end of certain pattern sections.
01:13:022 - ^
01:14:841 - ^
01:16:659 - ^
01:20:295 - ^
01:22:113 - ^
01:23:932 - ^
01:26:204 - ^ or put the finish too on 01:26:659 -

Muzukashii
00:02:113 - add a note here I'm not following the beat here. Also It was intension as well. Having some emphasizes break here.
00:05:750 - ^
01:13:477 - add finish here No. Because of same reason as in Oni.
01:20:295 - remove finish here Yes.

Futsuu
00:35:295 (1,1) - remove finish I will apply that for now. Still not sure.
00:42:568 (1,1) - ^

Kantan
01:04:841 (1) - i think a new player can't press too much note, so you can delete this
01:12:113 (1) - ^
01:18:477 - remove this note maybe better
I will think about this. Actually it's a good point.

Finally FINISH

1. Apparitions stalk the night, for an appearance in kiai.
2. version, since you used "ver.", as version is the full word (even though we almost never see that in older maps)

_Gezo_ wrote:

SPOILER

Here we go.

[Tags]
How come Elly-chan is still present? Unless she's done a diff there, I really recommend you to remove that one.
Tag recommendations, but not a must:

1. Apparitions stalk the night, for an appearance in kiai.
2. version, since you used "ver.", as version is the full word (even though we almost never see that in older maps)

Changed the tags.

Timing is a bit off, but I might be tricked since I actually got 3ms late at most while testing.
I hit too early... hm. I will see what the next modder is going to say.

The rest is okay so let's move on diffs. Yeah, diffs. There might be few suggestions, that you may deny without providing a reason if you find it too silly.

[Kantan]
Since the rhythm in 00:42:568 (1,2) - is the same as 00:35:295 (1,2,3) - , why not making these two patterns consistent between each other?
Didn't use three kats because the up coming part provides them. So I kept it simple.

I really couldn't find anything else; it's a very solid diff you got there.

[Futsuu]
00:15:295 (2,1,1,1,1,2,3,1,1,1,1,1,2,3) - Since I think 00:22:568 (1,1,1,1,2,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,2,1,1,1) - comes from the highlighted pattern, I think it would be better making it consistent between themselves (1/1-wise, you can keep the 1/2 on the second part.)
If you don't know which notes I'm precisely talking about, these are 00:17:568 (2) - and 00:21:204 (2) -
Needed some moments before I change it, but since someone else didn't like them much I will listen to your suggestion.

Same as Kantan, very solid.

[Muzukashii]
At first sight, I had the impression that it was an easier Oni. Not saying that it was one. Hm, I agree. I think I'm going to make a new Muzukashii.
01:02:795 (1,2,3) - You've used kkd numerous times before, why not here? Is that to make a don pattern of 2 notes ? the pattern kkd is really hard, so I wanted to keep it a bit simple by using a kkk as well. Also trying to emphasize note 01:04:841 (1) - in this way.
01:03:704 (1,2,1) - ^ same here (I think it used to be kkd before) ^
From 01:13:477 (1) - , I think it's a bit empty due to the absence of notes as in 01:13:932 - , 01:15:750 - , 01:21:204 - ... You miss a snare, I think.
Well, all intentionally so I want to keep it in this way.

Another solid map there, that's something I really like. However as I said, it feels like an Oni at times.

[Oni]
00:29:159 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1) - I find that too bad that there's no finish at the end, but either way, I think that would break the whole pattern, unless jirostyle allows for big notes at the end of streams (which would surprise me) well due to pattern constellation and the dislike of using finishers at the beginning of a stanza I keep it as it is.
00:44:386 (1) - Big don here ? We clearly hear a crash, that wouldn't be too much. Same as before. At 00:29:841 (1) - is also none, only at 00:57:113 (1) - which is at the end of the whole pattern section.

Oh man. That's one overly solid mapset. Good job!