forum

Nekomata Master+ feat. JUNE - being torn the sky

posted
Total Posts
64
Topic Starter
Leader
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on giovedì 4 luglio 2013 at 20:51:45

Artist: Nekomata Master+ feat. JUNE
Title: being torn the sky
Source: beatmania IIDX
Tags: 17 SIRIUS Leyko Nemis Electro Pop OST
BPM: 102
Filesize: 4299kb
Play Time: 02:14
Difficulties Available:
  1. Another (4,8 stars, 318 notes)
  2. Hyper (4,48 stars, 250 notes)
  3. Normal (2,52 stars, 144 notes)
Download: Nekomata Master+ feat. JUNE - being torn the sky
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
Hyper by Leyko
Normal by Nemis
riffy
Hey! Will mod 4 food

[General]
  1. Consider adding more tags? Techno and OST tags will fit here!
  2. Why don't you map a [Beginner] diff? first of all, this is your mapset, so we want to see more diffs from you! Secondly, only three diffs for such a short song? Looks like you're too lazy :< THink about mapping a [Beginner] diff!
  3. Try to kieep tick rate consistent? I'd recommend you to keep Slider Tick Rate 2 for all diffs.
  4. Disable letterboxes during breaks? Seems like those letterboxes hurt your cute BG :<
[Standard]
  1. Looks like this diff is the easiest here. Consider reducing HP Drain by one tick to make this diff easier-playable for beginner players.
    Note: If Leader ill map a [Beginner] diff, you should think about reducing HP Drain here, anyway. Just to keep mapset more balanced.
  2. 00:25:639 (3) - try to use circle+1/2 slider here instead? I feel like it will fith background music the way better. example
  3. 00:35:344 - if you agree with the suggestion above, add circle here. The same sound should have the same rhythm :)
  4. 00:46:521 (5) - consider removing that circle, because it doesn't really fits with your rhythm, try to remove it. Pattern sounds much better without it
  5. 00:49:168 (3) - it sounds quite weird, that vocals start in the end of this slider. Try to Ctr+G - 00:49:168 (3,4) this pattern. Don't forget to fix hitsounds after swapping objects!
  6. 00:55:639 (5) - this is the easiest diff, and double-reversed sliders are quite a bad idea here. Why? Because second reverse-arrow appears too son and beginners have no time to notice/read it properly. This is the easiest diff, so replacing your slider with something like this will be a good idea.
  7. 01:34:756 - remove this green line. Seems like this one is not in use. Same for 01:36:227 - this one
  8. 01:46:815 - you can use custom slidertick here to put a clap hitsound here. It will give you consistent clap-pattern.
  9. 02:16:815 - I'd finish the spinner here. It will give you some consistency with other diffs, and it also sounds much better, imo.
[Hyper]
  1. Consider using AR6 and OD/HP:5 to keep mapset more balanced. You will have AR4 on Standard/ AR:6 on Hyper / AR8 on Another. Sounds like a giood idea, right?
  2. 00:37:256 - 00:37:403 - I'd map one or both of those beats to keep consistent rhythm here. Personally, I'd recommend you to try something more creative. Probably this pattern will work here better.
  3. 00:43:286 - you can map that 1/4 triplet that starts here. It will make your rhythm a bit mre interesting for players. You can do it in two ways: 1 and 2. Same rhythm, but second example is alittle bit harder.
  4. 00:53:286 (3) - and 00:55:639 (1,2) - have some repeats and it's hard to guess how many repeats does each slider have. It makes this patten kinda hard to play. Consider using same number of reverses for each slider?
    Note: same as above for 01:13:286 (1,2,3,4). (4) will stress players a lot. Don't trust me? Test it by yourself!
  5. 01:19:756 (6) - x2.5+ jump after 1/4 slider for a calm song may be too hard for plyers. Try to reduce jump distance if it is possible? feel like you don't need to place here tht hard jump
  6. 02:07:403 (4) - 1 grid down for a perfect stack, please. /-Nazi- :3
[Another]
  1. 00:05:933 (4,5,6,7,8) - nazi - you can change direction of this stream, to make this 1/8 slider easier understandable for players. like this
  2. 00:10:639 (4,5) - nazi - I'd prefer to see consistent jumps between those notes. Jump between (4) and (5) flows weird and sounds random :< You can be more creative, this is [Another] diff, after all!
  3. 00:41:227 (8,3) - actually, I should say, that those claps sound pretty weird because there's no any claps in music :V
  4. 00:49:756 (3) - no, really. Those calps don't fit here. Sounds pretty weird. Check the whole map, I bet you'll find out that a lot of claps should be removed.
  5. 00:55:639 (1,2,3) - almost the same as above. But this time you can simply reduce volume of those claps.
  6. 01:21:080 (2,3,4) - 1/4>1/8>1/4 how do you want players to play it? try to replace (2,3,4) with 1/8 slider to make that pattern easier playable.
  7. 01:42:697 (5) - reverse arrow is overlapped with skin elements (scores) and it looks pretty messy here. Can you find a way to avoid that awkward overlap here? I bet you can fix it!
  8. 02:14:462 (1) - can't say that I like your velocity changes here. It is qute hard to play, but it fits here with kiai end. It may confuse players, but as long as this is the hardest diff - it's ok.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Good luck!
Topic Starter
Leader
-Bakari-

-Bakari- wrote:

Hey! Will mod 4 food

[General]
  1. Consider adding more tags? Techno and OST tags will fit here! I'll add some soon.
  2. Why don't you map a [Beginner] diff? first of all, this is your mapset, so we want to see more diffs from you! Secondly, only three diffs for such a short song? Looks like you're too lazy :< THink about mapping a [Beginner] diff! The song is rather calm and I don't see the need of an easier diff than Standard, it will be TOO boring imo.
  3. Try to kieep tick rate consistent? I'd recommend you to keep Slider Tick Rate 2 for all diffs. Ok
  4. Disable letterboxes during breaks? Seems like those letterboxes hurt your cute BG :< You're right!
[Another]
  1. 00:05:933 (4,5,6,7,8) - nazi - you can change direction of this stream, to make this 1/8 slider easier understandable for players. like this Fixed
  2. 00:10:639 (4,5) - nazi - I'd prefer to see consistent jumps between those notes. Jump between (4) and (5) flows weird and sounds random :< You can be more creative, this is [Another] diff, after all! That jump is fine imo, hoping it's not just me.. x.x
  3. 00:41:227 (8,3) - actually, I should say, that those claps sound pretty weird because there's no any claps in music :V Fixed
  4. 00:49:756 (3) - no, really. Those calps don't fit here. Sounds pretty weird. Check the whole map, I bet you'll find out that a lot of claps should be removed. Removed some
  5. 00:55:639 (1,2,3) - almost the same as above. But this time you can simply reduce volume of those claps. I like claps here because you can clearly listen them in the songs, so yeah, reduced volume to ~35%
  6. 01:21:080 (2,3,4) - 1/4>1/8>1/4 how do you want players to play it? try to replace (2,3,4) with 1/8 slider to make that pattern easier playable. Fixed
  7. 01:42:697 (5) - reverse arrow is overlapped with skin elements (scores) and it looks pretty messy here. Can you find a way to avoid that awkward overlap here? I bet you can fix it! My bad, should be fine now
  8. 02:14:462 (1) - can't say that I like your velocity changes here. It is qute hard to play, but it fits here with kiai end. It may confuse players, but as long as this is the hardest diff - it's ok. I'l see what to do soon, I'll keep this for now.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Good luck! Thank you!

Thank you for mod!
Melan Blue

-Bakari- wrote:

Hey! Will mod 4 food
/gives Baka some food :c

[Hyper]
  1. 00:53:286 (3) - and 00:55:639 (1,2) - have some repeats and it's hard to guess how many repeats does each slider have. It makes this patten kinda hard to play. Consider using same number of reverses for each slider? I think most experienced players would pass this part with no problem. o3o So no change.
    Note: same as above for 01:13:286 (1,2,3,4). (4) will stress players a lot. Don't trust me? Test it by yourself! It's fine. :c
Good luck!
Everything else fixed. Thanks! :3
http://puu.sh/2K4kZ.txt
Nemis
All fixed except the difficulty settings.

Duplica il file soft-hitclap2 e rinominalo soft-slidertick3 per favore :D

http://puu.sh/2KGol.osu
DeletedUser_1574070
Good Song~ ( I love nekomata :D )
for m4m
since I'm not a good modder, I've pointed just a simple and trivial things.... sorry.. :(

General
bitrate cool, bg cool.
TAG suggestion : Electro Pop, OST
Please match Audio-Lead-in
Plz Turn off Countdown, Letterbox
Preview Point is not set on Hyper diff

Standard

00:28:580 (1) - Rhythm suggestion. Placement is on your own http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/738096
01:20:344 (1) - the first red-tick will be better if it is placed on (196, 284)

that's all cool map :)

Hyper
00:06:521 (3) - nazi (52, 312) for the balance
01:01:227 (1) - IDK what others would say but I think this is awkward one. I think this one better works here http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/738110
01:34:462 (1) - remove whistle?
01:49:756 (3,4,5,6) - spacing inconsistency (but I think its okay)

Another
Drain 6, OD 8?
Your custom clap is too loud imo..

00:09:756 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,1,2) - here.. too loud considering atmosphere of the song. need lower sample volume
Hyper was fine so do like Hyper OR

here is hitsound suggestion below (You don't have to do this since I thought that pattern is kinda messy one)

  • first 8 circles 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 (FC) (N) (N) (N) (C) (N) (N) (N)
    next 8 circles 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 (C) (N) (C) (N) (C) (N) (C) (N)
    next 4 sliders same
    the last 2 sliders <- keep that
00:21:521 (1) - intentional unstacking?
00:32:697 (5) - not effective stack I think. consider unstacking it
01:52:403 (1) - awkward spinner. I think proceeding this part with notes is better idea.
02:01:227 (3) - to follow vocals as you did, i suggest this rhythm http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/738130

Good Song with Good map! I hope to play this with ranked form :)
DJNightmare
Hey! Here's your mod :3

Blue = Suggestion
Red = Recommended
Green = Comments

Another
00:01:080 (2) - Move up by 1 Grid (level 4 grid)
00:05:050 (1) - Move to the left by 2 grid and down by 1 grid
00:12:697 (3) - Move to the right by 1 grid
00:13:874 (7) - Move to the left by 1 grid
00:17:992 (3) - Perhaps moving to this coordinate? X:0 Y:160
00:19:168 (1) - If ^ is accepted, move this to coordinate X:24 Y:276
00:21:521 (1) - Move to the right by 2 grid
00:31:521 (2) - Move to X:112 Y:124
00:32:403 (4) - Move down by 1 grid
01:21:815 (6) - Move to X:220 Y:320
01:21:962 (7) - Move down by 1 grid
01:31:374 (7) - Move down by 1 grid
01:46:227 (7) - You should add a Crash Cymbal sound to the start of the slider
02:06:080 (2) - Move down by 1 grid
02:16:521 (7) - Move right by 1 grid

Hyper
01:50:344 (5) - Move to the right by 1 grid

Standard
Great Diff :D

Good luck on ranking this map :3
Melan Blue

Kloyd wrote:

Hyper
01:01:227 (1) - IDK what others would say but I think this is awkward one. I think this one better works here http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/738110 Nope. >3<'
01:34:462 (1) - remove whistle? Nope.
01:49:756 (3,4,5,6) - spacing inconsistency (but I think its okay) I think it's okay too. o.o
Everything else fixed(...I hope). :3 Thank you!
http://puu.sh/2NhZi.txt
Kryptogram
Hi !

General


  1. The tags are not the same for every diff, make then the same for every difficult

    Standard: Leyko Nemis
    Hyper: Leyko Nemis Electro Pop OST
    Another: Leyko Nemis Electro Pop OST
Standard

  1. 00:00:345 (1) - A whistle at the begin sounds good whit the instrumental
  2. 00:23:286 (5) - Add a whistle there, it totally fits whit the high sound of the instrumental
  3. 00:56:815 (1) - Add a finish at the begin to follow the instrumental
  4. 01:15:639 (1,2) - This partnern will confuse new players since there is no spacing between those notes they'll confuse when they're gonna hit, try something like this http://puu.sh/2Pm7T.jpg
  5. 01:15:933 (2) - Add a whistle at the begin, it follows the instrumental
  6. 01:18:286 (4) - I think you've missed a clap at the end there since you're following the instrumental, add it
  7. 01:23:286 (4) - Same here, but add it on this note
  8. 01:25:050 (1) - A finish there may sound good whit the song, try it
  9. 01:25:344 (2) - Add a whistle at the begin, to follow the instrumental
  10. 01:27:403 (3) - I think you've missed a clap at the end there since you're following the instrumental, add it
  11. 01:29:756 (1) - Same here
  12. 01:32:109 (4) - Same here
  13. 01:46:227 (1) - Add a finish at the begin to follow the instrumental
  14. 01:53:286 (3) - Make this slider more focused in the shape http://puu.sh/2Pmja.jpg it really looks better
  15. 02:05:050 (1) - Add a finish at the begin to follow the instrumental, aslo i think that slider doesn´t flow very well try something more curve http://puu.sh/2Pmnb.jpg its just a suggestion
Hyper

  1. 00:00:345 (1,2,3) - When i played on the first time i really get confused about the spacing, imo make the space consistent at the begin of a song to get an idea of how the space between the notes should be, then you can add jumps,etc.
  2. 00:09:756 (x) - The sound of this timeline its really low, 30~40 at volume should work better IMO
  3. 00:55:639 (1,2) - I think that the jump between those slider may get confusing while you play, if you end (1) where it started it should play better
  4. 02:14:609 (1) - I think that this slider sounds better if you end it on 02:16:668 (x), try it
Another

  1. 00:01:227 (3) - Make this slider more curve, the shape of it it's really boring and doesn't flow very well http://puu.sh/2PmHP.jpg
  2. 00:03:580 (3) - Same here
  3. 00:09:756 (x) - The sound of this timeline its really low, 30~40 at volume should work better
  4. 00:10:933 (5) - This finish is really unnecessary, remove it
  5. 00:19:168 (1) - To 01:10:639 (6) those finish sounds good at the begin but then you start to hate them, use the same hitsounds technic that the other diffs used it really sounds better, be carefull of how you use hitsounds
  6. 00:25:933 (1,3) - Add a whistle in those notes, that sounds good whit the instrumental
  7. 00:35:344 (1,3) - Same as above
  8. 00:43:286 (4,6) - Same as above
  9. 01:11:521 (1) - Add finish in that spinner and remove it from the begin of the next slider 01:15:933 (1) maybe add a whistle instead of finish
  10. 01:46:227 (7) - Add a finish at the begin at the slider to follow the instrumental
  11. 02:16:962 (1) - I think you should end like the other Diffs, so maybe just end mapping at 02:16:668 (8) i think that spinner at the end really kills the song end and doesn't fit too well there

I like this song it's so relaxing, and you did a great job mapping it, hope my mod was helpfull


Good Luck !
Topic Starter
Leader
Thank you guys!
I'll write what I've fixed soon, I'm kinda lazy now. =w=
Melan Blue

[Te][Amo] wrote:

Hyper

  1. 00:00:345 (1,2,3) - When i played on the first time i really get confused about the spacing, imo make the space consistent at the begin of a song to get an idea of how the space between the notes should be, then you can add jumps,etc. Mmm, I don't wanna remove them ;~; I mean, you can always restart. It prepares you for what's coming next >:D
  2. 00:55:639 (1,2) - I think that the jump between those slider may get confusing while you play, if you end (1) where it started it should play better Any experienced player would just press and hold still, untill the other slider appears. And I don't see no jumps here.
  3. 02:14:609 (1) - I think that this slider sounds better if you end it on 02:16:668 (x), try it Nope. >3<
Thank you for modding! x3
http://puu.sh/2QoaO.txt

Leader baka
Neliel
Yo!

This is my mod, as promised a few days ago. Most changes are just suggestions. You don't have to take my changes. But I think some might look better.
Don't expect a pro mod please :oops: since I am a newbie modder :)

General

There's an inconsistency in Countdown and LetterBoxInBreaks.
Standard has both 1 and hyper and another both 0.

Standard
00:12:109 (4,5) - Make those sliders looking like that : http://puu.sh/2Rbaw.jpg I think this looks better
00:15:050 (2) - Maybe the shape like that : http://puu.sh/2Rbck.jpg
00:33:286 (1) - this http://puu.sh/2Rbe8.jpg ?

Forgot to change my skin :S so don't wonder about the skin changes in the Screenshots lol

00:40:344 (4) - I think this looks better http://puu.sh/2Rbha.jpg
00:56:815 (1) - Maybe finish instead of whistle ?
01:20:344 (1) - The first point of the shape is one to low and the last one, one to high.
01:45:050 (5) - http://puu.sh/2RbqB.jpg

Nothing more to say.
Nice dif :)

Hyper

00:24:756 (2) - Make this one look more like 00:25:344 (3) so the last point of the shape one or two up
01:45:344 (5,6,7,1) - Like this ? http://puu.sh/2RbE3.jpg
02:07:697 (1) - Maybe make this one also curvy like 02:08:286 (2,3)

Nothing more to say :3

Another

I think you overused finish in this dif. It confused me like hell D:
Maybe HPD +1.

00:02:697 (1,2,3) - More like this http://puu.sh/2RbUu.jpg
00:40:050 (7) - This slider looks ugly
00:30:344 (4) - Put this circle on the same position as 00:29:168 (2)

Nothing more to say.

This song is really nice and I like your map.
I hope my mod could help you.
Good luck.
Topic Starter
Leader
Fixed all except HP Drain, thank you! Also re-working on hitsounds =ç=
Melan Blue
All fixed. Thanks! :3 http://puu.sh/2SvNm.txt
Nemis
http://puu.sh/2U6gB.osu
Thanks for suggestions, I applied a lot of them :D
MineC24
Korean Modding queue~ (So Sorry.. I'm late :o )

unicode error..? -> http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/759874

Standard
imo, AR - 1

00:13:286 (5) - Blanket by 00:12:109 (4)
00:39:756 (3) - Blanket by 00:38:580 (2)
01:45:050 (5) - remove red slider point..?
01:53:286 (3) - how about this? ->
02:05:050 (1) - stack by 02:03:874 (5)
02:06:815 (2) - Distance

Hyper
00:55:639 (1,2) - how about this? -> http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/759879
01:19:168 (5) - Move to the left -> 2nd slider point ->
01:30:639 (2,3) - combine into slider
01:53:874 (2) - remove 2nd slider point
02:01:521 (4) - ^

Another
imo, OD - 1
00:59:168 (1) - 2nd slider point -> Grid up
01:20:933 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - looks bad stream shape... move notes

GL :)
Thunderstorm
Hey! =)

Some suggestions

[Overall]
Make aundio lead-in and letterbox during breaks consistent in all diff's

[Standart]
01:18:286 (4) - I'd suggest to do not use hidden notes in easiest diff's since it can be confusing dor newbs
01:27:403 (3) - ^
01:34:756 - maybe put a spinner here instead of break?
02:03:874 (5) - badly overlapping 02:05:050 (1) maing it's start invisible (and it don't looks good also)

[Hyper]
Seems fine

[Another]
I'd suggest to increase SV at 1.8 since 1.4 looks too slow for hardest diff


That's all I can find. Good job
Charles445
Waugh everyone maps the short ver Q_Q
Genshin
allora

[Standard]

cala l'OD a 2

00:07:403 (4) - spacing e stai attento a non farlo uscire dai bordi (cubetti)
00:14:462 (1) - finish nell'inizio dello slider
00:19:756 (2) - blanket fixato>
340,68,19756,2,0,P|336:133|379:182,1,120,2|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
00:28:580 (1) - fuori grid
00:36:815 (5) - (parere personale) per un flow migliore consiglio la curva verso giu'
00:39:756 (3) - muovilo a x105 y232 per sistemare il blanket (leva grid snapping)
00:46:227 (4) - fuori grid
00:53:874 (3) - x395 y272 x fix blanket
01:03:874 (4) - blanket fixato>
158,300,63874,2,0,P|88:314|34:284,2,120,2|8|0,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
01:20:344 (1) - un po' antiestetico, consiglierei qualcosa di migliore
01:52:109 (2) - 1 tick x100 y116, 2 tick x77 y136, 3 tick x59 y178

[Hyper]

01:34:462 (1) - remove nc

[Another]

00:09:756 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - giusto per, cerca di fargli fare una curva piu' omogenea
00:21:521 (1) - stacka con 00:20:933 (4) -
00:40:050 (7) - fixa curva o cambia forma dello slider (consiglio)

done
Topic Starter
Leader
MineC24

MineC24 wrote:

Korean Modding queue~ (So Sorry.. I'm late :o )

unicode error..? -> http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/759874 Fixed x.x
[box=Another]imo, OD - 1 Mhm no, I prefer OD7 for now
00:59:168 (1) - 2nd slider point -> Grid up Done
01:20:933 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - looks bad stream shape... move notes Okay]
Thunderstorm

Thunderstorm wrote:

Hey! =)

Some suggestions

[Overall]
Make aundio lead-in and letterbox during breaks consistent in all diff's They are already fine..?

[Another]
I'd suggest to increase SV at 1.8 since 1.4 looks too slow for hardest diff I like this SV, it's such a calm song and it doesn't need a faster SV.


That's all I can find. Good job
Genshin

Genshin wrote:

[Another]
00:09:756 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - giusto per, cerca di fargli fare una curva piu' omogenea Mi piace così come o.o
00:21:521 (1) - stacka con 00:20:933 (4) - Ok
00:40:050 (7) - fixa curva o cambia forma dello slider (consiglio) Nah

Thank you everyone!
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply