FruityEnLoops wrote:

hmmm meta seems wrong :thinking:
iamkwan seems to be wrong

meta from official MP3

Général
Complete name : 06 Petals.mp3
Format : MPEG Audio
File size : 13,5 Mio
Duration : 5mn 46s
Overall bit rate mode : Constant
Overall bit rate : 320 Kbps
Album : Secretale
Part/Position : 1
Part/Total : 1
Track name : Petals
Track name/Position : 06
Track name/Total : 10
Performer : かめりあ & ななひら
Writing library : LAME3.99r
Cover : Yes
Cover type : Cover (front)
Cover MIME : image/jpeg

the artist should be Camellia ft. Nanahira, and camellia should not only be in the tags
gratz on ranking though! i'll be happy to play it!
(plz don't disqualify for this)

Doormat wrote:

just saying, but they provided an official source for the metadata whereas you didn't; I did this can hardly be considered as legitimate or correct. the source they provided shows that Nanahira is the artist, so current metadata is acceptable.

that being said, gl with requalification toybot~

FruityEnLoops wrote:

Doormat wrote:

just saying, but they provided an official source for the metadata whereas you didn't; I did this can hardly be considered as legitimate or correct. the source they provided shows that Nanahira is the artist, so current metadata is acceptable.

that being said, gl with requalification toybot~

So, if you want proof of what i'm saying :
Here's the MP3 : https://puu.sh/wr6Jt/bdb1bacf58.mp3
Source : http://hikarinoakariost.info/c91-confet ... secretale/
Check the ID3 tags.
It's just like the one in the box on my post ^.
This song is an Utaite by Nanahira, and the original creator is Camellia.

Doormat wrote:

you're missing the point. the link you provided is not an official source by the artist, so it doesn't matter if the mp3 claims it is "official" because it can't be proven. the website link that IAmKwan provided, however, is an official source by the artist, so that's why current metadata is acceptable.

please learn about using proper sources before making claims about wrong metadata.

AKIBA-HOBBY wrote:

06.Petals
イラスト：鍵空富焼
作編曲：かめりあ作詞：かめりあ

FruityEnLoops wrote:

k den
http://ec.akbh.jp/products/detail.php?p ... 0000071753

AKIBA-HOBBY wrote:

06.Petals
イラスト：鍵空富焼
作編曲：かめりあ作詞：かめりあ

which translated with google translate gives "Work Arrangement: Camelia Lyrics: Camelia" that's the composer; the vocalist is still nanahira and doesn't prove my point, since it's usually the vocalist that gets credited as the artist

https://www.melonbooks.co.jp/detail/det ... _id=196071
かめりあ (Camellia) is listed in the artist section so are Nanahira, Harunaba, Massive New Knew, etc. should we include them in the artist as well? this link isn't specific enough as to who did which track

https://diverse.direct/confetto/cfcd-0013/
Again, Camellia is listed same as the first link

btw, AKIBA, Melonbooks and diverse direct links are official retailers of secretale official retailer links aren't considered official sources

hikarinoakariost's mp3s are from diverse direct most of the time, but ofc I can't prove it. just saying. and i could easily change the ID3 tags from the .mp3 file; it doesn't mean that it'll be correct though. just saying.

Doormat wrote:

that's the composer; the vocalist is still nanahira and doesn't prove my point, since it's usually the vocalist that gets credited as the artist see at the bottom

so are Nanahira, Harunaba, Massive New Knew, etc. should we include them in the artist as well? this link isn't specific enough as to who did which track just pushing up the fact that Camellia participated in the making of the song

same as the first link

[b]official retailer links aren't considered official sources LOL

and i could easily change the ID3 tags from the .mp3 file; it doesn't mean that it'll be correct though. just saying. that's why I linked where I got the files, if you wanted to verify if I didn't changed the IDT3... idk why would I do that though

Wikipedia wrote:

An artist is a person engaged in an activity related to creating art, practicing the arts, or demonstrating an art.

KittyAdventure wrote:

Nanahira is fine as artist, same case like yf_bmp's map and Janpai's map

p/5458448#p5458448
p/5525872#p5525872

Doormat wrote:

the link you provided is not an official source by the artist

FruityEnLoops wrote:

KittyAdventure wrote:

Nanahira is fine as artist, same case like yf_bmp's map and Janpai's map

p/5458448#p5458448
p/5525872#p5525872

lol, so another song is a source for this one
as doormat would say

Doormat wrote:

the link you provided is not an official source by the artist

Poncho wrote:

Why was this ranked with the wrong metadata??? it should be Camellia feat. Nanahira!! it even says it in the banner included in the description!!!!!