pw384 wrote:

gratz!!

Yumeno Himiko wrote:

goubi

Mirash wrote:

00:39:759 (1,1,1) - no feedback on those downbeat drums feels so cringe lol, could be nice if you drum sampleset them
02:16:879 (3) - missing whistle
02:22:236 (4) - you seem to be following guitar with drum sampleset here, so placing drum sampleset on 02:22:665 (5) - would be nice, right now it sounds empty
03:24:539 (1) - place at least drum sampleset on it
06:53:202 (2) - this should be a drum finish and not a soft whistle, just listen to that drum. also 06:53:405 (3) - 06:54:216 (1) - 06:54:824 (3) - and 06:54:013 (3) - could be drum clap for some rhythm variety. anyway look up this end of section i think it really needs stronger hitsounding feedback
11:06:830 (1,1) - 11:07:571 (1,1) - stacks are broken but thats whatever just pointing out

aside from section on 7 minute this is a good map

Shovan wrote:

Just wanted to ask you if there was any reason behind 06:31:209 (2) - ? It seems to me to only be there to confuse players. Barely any notable sound and the similar vocal sections before (example 06:29:486 (1,2) - ) were always done with 2 circles and not 3...

Aside from that it's a rather nice map and thanks for sharing the Nightwish love OwO

EncoreW wrote:

because of vocal

Shovan wrote:

EncoreW wrote:

because of vocal

That's what i meant with the comparison to other sections. There are clear vocals on the white and red tick of that section, just like for other vocals, but the blue tick is barely notable.

06:24:216 (1,2) - The word is "Listen". White Tick is "Lis", Blue Tick is a held "s" leading into the next syllable. Red tick is "-ten".
06:29:486 (1,2) - White Tick is the impact of the word "Did". The second half of the word (the second "d") is already on the blue tick. The red Tick is "We".
06:31:108 (1,2,3) - White Tick is the impact of the word "Just". The second half of the word (the held "s" that leads in to the next word "t") is already on the blue tick. The red Tick is "to"

Those three sections have the exact same vocal structure to me, but are mapped differently. It is fine to do it with 3 notes, but it is weird because it is done with 2 notes before.

So new question: What is different at 06:31:108 (1,2,3) - that made you put 3 circles? For me the vocals have the same structure.

EncoreW wrote:

06:31:108 (1) - ju 06:31:209 (2) - s 06:31:311 (3) - t to

pw384 wrote:

Hey men mapping is a perceptual activity of human being so it's not a necessity to be picky on things related to such trivial consistency

Shovan wrote:

pw384 wrote:

Hey men mapping is a perceptual activity of human being so it's not a necessity to be picky on things related to such trivial consistency

If you think the existance of a hitobject is trivial then I guess we will never share the same opinion. That being said I'm fully aware that mapping has a lot to do with individual perception
of a song and all I did above was state my perception of the song.