my part of the M4M as requested
Overall fine (a bit unusual) but undermapped style to me
Also I think it lacks big notes, some random examples from the beginning : - 00:29:709 (185) -/- 00:52:982 (339) -/- 01:04:619 (403) -/ etc.
[Oni]
*- 00:08:437 (48,49,50,51,52,53) – try kk dkkd instead of kkdk kd ? plays better imo, also it seems weird to dodge - 00:08:800 – from the melody
*- 00:11:619 (69) – move this to - 00:11:709 – as d? again ^, important sound missed at - 00:11:709 -
*- 00:17:528 (108,109,110,111,112) – maybe swap colors? => D kkkd, I see you try to keep simple mono color patterns but kkkd would emphasize - 00:18:073 (112) – which deserves it
*- 00:29:164 (179,180,181,182) – I don’t mind it but I don’t hear any 1/6 so good luck with the BNs kek (ok there is similar stuff pretty much everywhere tho)
*- 00:35:255 (224,225) – maybe swap colors ? logic with - 00:32:437 (204) -/- 00:38:255 (245) – that are k
*- 00:40:528 (262,263,264) – remove those 3 and add finishers on - 00:40:437 (261) – and - 00:41:346 (270) - ? those 2 really lack the emphasize they deserve imo
*- 01:29:528 -/- 01:32:437 – add k? flows better than the 5-plets alone to me, also it is heavily supported by the song
*- 01:41:528 (656,657,658,659,660,661) - / - 01:44:437 (674,675,676,677,678,679) – refer to 1st/2nd suggestions
*- 01:51:891 -/- 01:54:800 – k ? feels a bit empty while the song isn’t, it doesn’t hurt the following density change that much either
*- 01:59:528 (747) – move to - 01:59:709 - ? sounds better than avoiding the vocal imo
*- 02:08:164 (802,803,804,805) – refer to the 35 sec suggestion, same for - 02:13:619 (842,843,844) – I guess
*- 02:25:346 (919,920,921) – kkkd 1/6 instead ? I think that would support more your double 1/6 choice at - 00:52:255 (331,332,333,334) – for consistency
*- 03:02:619 -/- 03:05:528 – k if you applied the same suggestion in the previous kiai
*- 03:21:528 (1303,1304) -/- 03:22:164 (1310,1311) – free 1/8 keepo
*- 04:00:982 (65) – this would support the song in a better way as a spinner or slider I think, ending before - 04:02:073 – with a k there ?
*- 04:28:437 -/- 04:31:346 – k suggestion again hue
*- 04:41:891 (12,13,14,15,16,17) – kk dkdd ? - 04:44:800 (30,31,32,33,34,35) – kkd kdd ? following my earlier suggestions on similar parts
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
gl
Overall fine (a bit unusual) but undermapped style to me
Also I think it lacks big notes, some random examples from the beginning : - 00:29:709 (185) -/- 00:52:982 (339) -/- 01:04:619 (403) -/ etc.
[Oni]
*- 00:08:437 (48,49,50,51,52,53) – try kk dkkd instead of kkdk kd ? plays better imo, also it seems weird to dodge - 00:08:800 – from the melody
*- 00:11:619 (69) – move this to - 00:11:709 – as d? again ^, important sound missed at - 00:11:709 -
*- 00:17:528 (108,109,110,111,112) – maybe swap colors? => D kkkd, I see you try to keep simple mono color patterns but kkkd would emphasize - 00:18:073 (112) – which deserves it
*- 00:29:164 (179,180,181,182) – I don’t mind it but I don’t hear any 1/6 so good luck with the BNs kek (ok there is similar stuff pretty much everywhere tho)
*- 00:35:255 (224,225) – maybe swap colors ? logic with - 00:32:437 (204) -/- 00:38:255 (245) – that are k
*- 00:40:528 (262,263,264) – remove those 3 and add finishers on - 00:40:437 (261) – and - 00:41:346 (270) - ? those 2 really lack the emphasize they deserve imo
*- 01:29:528 -/- 01:32:437 – add k? flows better than the 5-plets alone to me, also it is heavily supported by the song
*- 01:41:528 (656,657,658,659,660,661) - / - 01:44:437 (674,675,676,677,678,679) – refer to 1st/2nd suggestions
*- 01:51:891 -/- 01:54:800 – k ? feels a bit empty while the song isn’t, it doesn’t hurt the following density change that much either
*- 01:59:528 (747) – move to - 01:59:709 - ? sounds better than avoiding the vocal imo
*- 02:08:164 (802,803,804,805) – refer to the 35 sec suggestion, same for - 02:13:619 (842,843,844) – I guess
*- 02:25:346 (919,920,921) – kkkd 1/6 instead ? I think that would support more your double 1/6 choice at - 00:52:255 (331,332,333,334) – for consistency
*- 03:02:619 -/- 03:05:528 – k if you applied the same suggestion in the previous kiai
*- 03:21:528 (1303,1304) -/- 03:22:164 (1310,1311) – free 1/8 keepo
*- 04:00:982 (65) – this would support the song in a better way as a spinner or slider I think, ending before - 04:02:073 – with a k there ?
*- 04:28:437 -/- 04:31:346 – k suggestion again hue
*- 04:41:891 (12,13,14,15,16,17) – kk dkdd ? - 04:44:800 (30,31,32,33,34,35) – kkd kdd ? following my earlier suggestions on similar parts
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
gl