1. Easy (2,61 stars, 235 notes)
2. Hard (4,95 stars, 541 notes)
3. Normal (4,16 stars, 332 notes)
4. Shooting Stars (5 stars, 793 notes)

DakeDekaane wrote:

Hola :v

Modding in English because I'm not used to do it in Spanish ;c
Summoned here via ~ ★ Dake's and Irre's Modding Queue ★ ~
Nice song, here I go~
[Generall]
It seems your mp3 is above 192kbps (320) please change bitrate ;c fixed

[Shooting Stars]
I'll only point some jumps that bothered me a bit, all is nicely done imo ;3
00:26:687 (5,6) - This jump doesn't fit very much in my opinion, as the intensity in vocals isn't increasing that much, you could make something like a pentagon I changed it but not exactly a pentagon, take a look at it :3

SPOILER

.
00:37:473 (5,6) - Same for here, but sadly I can't think in something that doesn't imply make the jump in 00:37:642 (6,1) larger orz made it a bit closer but left the pattern
01:49:777 (2) - No antijumps here, breaks the flow so badly ;w; antijump? that's a stack o.O
02:09:327 (2) - Maybe move this a bit closer to 02:09:159 (1)? I don't see why
02:49:271 (4,5) - Why no long jump here, as previous patterns? fixed

[Hard]
This diff is so nice, just one thing
03:52:810 (4) - This overlap doesn't look very well in my opinion :c fixed

I made a quick look at Normal and Easy but there's nothing I could suggest :c, throwing a star because this map is really good. Good luck o/
When you're done, send PM to Irreversible to receive your second mod ;3

Satellite wrote:

hi~

[General]
title B.O.B → B.o.B ?
Source: http://osu.ppy.sh/b/132873
o.o? It's true, fixed :3

[Shooting Star]
00:34:271 (2) - try Ctrl+G yes
00:37:473 (5) - move x^252 y^164 I don't wanna make square :c
01:11:265 - add note? good idea but it doesn't fit that well D:
01:35:451 (6) - stack is 01:34:945 (3) - here? Why? o.o
02:36:293 (6) - In front of one note I think it is very close. use distance snap? changed
02:41:181 (3,4) - I think it is hard to understand people,So,Newcombo? yes
02:43:878 (4,5) - ^ yess

[Hard]
01:04:355 - remove note is better? yes
03:57:529 (1) - why spinner end is this? 04:00:057 - end 04:02:754 - here? same insane( Normal Easy too ) uh yes, sorry, fixed xD

[Normal]
I can not say anything So,awesome o3o really? thanks !!!

[Easy]
I can not say anything So,awesome.... o3o

sorry,poor english and modding D:
good luck~

1. You should somehow show that Shooting Stars is Insane (Just write it on this text, when you upload it)
2. Remove airplanes from your tags, since it's already in the song's title.
3. I think you can remove 'and' as well.
4. Since the song ends soon, try to lower the hitsounds a bit 03:45:226 (1) - in this part (like 10%)

Suggestion

Suggestion

Haya wrote:

The song name is:
B.o.B feat. Hayley Williams - Airplanes (Feint Remix)

Irreversible wrote:

Hey :3

You'll receive your second mod now haha :b
!! These are only SUGGESTIONS. There is no need to change them! Feel free to, if you like one or two ideas. !!

[General]

1. You should somehow show that Shooting Stars is Insane (Just write it on this text, when you upload it) kk
2. Remove airplanes from your tags, since it's already in the song's title. it's separated, i did it on purpose
3. I think you can remove 'and' as well. it's drum and bass so i think it's okay?
4. Since the song ends soon, try to lower the hitsounds a bit 03:45:226 (1) - in this part (like 10%) I think it's okay like this

[Hard]

First impression: Nice to play, also with hidden, not much to complain here.

01:19:271 (4) - How about moving this one a bit down? It's a bit boring how it currently is. But it's symmetric :c
01:58:709 (1) - I don't really like this stacking, maybe just put it to somewhere else.I like it D:
02:04:102 (1) - You could also move this one a bit down, so the slider end of 4 will be in that curve of 1. done

Suggestion

If you look what i disliked in the Shooting Stars map (i modded it first). Here, I think, it's better. It's the same rhythm yeah, but with this distance snap you can catch it more easily. I think you could make this part the same in the Shooting Stars, since I think it should be a 'break' part, with some easy parts.


[Shooting Stars]

First impression: Very nice beatmap!! love it XD There was only one part i really dislike, it's very confusing.

00:23:990 (3) - I think the flow of this circle isn't that well. You got a curve to the left in your slider, so i recommend some placing to the left of the slider, just for a better flow. uhh yes

Suggestion

00:30:395 (3) - It breaks the flow of your extended slider pattern a bit, but I think a reverse slider fits better here. She's saying no-ow <- somehow like this, that's the reason why. If you do it, delete the next slider as well, otherwise it'll overlap. Hmm i see what you mean but i think it's better like this, let's see if someone else complains
00:37:642 (6) - Move this one to x: 224 y: 248, so it'll form a triangle with 2 and 3. done
00:41:518 (5) - Could you move this one a bit to the right? Imo it's a bit weird if it's that near to a slider (only a little bit ofc) done
00:52:305 (5) - I would move the last white point like this, so it gets a 'curve' in compare with 4. Let me show you what i mean:

Example

[img]http://puu.sh/2zlK2
[/img]

You only have to make the angle of it a bit tighter. But that's not the idea, i wanted to make it fit with the next slider's (1) flow

The part i kinda dislike is this one: 02:31:237 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,1,2,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1) -
It's very confusing, the rhythm in the song (lyrics and beat) sometimes just have no relations with the rhythm created.
02:37:810 (5,1,2) - For exmaple this : If you wanna do something like this, try to lower the DS, since it's so surprising if it's just there.. and yeah :c i hope you know what i mean? I see what you mean and a) it's intentionally tricky. b) lots of people that tried it perfectly read and fced that part. Still, i rearranged some NCs so it's more readable, but it's not that confusing imo.
02:32:586 (1,2,3,4) - Or this one. I think it's a on-going rhythm, but there is a, let's call it break, between 2 and 3. It's really hard to get if you first time play it! I hope you can change some things in that part. as i said before, rearranged ncs and it's better.
02:48:597 (1,2,3) - This is the most confusing one :c i think you have to use DS here badly xD
You know why i did this stuff? The strong beats are the jumps. The rest is just filling the blanks in between the strong beats so it doesnt lose consistence and flow in what keys you have to press. If you can listen properly, you would understeand that the strong beats are the jumps and it feels really good to make jumps while playing on the strong beats

02:57:361 (3) - Move this one a bit up? so it flows better with the slider before. yes
03:07:473 (1) - Make this big slider to a little slider and a circle. rearranged everything
03:08:316 (5) - Remove this one? He doesn't sing anymore.. i think it would be better like that. It also creates some tension for the next circles. nope, i don't like leaving empty blankets in parts that it doesn't fit/there are beats in the music, it makes the map very unconsistent and loses flow

good luck! i hope this was a bit helpful for you.

Louis Cyphre wrote:

[General]
- Use same amount of breaks in all difficulties. That is not necessary, i like it this way

[Shooting Stars]

Name it please "Insane" Instead, I clarified that it is insane in the map's description

Good difficulty, but unfortunatly seems for me a overdone, some insane jumps in my regarding don't fit with music.

00:49:777 (6) - i don't really feel a jump here, you should remove the jump here, it's really pointless. I made it easier/less jumpy, decreased the distance a bit
00:27:024 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - i doubt these patterns might be rankable, you should get some opinions. blue ticks are silenced (i know 5%, but still it's physically silenced) I see no problem with that tbh, not sure if that's unrankeable
02:50:451 - this place can be filled with notes, don't feel like seeing here a break, seriously. Imo it really feels good to make a pause there, it gives much more emotion to the next part.

03:28:372 (5,6,7,8,1) - ctrl+shit+d to make perfect shape of different polygons, after making adjust slider start on last note in that exact polygon. ehh fixed

[Hard]
This one is good, really good. thanks
01:06:125 (1,2) - fix the spacing, please. fixed

[Normal]
Clean difficulty, but i don't approve slowdown sections on easy/normal difficulties. I know, you will not change whole section, but i suggest to avoid any slowdowns on such difficulties, at least take an accent on future maps. I know, wasn't entirely intentional since i forgot to delete timing sections from insane when i mapped this one afterwards, but since the slowdowns are in between breaks i think it's readable

[Easy]
02:58:035 (1,3) - stack perfectly with previous '1' slider. done
03:19:608 (1) - move some grids right i dont see why o.o


Good luck ~

Sieg wrote:

Hello :3

General:
Your combo colors 3 and 4 a way too similar, not a big deal but maybe you can try to find better ones. I will try o.o
You can read my suggestion about drum-hitfinish in normal diff, that as for all spread kk

Easy:
02:31:743 (1) - this may bee too early for Easy. Don't think so :c it's like 2 white ticks away
03:00:057 (3) - make this perfect stack? yes
366,98,180057,2,0,P|323:82|282:93,1,90,2|2,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
03:46:574 (1) - http://puu.sh/2A3Xd for better flow yes

Normal:
00:40:507 (1) - honestly this drum finish fits not so well to song, I can suggest to something like deep bass drop maybe - http://puu.sh/2A4aZ sounds 20% cooler, try please before refusing. Tried and I see what you mean, but that new sample fits better only for parts like 00:41:855 (1) - when it's like a finish of a pattern. I'll take it into account and ask some other people.
00:57:192 (2,2) - turn off grid snap and stack them kk
01:27:361 (2,4) - ^ lol, sorry for just this suggestions but rhythm and flow is good so there is really nothing to point out. haha thanks c: done
01:56:013 (1,3) - ^
02:07:473 (2,2) - ^ done all
03:41:855 (2,3,4) - this circle flow is not so great i know but i cant think of anything better D:
03:47:249 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - http://puu.sh/2A4Ao fixed

Hard:
00:20:451 (1) - start from circle especially that follows vocal and not strong part of music if kinda strange and often plays bad true, fixed
00:41:181 (3,4) - http://puu.sh/2A4QZ this better follows music and lyrics.done
00:43:709 (2,3) - http://puu.sh/2A4TJ your circle placing on start of vocals and slider start in middle is not so smart as it can be. orz hmm but i cant think how to arrange the pattern
01:03:513 (2) - is this necessary? don't seems this is follow anything in song there's a stream in the song
02:37:979 (1,2,3,4) - idk http://puu.sh/2A5bT try something, current one is not playing well yes
03:38:484 (1,2) - try this? http://puu.sh/2A5iP nah its okay like this

Shooting Stars:
00:20:451 (1) - same as for Hard since its an insane and theres music before, i think its okay
00:28:035 (4,1,2,3,4) - is this DS change intended? because this may be confusing and I can't see what this DS increase follows in song. Yeah its something i wanted to try :3
00:46:911 (4,5,6) - ok this is insane, but even insane is a place for random overmap. fixed..
00:49:608 (5,6) - this jump seems too big ^
03:31:911 (2) - ^ fifxed kinda
01:02:080 (1) - oh... okay fixed
01:15:226 (9,10,11) - at least please remove random triplets i removed some already LOL
03:03:091 (5,6,7) - ^ and so on this one fits perfectly imo

Good Luck!

Static Noise Bird wrote:

[General]
Feint = luv <3 yesss

[Easy]
Either map the break after 01:03:428 (1) OR remove 01:10:170 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4) . Same in Normal diff. It's just unfitting. ehhh ill see what others think. I wanted to add some break before the middle one..
02:56:687 (3) - Make the bump @ red point more visible.what do you mean o.o
03:18:260 (3,1) - You could make the overlap like this: I like it more half-overlapped, not completely

SPOILER

If you prefer incomplete overlap, half a circle would do fine (x:120 y:172). But a small touch like this is not cool. done this one
03:26:350 (2) - Move start to x:184 y:336 + a new sliderpoint at x:264 y:364 to avoid overlap and blanket the previous one. the overlap is intentional :c

[Normal]
00:29:720 (1,2,3,4,5) - This pattern could be smoother. fixed
01:27:361 (2) - Stack to (4)'s end. already is o.o
01:34:777 (2) - ^ done
02:03:765 (5) - Stack to (2)'s end.
02:08:484 (2) - ^ done all
Nice diff.

[Hard]
00:30:395 (3,4) - You could combine these into a slider. why D:
Another smooth diff.

[Insane]
00:49:608 (5,6) - Unorthodox jump that doesn't go well with the song. fixed a bit
01:01:574 (4,5,6) - ^ fixed
02:01:743 (3,4,5) - ^ fixed
03:08:316 (4,5) - This is quite fitting jump, but it's too harsh. Reduce a bit. i like this one
03:48:934 (6,7) - Nope. fixed
Nice patterns but ridiculous jumps.

Well, good luck!

E: Huh, I see two faster modders O__O If I have accidentally repeated something, obviously just ignore those.

AnimeStyle wrote:

My Mod


[General]

You should reduce the background image size, it's too big its the widescreen allowed size
Maybe use Fotosizer ->http://www.chip.de/downloads/Fotosizer_28841825.html

03:54:664 - Why 63% volume? Better use 60% Because 63 sounds better o.O
03:57:361 - ^ Use 90%

You have B.O.B already in the title, delete it in the tags the tags have no dots, in case someone searches it like that

[Easy]

01:04:777 - Mabe fill this break? ill see what more ppl say
02:29:215 (1) - Should start at the same time as in the other diffs (I would start all spinners at 02:29:215 like in easy) yes
02:49:945 - Delete the break , at 03:11:518 theres also no break the rest of the diffs have breaks too
03:38:484 (1) - http://puu.sh/2A5yi <- should look like this yes
03:57:698 (1) - Should start at the same time as in the other diffs fixed

[Normal]

01:04:777 (2) - New combo yes
01:04:777 - Why is this break longer then the break in easy at the same time? fix this please what do you mean o.o they are the same
03:11:518 - I wouldn't place it under the sliderend http://puu.sh/2A6nJ yes

[Hard]

02:36:462 (1) - The ratio between this circle and the previous one looks not good in my opinion , maybe change this
02:44:552 (1) - Looks also strange ^ they are good for me
02:47:249 (1,2;4,5) - Should be stacked perfectly its intentional :3

[Shooting Stars]

01:21:968 (4;9) - Should be stacked perfectly changed
02:49:945 - Delete this break why? i added it in the rest of the diffs :3


I hope the mod is helpful :3

Really cool map and song ^^

TMAstraf wrote:

Easy:
All be fine =)

Normal:
00:38:484 put slider so that the circles before not overlay
03:18:260 ^
03:22:979 ^ these are is kinda useless, i see no reason to do these... they only overlap in editor lmao...

Hard:
00:53:147 This is an unhappy place because its underlay 00:51:631 please fix it ah o.o? that note is 2 seconds before, in gameplay you don't even see that
01:48:428 same like above same
01:58:709 this is confused please make distance why? just a stack :3
02:36:462 unhappy place its a stack but a bit moved
02:44:552 ^
02:48:597 ^

Shooting Stars:
Care of the over/underlayed cirlces/sliders =)

Thats all =)