a
[Normal]
00:03:482 (1,2) - why is the slidershape different from 00:00:054 (1,2) ? 00:00:054 (1,2) was a curved slider into a straight one and here it’s the opposite while nothing in the song calls for a clear change in shapes ; inconsistencies within slider shapes happen regularly in the map so I suggest you look out for them throughout
00:06:911 (1) - inconsistent rhythm with 00:00:054 (1,2)
00:18:482 (2,3,4) - rhythm getting different here as well for no reason
00:35:625 (2,3) - stacked notes into a slider are already being used for other hitsounds ( 00:18:482 (2,3) ), so it might get confusing to use them here
00:43:768 (3) - I don’t know how I feel about putting piano and vocals within the same slider… maybe remove reverse arrow and add a circle at 00:44:625 ?
00:51:482 (1,1) - why 1/1 sliders here ? it’s being inconsistent with 00:48:053 (1,2) as well as missing the drums at 00:51:911 while it’s perfectly doable to catch them in a normal. Also, it leaves the snare un-clickable while it’s clickable before, so the emphasis is inconsistent as well
00:53:196 (3) - same thing with snare being un-clickable
Again all the rhythm problems I’ve talked about are here as well afterwards so I’m not gonna mention the same thing twice
[Metaku’s Hard]
00:07:768 (2,3) - the transition between those 2 looks different than the one at 00:00:911 (2,3), because 00:00:911 (2) is at an angle that looks kinda like the continuity of 00:01:339 (3)’s curve, while here the angle looks otherwise ; should be fixed with a rotation of 00:01:339 (3)
00:21:482 (2,3) - here the flow isn’t changed while it was earlier at 00:14:625 (3,4) for example, so it should be for the sake of consistency
00:23:839 - I think you’re missing on a cymbal here
00:58:339 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - you were following the vocals for the entire kiai, why did you not carry on here ?
01:01:768 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - rhythm here is inconsistent with 01:01:768 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) while both measures are identical
[Hazu’s Light Insane]
00:30:911 (1,2,3,4) - this is a different rhythm from 00:27:482 (1,2,3,4,5) while it’s the same drum pattern, should be more consistent
00:35:839 (4) - red tick slider feels weird here since you’re following the drums which traditionally emphasise white ticks
00:42:053 (2) - I don’t really like having piano and vocal on the same slider here but it’s up to you here
00:44:625 (1) - could be more polished
00:48:911 (3) - pretty sure you wanted to make a very slightly curved slider but this is a straight one despite having 3 anchors
00:54:911 (1) - this one feels a bit out of place cause it’s the only slider that starts a measure and has clear curves
01:09:482 (3) - once again this feels out of place due to being the only one with such a clear curve
01:23:542 (3,4) - why a stack here ? it’s the only time in the phrase there’s one so it feels out of place
[Fate]
00:03:482 (1) - not correctly centered, move it up there
00:04:339 (3) - once again there are rhythm inconsistencies ; there were 2 sliders at 00:00:911 (3,4) for an identical measure, so there should be 2 sliders here as well
00:18:053 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - where’s the pattern from 00:14:625 (1,2,3,4,5) ?
00:38:625 (3) - idk this looks kinda weird for some reason
01:02:411 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - back at it again with inconsistencies in rhythm
01:10:339 (1,2,1) - curves here feel out of place since all the rest of the phrase is made out of straight sliders
[Normal]
00:03:482 (1,2) - why is the slidershape different from 00:00:054 (1,2) ? 00:00:054 (1,2) was a curved slider into a straight one and here it’s the opposite while nothing in the song calls for a clear change in shapes ; inconsistencies within slider shapes happen regularly in the map so I suggest you look out for them throughout
00:06:911 (1) - inconsistent rhythm with 00:00:054 (1,2)
00:18:482 (2,3,4) - rhythm getting different here as well for no reason
00:35:625 (2,3) - stacked notes into a slider are already being used for other hitsounds ( 00:18:482 (2,3) ), so it might get confusing to use them here
00:43:768 (3) - I don’t know how I feel about putting piano and vocals within the same slider… maybe remove reverse arrow and add a circle at 00:44:625 ?
00:51:482 (1,1) - why 1/1 sliders here ? it’s being inconsistent with 00:48:053 (1,2) as well as missing the drums at 00:51:911 while it’s perfectly doable to catch them in a normal. Also, it leaves the snare un-clickable while it’s clickable before, so the emphasis is inconsistent as well
00:53:196 (3) - same thing with snare being un-clickable
Again all the rhythm problems I’ve talked about are here as well afterwards so I’m not gonna mention the same thing twice
[Metaku’s Hard]
00:07:768 (2,3) - the transition between those 2 looks different than the one at 00:00:911 (2,3), because 00:00:911 (2) is at an angle that looks kinda like the continuity of 00:01:339 (3)’s curve, while here the angle looks otherwise ; should be fixed with a rotation of 00:01:339 (3)
00:21:482 (2,3) - here the flow isn’t changed while it was earlier at 00:14:625 (3,4) for example, so it should be for the sake of consistency
00:23:839 - I think you’re missing on a cymbal here
00:58:339 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - you were following the vocals for the entire kiai, why did you not carry on here ?
01:01:768 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - rhythm here is inconsistent with 01:01:768 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) while both measures are identical
[Hazu’s Light Insane]
00:30:911 (1,2,3,4) - this is a different rhythm from 00:27:482 (1,2,3,4,5) while it’s the same drum pattern, should be more consistent
00:35:839 (4) - red tick slider feels weird here since you’re following the drums which traditionally emphasise white ticks
00:42:053 (2) - I don’t really like having piano and vocal on the same slider here but it’s up to you here
00:44:625 (1) - could be more polished
00:48:911 (3) - pretty sure you wanted to make a very slightly curved slider but this is a straight one despite having 3 anchors
00:54:911 (1) - this one feels a bit out of place cause it’s the only slider that starts a measure and has clear curves
01:09:482 (3) - once again this feels out of place due to being the only one with such a clear curve
01:23:542 (3,4) - why a stack here ? it’s the only time in the phrase there’s one so it feels out of place
[Fate]
00:03:482 (1) - not correctly centered, move it up there
00:04:339 (3) - once again there are rhythm inconsistencies ; there were 2 sliders at 00:00:911 (3,4) for an identical measure, so there should be 2 sliders here as well
00:18:053 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - where’s the pattern from 00:14:625 (1,2,3,4,5) ?
00:38:625 (3) - idk this looks kinda weird for some reason
01:02:411 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - back at it again with inconsistencies in rhythm
01:10:339 (1,2,1) - curves here feel out of place since all the rest of the phrase is made out of straight sliders