forum

Floating Cloud - Makuai ~Amefuru Mori~

posted
Total Posts
30
Topic Starter
Ekoro
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on jeudi 5 février 2015 at 22:32:10

Artist: Floating Cloud
Title: Makuai ~Amefuru Mori~
Source: 東方Project
Tags: toshimasa irish The Gods Give Us Blessed Rain Sylphid Dream staff roll theme zun arrangement remix instrumental touhou intermission ~rainy forest~ c79 comiket 東方アイリッシュ 東方風神録 ~ Mountain of Faith
BPM: 98
Filesize: 2089kb
Play Time: 01:31
Difficulties Available:
  1. Easy (0,89 stars, 44 notes)
  2. Rain (1,24 stars, 59 notes)
Download: Floating Cloud - Makuai ~Amefuru Mori~
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
Neil Watts
cc
little mod from a noob modder

Floating Cloud - Intermission ~rainy forest~~

- Le style de mapping est intéressant mais impose un low CS. Je ne sais honnêtement pas si c'est rankable, il faudrait peut-être contacter un BAT/QAT pour avoir la confirmation.
- Je pense qu'essayer d'utiliser un autre style de hitsounds pourrait être intéressant. Parce que bon, les soft whistles c'est bien, mais classique xD
Si tu as un custom hitsound en réserve, tu peux tester. Sinon, bah, essaye les drums ? ._.
- Donne un nom original à ta Easy diff. Par exemple, si un jour tu veux créer une Hard (bon courage...) tu peux la nommer Storm. owo
- L'ajout d'un spinner dans les deux diffs serait envisageable.

[Easy]
- 00:11:832 (1,2) - j'ai comme l'impression qu'elles sont pas en rythme, ces deux là, à voir. As-tu essayé de les placer sur le même BPM que les autres, tout simplement ? L'utilisation d'un beat snap plus grand ne devrait pas poser de problème.
Aussi je te conseillerais d'utiliser un slider, car ces deux-là particulièrement sont plus difficiles à cliquer en rythme que les autres.
- 00:15:593 (2,1) - les rendre parallèles serait pas mal imo. Et pourquoi pas leur donner une forme originale.
- 00:53:501 (2) - waaat, 1/8, pas d'autre choix?
- 01:12:821 (2) - supprime ce slider et reprends à 01:14:941 - ça donne plus de sens

[Rain]
- 00:18:202 (1) - alors ici tu mets un whistle à la reverse arrow mais pas à la fin du slider ? Pourtant il s'agit de sons identiques.
- 00:46:898 (4) - c pa bo
- 01:12:821 (1,2,3,4,5) - faudrait savoir ce que tu mappes. Les notes en premier ou arrière plan. Surtout que là ça fait un bond de difficulté soudain et, hm... Je ne sais pas si c'est rankable.

Voilà voilà :D
Topic Starter
Ekoro

Neil Watts wrote:

cc
little mod from a noob modder

Floating Cloud - Intermission ~rainy forest~~

- Le style de mapping est intéressant mais impose un low CS. Je ne sais honnêtement pas si c'est rankable, il faudrait peut-être contacter un BAT/QAT pour avoir la confirmation. Irre's Extra *coughs* Plus c'est lent, plus j'"impose" un low CS, je fais comme ça avec les relax maps.
- Je pense qu'essayer d'utiliser un autre style de hitsounds pourrait être intéressant. Parce que bon, les soft whistles c'est bien, mais classique xD
Si tu as un custom hitsound en réserve, tu peux tester. Sinon, bah, essaye les drums ? ._. Oui c'classique mais j'ai rien d'autre. J'pense que les soft whistles vont bien avec. Sur Kappa Booty j'ai eu l'idée des custom direct, mais ici rien ne m'inspire.
- Donne un nom original à ta Easy diff. Par exemple, si un jour tu veux créer une Hard (bon courage...) tu peux la nommer Storm. owo >rules about diffs. Je l'aurai déjà fait, un truc genre Rain/Deluge (sorry CtB players), mais ça va complain dessus. Pareil sur toutes les autres maps, surtout Kappa Booty (again), où j'aurai mis Beach/Aqua en spread.
- L'ajout d'un spinner dans les deux diffs serait envisageable. Sauf le dernier slider, j'vois pas où j'peux le mettre. Pour l'instant j'garde mon slider, je verrai ensuite.

[Easy]
- 00:11:832 (1,2) - j'ai comme l'impression qu'elles sont pas en rythme, ces deux là, à voir. As-tu essayé de les placer sur le même BPM que les autres, tout simplement ? L'utilisation d'un beat snap plus grand ne devrait pas poser de problème.
Aussi je te conseillerais d'utiliser un slider, car ces deux-là particulièrement sont plus difficiles à cliquer en rythme que les autres. Elles le sont pas, quand j'ai essayé de map, j'ai remarqué que c'était plus rapide que les autres. Toute façon, pour moi, le long slider qui vient ensuite donne une impression de "doute" au joueur, fin il sait pas si le bpm va changer ou pas, au final.. J'pense qu'elles sont faciles à hit. uwu
- 00:15:593 (2,1) - les rendre parallèles serait pas mal imo. Et pourquoi pas leur donner une forme originale. J'allais faire un pavé à propos des lignes droites jusqu'à ce que je trouve un léger arrangement. fixed
- 00:53:501 (2) - waaat, 1/8, pas d'autre choix? Non, j'ai vérifié.
- 01:12:821 (2) - supprime ce slider et reprends à 01:14:941 - ça donne plus de sens j'hésitais à le faire, au final ouais c'mieux. done

[Rain]
- 00:18:202 (1) - alors ici tu mets un whistle à la reverse arrow mais pas à la fin du slider ? Pourtant il s'agit de sons identiques. C'est le même son que 00:17:550, et en plus imo ça sonne mieux. Les deux sons sont légèrement différents, mais j'pense que ça sonne bien comme ça.
- 00:46:898 (4) - c pa bo rythme. J'y peux rien (ou presque).
- 01:12:821 (1,2,3,4,5) - faudrait savoir ce que tu mappes. Les notes en premier ou arrière plan. Surtout que là ça fait un bond de difficulté soudain et, hm... Je ne sais pas si c'est rankable. Je mappe en suivant la mélodie principale. Le seul endroit où ça peut poser problème, c'est ce slider 01:15:593 qui suit l'arrière-plan. Je l'ai corrigé par contre, et le reste je garde.

Voilà voilà :D
thanks Neil, parfois j'ai pas eu le choix, la musique m'a "contraint" à mapper comme ça. c:
Nozhomi
Coucou Ekopro :D

- General :
  1. Fix ce que te dit l'AiMod ! (192 Kpbs / mp3 trop long même si reste à voir / preview point à définir)
- Rain :
  1. 00:46:898 - Le rythme est bof ici. Je te propose celui-ci pour plus suivre la flûte qui sera plus adapté :
  2. 01:13:963 (3,4,5) - Je sais que c'est pas facile, mais essaye de leurs donner un peu plus d'espace, ca fait vraiment compacté avec le high CS.
  3. 01:16:734 (3) - Go pour un 1/4 slider, ça colle parfaitement avec la flûte.
  4. 01:26:028 (1,2) - Je serais plus partant pour un long slider. Ca fait super vide avec la longue note sur la musique.
  5. 01:31:245 (1) - Tu peux améliorer le blanket un peu, et btw le point de fin est hors de la grille alors qu'il est au centre du cercle c'est pas rankable.
- Easy :
  1. 00:35:811 (2,2) - Stack les.
  2. 00:36:463 (3) - Courbe le un peu plus pour améliorer la transition avec 00:39:071 (1) - .
  3. 00:39:071 (1) - Pareil.
  4. 00:53:501 (2) - Ne le fait pas partir sur du 1/8 par pitié. C'est la plus facile des diffs alors fait le commencer à 00:53:419 - , et ça ne choque pas tant que ça à l'écoute.
  5. 00:59:289 (3) - Petite erreur de DS (1.11x au lieu de ~1.20x)
  6. 01:13:637 - Peut être add un circle ici mais c'est purement mon avis.
  7. 01:28:637 (3) - Un poil plus courbé pour le flow.

Petit mod pour une petite map relax super cool. Let's go la rank :D
Mukyu~ (star +1)
Topic Starter
Ekoro
hi, here is your fix

Nozhomi wrote:

Coucou Ekopro :D

- General :
  1. Fix ce que te dit l'AiMod ! (192 Kpbs / mp3 trop long même si reste à voir / preview point à définir) eeeeeeeee fuck, j'peux fix ça plus tard? XD
- Rain :
  1. 00:46:898 - Le rythme est bof ici. Je te propose celui-ci pour plus suivre la flûte qui sera plus adapté : Tu sais pas comment j'ai réfléchi pour trouver un arrangement à ce pattern hue, fixed
  2. 01:13:963 (3,4,5) - Je sais que c'est pas facile, mais essaye de leurs donner un peu plus d'espace, ca fait vraiment compacté avec le high CS.
  3. 01:16:734 (3) - Go pour un 1/4 slider, ça colle parfaitement avec la flûte. Je sais pas trop... Je verrai si j'le garde.
  4. 01:26:028 (1,2) - Je serais plus partant pour un long slider. Ca fait super vide avec la longue note sur la musique. done
  5. 01:31:245 (1) - Tu peux améliorer le blanket un peu, et btw le point de fin est hors de la grille alors qu'il est au centre du cercle c'est pas rankable. sais pas si ce que j'ai fait est mieux, tbh... (+ fk off blanket ;w;)
- Easy :
  1. 00:35:811 (2,2) - Stack les. no, ça fait un bon triangle pattern avec le suivant, qui lui même fait un triangle pattern avec tout le reste !
  2. 00:36:463 (3) - Courbe le un peu plus pour améliorer la transition avec 00:39:071 (1) - Justement, le (1) est le (3) flip à 120°, donc je préfère que ça soit comme ça !
  3. 00:39:071 (1) - Pareil. same
  4. 00:53:501 (2) - Ne le fait pas partir sur du 1/8 par pitié. C'est la plus facile des diffs alors fait le commencer à 00:53:419 - , et ça ne choque pas tant que ça à l'écoute. Franchement, au playback rate 25%, je pense vraiment qu'on peut distinguer ça, et bon, j'préfère encore le mettre dans le bon timing... Je verrai avec d'autres suggestions si c'est vraiment pas possible de le garder.
  5. 00:59:289 (3) - Petite erreur de DS (1.11x au lieu de ~1.20x) oops
  6. 01:13:637 - Peut être add un circle ici mais c'est purement mon avis. Ca fait vraiment un rythme bizarre avec ce cercle, non?
  7. 01:28:637 (3) - Un poil plus courbé pour le flow. J'pense que le flow est correct ici

Petit mod pour une petite map relax super cool. Let's go la rank :D
Mukyu~ (star +1)
thanks ! :3
Kaguya Hourain
modbox
01:36 Ekoro: mod [Rain] diff first
01:36 Ekoro: i'll fix it fastly on [Easy] :v
01:37 Kaguya Hourain: 00:15:593 (2,1) - maybe you should move 1 lower and right to uhhhh
01:37 Kaguya Hourain: make the flow smoother
01:38 Kaguya Hourain: 00:28:637 (1) - this slider ends on the blue tick btw
01:38 Kaguya Hourain: 00:53:501 (1) - HOLY MOTHER OF WEIRD
01:39 Kaguya Hourain: 01:23:256 (2,3) - you should lower the spacing for this maybe into 2/3 of the circle in or something
01:39 Ekoro: 1) i don't think that's necessary, i think it works
01:40 Kaguya Hourain: it works but it would play nicer
01:40 Ekoro: i just moved the (2) higher to make a better triangle pattern, that's all to me
01:40 Kaguya Hourain: than it currently does
01:40 Kaguya Hourain: well uh
01:40 Kaguya Hourain: that would work i guess
01:40 Ekoro: 2) fixed
01:40 Ekoro: 3) THE SONG DOESN'T HELP ME
01:40 Kaguya Hourain: yea :D
01:40 Kaguya Hourain: the last one I find 0,6 DS to work nicely
01:41 Ekoro: done !
01:41 Kaguya Hourain: yea that's all basicalluy
01:42 Ekoro: uploaded Easy diff btw
01:42 Ekoro: there is one thing i deleted but i put back because that's the best thing for me
01:42 Ekoro: 01:10:376 (1,2) -
01:42 Kaguya Hourain: 00:28:637 (1) - same thing as rain
01:42 Kaguya Hourain: and btw I think OD3 is okay for easy
01:43 Kaguya Hourain: since it makes it too easy at 1,5 right now
01:43 Ekoro: rain could have been the easy diff, you know
01:43 Kaguya Hourain: indeed
01:43 Ekoro: low OD for this kind of map is my way of settings
01:43 Kaguya Hourain: still ar=od the best way to go
01:43 Kaguya Hourain: always
01:43 Kaguya Hourain: but anyway
01:44 Ekoro: here it's CS=AR and OD=HP
01:44 Kaguya Hourain: 00:46:898 (3) - this ends 1/8 later
01:44 Ekoro: well CS=AR only works in Rain diff
01:44 Kaguya Hourain: those settings don't make sense
01:44 Kaguya Hourain: they're just personal quirks
01:44 Kaguya Hourain: ar should = od because of mechanics
01:44 Kaguya Hourain: of the game
01:44 Kaguya Hourain: not because of my personal preference
01:45 Ekoro: well mapping is mostly based on personal preference
01:45 Ekoro: how do you think i map, then
01:45 Kaguya Hourain: mapping is one thing
01:45 Ekoro: i would put less streams in everything will freeze to make everyone pleased?
01:45 Ekoro: if i'm happy with it then it's okay
01:45 Ekoro: if i can't rank it then fuck off, i'll keep it as that
01:45 Kaguya Hourain: like i said
01:45 Kaguya Hourain: mapping is one thing
01:45 Kaguya Hourain: diffsettings are different
01:45 Ekoro: that's why i hate modding, it feels like your map isn't yours anymore
01:45 Ekoro: :/
01:46 Kaguya Hourain: and like i told you
01:46 Kaguya Hourain: there are mechanics for the game
01:46 Kaguya Hourain: which suggest that ar should be equal to od
01:46 Ekoro: okay
01:46 Ekoro: let me change OD in Time Freeze to 10 then
01:46 Kaguya Hourain: i would actually
01:46 Kaguya Hourain: love that
01:46 Kaguya Hourain: 3
01:46 Kaguya Hourain: :3
01:46 Ekoro: ._.
01:47 Ekoro: i don't think that's necessary
01:47 Kaguya Hourain: well too many people would bitch about it
01:47 Ekoro: 9 is already crazy why would i do worse
01:47 Kaguya Hourain: it should not be lower than od9 though
01:47 Kaguya Hourain: because of notelock
01:48 Kaguya Hourain: well uh i got nothing on easy
01:48 Kaguya Hourain: other than that one thing
01:48 Kaguya Hourain: or two things lel
01:48 Ekoro: 4.5/2.5/2.5/1.5
01:48 Ekoro: if this isn't enough i'll go back to my old settings
01:49 Kaguya Hourain: well 2,5 is better than 1,5
01:49 Ekoro: lowered AR to 5.5 in Rain, increased OD to 4.5, increased HP to 4
01:49 Kaguya Hourain: oh i didn't even notice the high ar in rain XD
01:49 Kaguya Hourain: well okay
Cherry Blossom
As promised
ET RANK CETTE MAP SINON JE TE TUE, PARCE QUE SA ME SOULE DE VOIR QUE T'ABANDONNES TOUTES TES PENDINGS.

General

  1. Since you don't have any sb, disable widecscreen support on each diffs.
  2. Using muted slidertick is unrankable, you must make slidertick audible.

Easy

  1. 00:25:376 (3) - Adjust distance with this object, the difference is a little noticeable.
  2. 00:28:637 (1) - end this slider on the downbeat later, you still can hear something if you listen to this part with 25% speed. And it will also avoid the polarity issue between this and the next object.
  3. 01:18:202 (2) - adjust the distance with 01:15:593 (1,2) - , you see a lower distance compared to 01:12:821 (2,1) - for example.

Normal

  1. 01:18:202 (1) - adjust the distance here, you see that the distance between 01:17:224 (4,1) - is not the same as 01:18:202 (1,2) -

I really have doubts concerning timing, many objects sound offbeat, if you listen carefully with 25% speed.
Try to get a timing check by an experienced modder/BAT. And then i will be able to do something to push this map forward.
Topic Starter
Ekoro

Cherry Blossom wrote:

As promised
ET RANK CETTE MAP SINON JE TE TUE, PARCE QUE SA ME SOULE DE VOIR QUE T'ABANDONNES TOUTES TES PENDINGS. i'll try ♥

General

  1. Since you don't have any sb, disable widecscreen support on each diffs. yep
  2. Using muted slidertick is unrankable, you must make slidertick audible. done!

Easy

  1. 00:25:376 (3) - Adjust distance with this object, the difference is a little noticeable. done, x1,23 spacing between each object here
  2. 00:28:637 (1) - end this slider on the downbeat later, you still can hear something if you listen to this part with 25% speed. And it will also avoid the polarity issue between this and the next object. It seems that it ends at the yellow tick, but i'm not really sure to leave it on white tick... Let's see what next modders will say, hm.
  3. 01:18:202 (2) - adjust the distance with 01:15:593 (1,2) - , you see a lower distance compared to 01:12:821 (2,1) - for example. fixed!

Normal

  1. 01:18:202 (1) - adjust the distance here, you see that the distance between 01:17:224 (4,1) - is not the same as 01:18:202 (1,2) - my bad, i changed this part and i forgot to fix that slider. done !

I really have doubts concerning timing, many objects sound offbeat, if you listen carefully with 25% speed.
Try to get a timing check by an experienced modder/BAT. And then i will be able to do something to push this map forward.
I checked, and i added a 90 BPM section for the first slider, then 92 for the whole map. It sounds way better, actually you were right, every note was delayed 1/16 earlier, and it's fixed now. Except for two sliders which i can't change because the song is like that, flute too strong ;_;

Thanks a lot for your mod, CB!
Floating Cloud
:) I just want to see why BanchoBot hightlighted me in osu! just now lol
have a good time~ Bonne chance
Kyubey
\o
We've talked about general things yesterday, as mp3 / source / ending <80% / circle size, and now I'm going to mod it more.
[General]
Romanised Title should be "Makuai ~Amefuru Mori~". You can add your current title to the tags though.
You can add these tags: "c79 comiket 東方アイリッシュ 東方風神録 ~ Mountain of Faith" 東方アイリッシュ is album title and 東方風神録 ~ Mountain of Faith is game title.
[Easy]
maybe increase overall distance snap by 0.1? I don't really like how is every object touching each other, looks really unpolished
00:11:877 (1) - i wouldn't recommend to start easy/normal difficulty with notes because it can be hard to get 300 here, because you don't hear any rhythm before
[Rain]
A lot of unsnapped things. But you can leave them, because I asked TicClick for help with timing and he promised to provide it at evening.
00:11:877 (1) - same thing as with Easy
01:14:048 (3,4) - this pattern is pretty clustered and hard to read, maybe better to leave that sound and use 2 1/2 sliders?
01:16:819 (3) - how about using slider here that ends here 01:17:312 - here? will looks much easier with that kickslider before that looks questionable
01:23:341 (2) - you didn't use such a "fast" notes before, maybe better to ignore this sound and delete that note? it looks just pretty sudden because you didn't use it before and can be pretty hard

Now let's wait for TicClick.
Topic Starter
Ekoro

Kyubey wrote:

\o o/
We've talked about general things tomorrow, as mp3 / source / ending <80% / circle size, and now I'm going to mod it more. yeye
[General]
Romanised Title should be "Makuai ~Amefuru Mori~". You can add your current title to the tags though. done
You can add these tags: "c79 comiket 東方アイリッシュ 東方風神録 ~ Mountain of Faith" 東方アイリッシュ is album title and 東方風神録 ~ Mountain of Faith is game title. done
[Easy]
maybe increase overall distance snap by 0.1? I don't really like how is every object touching each other, looks really unpolished Objects weren't supposed to touch each other but since the rules "doesn't allow low CS", it makes it like that ! Changed to x1.3 anyway.
00:11:877 (1) - i wouldn't recommend to start easy/normal difficulty with notes because it can be hard to get 300 here, because you don't hear any rhythm before changed to a slider
[Rain]
A lot of unsnapped things. But you can leave them, because I asked TicClick for help with timing and he promised to provide it at evening. blame song
00:11:877 (1) - same thing as with Easy done
01:14:048 (3,4) - this pattern is pretty clustered and hard to read, maybe better to leave that sound and use 2 1/2 sliders? nah, the melody's pretty much loud here so i'm leaving this here
01:16:819 (3) - how about using slider here that ends here 01:17:312 - here? will looks much easier with that kickslider before that looks questionable adjusted part
01:23:341 (2) - you didn't use such a "fast" notes before, maybe better to ignore this sound and delete that note? it looks just pretty sudden because you didn't use it before and can be pretty hard adjusted part because i don't wanna remove this

Now let's wait for TicClick.
i swear those circle-size rules are making me so mad that i won't try to rank maps like this anymore after this. but thanks for your mod Kyubey, now it's way more adjusted in some parts~
TicClick
i swear those circle-size rules are making me so mad that i won't try to rank maps like this anymore after this
because you know, easy maps are supposed to be easy

replace your timing with this
SPOILER
11887,612.244897959184,4,2,1,50,1,0
13111,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
15067,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
15719,666.666666666667,4,2,1,50,1,0
17719,612.244897959184,4,2,1,50,1,0
18331,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
22244,631.578947368421,4,2,1,50,1,0
22875,618.556701030928,4,2,1,50,1,0
23184,722.89156626506,4,2,1,50,1,0
23545,659.340659340659,4,2,1,50,1,0
25523,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
26175,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
28783,631.578947368421,4,2,1,50,1,0
32572,779.220779220779,4,2,1,50,1,0
33351,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
41829,666.666666666667,4,2,1,50,1,0
43162,625,4,2,1,50,1,0
43787,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
44439,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
47047,666.666666666667,4,2,1,50,1,0
48047,638.297872340426,4,2,1,50,1,0
49004,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
49656,645.161290322581,4,2,1,50,1,0
53204,779.220779220779,4,2,1,50,1,0
53593,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
54897,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
82940,638.297872340426,4,2,1,50,1,0
83578,652.173913043478,4,2,1,50,1,0
everything snaps to 1/1 and 1/2, except that funky part at 01:12:994
Topic Starter
Ekoro

TicClick wrote:

i swear those circle-size rules are making me so mad that i won't try to rank maps like this anymore after this
because you know, easy maps are supposed to be easy
Yeah but when the song forces you to map that slowly, you cannot make a hard overmapped diff just for the sake of "being allowed to use small CS". I wanted to use that CS because the song is very calm and the background "dark", and the slow rhythm make me want to do this. If it's not allowed because it's "too easy", i don't understand. It's the hardest diff i made (along with an even more Easy diff), and yet i'm not free with settings. (not talking about extremes like AR/OD10).

TicClick wrote:

everything snaps to 1/1 and 1/2, except that funky part at 01:12:994
Do you mean the whole part? Because i listened carefully (playback rate 25%) and i found out those 5 sliders (+4 next ones) are delayed 1/16ms later, so instead of moving all of them in weird yellow tick, i added a red section 1/16ms earlier (here) and added one when it comes back to normal. I think it's way more better like that.
There is also one other part just after that moment (probably around 1:18-1:20) that i find weird ; yellow tick sounds so much better than normal one, and next slider sounds better 1/16 (or 1/8) ms earlier. As i'm not in-game atm, i can't tell exactly which moment it is: but i know that it's two -longs- sliders in the top (left-corner) of the screen, if that can help you.

I'm not saying that the timing is bad, it's the contrary since it helped me a lot with most parts. Except the parts i mentioned, there's no problems as i -fastly- checked.

I also reduced some end of sliders to 10%. To me, they sound better if i end them earlier as the flute ends earlier than white tick (but later than blue tick) when we listen to it. Happened twice, and i wonder if i should keep them or move to -weird- tick again.
Didn't uploaded yet, i'll do it tomorrow probably.
TicClick
Please stop using 25% playback as it distorts the audio and you are unable to hear it unchanged; for details, talk to Charles.
Have you play tested the said parts and found them still being off?
It would also help a lot more if you posted more timestamps with exact changes and way less words
Topic Starter
Ekoro

TicClick wrote:

Please stop using 25% playback as it distorts the audio and you are unable to hear it unchanged; for details, talk to Charles.
Have you play tested the said parts and found them still being off?
It would also help a lot more if you posted more timestamps with exact changes and way less words
The parts sounds "correct" but it sounds better with some -slight- changes. Yes i tested them with normal audio and it does.
Sorry about timestamps, wasn't in-game to link them. Will surely link them when i'll be home.

EDIT: here are the moments that are questionable to me

  1. 01:10:548 (1,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - as there isn't any red section around and blue tick sounds weird, i added a red section at this moment for this part, changed back at 01:18:375.
  2. 01:21:962 (2,3) - Outside the problem that the slider overlaps the red section (not blaming anyone ofc), i moved 01:23:578 earlier because it sounds better, and not only in 25% playback, in 100% too. Added another section to "revert" back the delay after this slider.
Updated with your timing and some of my -slight- changes, i think that they're better but i'm not claiming it as ready yet, needs to be checked.
TicClick
will see tomorrow
edit: change 01:23:537's bpm to 89 to fix the snapping of slider tail (there's about 3ms difference on the end, resnap it too) and you're good to go

but please, show this to someone else

oh, and 01:21:961 (2) - should not be snapped to 1/8. use 1/2 instead solved
Topic Starter
Ekoro
timing issue solved with TicClick ; huge thanks to him !

irc chat
2015-02-04 19:40 Ekoro: Well, i do agree with 89 bpm section (and 3 ms resnap for next section)
2015-02-04 19:41 Ekoro: although 1/2 snap is obvious, it doesn't sound good (too earlier) and only yellow tick solves it
2015-02-04 19:41 Ekoro: but i don't know if i can move the red section 1/8ms earlier
2015-02-04 19:41 TicClick: don't
2015-02-04 19:41 Ekoro: this is only the part that tickle me, everything else is fine to me now
2015-02-04 19:41 TicClick: for me they both sound equally good/bad
2015-02-04 19:42 TicClick: depends on what you hear as the sound's end
2015-02-04 19:42 Ekoro: i don't know how to explain this, but well, i want to end the slider in the "main melody"
2015-02-04 19:42 TicClick: and whether you consider the echo significant enough to stretch sliders according to it
2015-02-04 19:44 TicClick: well, leave it like that if you wish
2015-02-04 19:45 TicClick: there are only sliders around, I don't think a random offbeat will throw someone off
2015-02-04 19:46 TicClick: are you dead? stunned? please say something
2015-02-04 19:46 Ekoro: haha sorry, was brb for a very short time
2015-02-04 19:46 TicClick: or you may be away
2015-02-04 19:47 Ekoro: it was originally circle+slider here, kyubey suggested me to change it so it was the good way i guess
2015-02-04 19:47 Ekoro: but since you suggested me to change to 89 bpm, 01:23:537 (3) - the beginning is unsnapped
2015-02-04 19:47 Ekoro: idk if that's an issue
2015-02-04 19:48 TicClick: uhh
2015-02-04 19:48 TicClick: I think you changed the wrong offset
2015-02-04 19:49 Ekoro: oh wait
2015-02-04 19:50 Ekoro: yeah it changed to 01:23:342 for wrong reason, now it's gone
2015-02-04 19:50 Ekoro: except that sliderend, everything should be fine
2015-02-04 19:50 Ekoro: should i get timing checked again or is it ready to go
2015-02-04 19:50 TicClick: for slider end, just resnap the offset that's near it
2015-02-04 19:50 TicClick: there should be about 3ms of difference
2015-02-04 19:51 Ekoro: i meant this 01:21:961 (2) actually
2015-02-04 19:51 Ekoro: i fixed the 3-ms difference and resnapped every notes
2015-02-04 19:51 TicClick: you know, I am not sure what you fixed anymore
2015-02-04 19:51 Ekoro: haha, well, let me resume
2015-02-04 19:51 TicClick: can you please send me .osu without uploading it to BSS first
2015-02-04 19:52 Ekoro: oh
2015-02-04 19:52 Ekoro: sure
2015-02-04 19:52 Ekoro: http://puu.sh/ftdtv.osu here
2015-02-04 19:56 TicClick: :(
2015-02-04 19:56 TicClick: the unsnapped tail still bothers me
2015-02-04 19:56 TicClick: I'll probably come up with something that formally fixes it
2015-02-04 19:56 TicClick: and we're done
2015-02-04 19:56 TicClick: wait till I message you
2015-02-04 19:56 Ekoro: sure
2015-02-04 19:57 Ekoro: asking question again, after this fix, should i get timing check again or is it ready to go
2015-02-04 19:57 TicClick: do as you wish
2015-02-04 19:58 Ekoro: hm ok
2015-02-04 19:58 TicClick: I am sure my timing is somehow stable
2015-02-04 19:58 TicClick: but it may be flawed
2015-02-04 19:58 Ekoro: well we'll see then, i think that it's good
2015-02-04 19:58 Ekoro: i don't know if it's wrong or not but if it is, it must be like 1-2 bpm difference or something
2015-02-04 20:06 TicClick: 01:22:940 -
2015-02-04 20:06 TicClick: set its bpm to 101.5
2015-02-04 20:06 TicClick: 01:21:961 (2) - 's end should be snapped to 1/16 on new section
2015-02-04 20:07 TicClick: the workaround is ugly as fuck and probably also musically incorrect
2015-02-04 20:08 Ekoro: sounds correct as it didn't really moved
2015-02-04 20:10 TicClick: or you can try 98.3
2015-02-04 20:10 TicClick: yeah try it
2015-02-04 20:10 TicClick: snaps to 1/3
2015-02-04 20:10 Ekoro: oh
2015-02-04 20:10 Ekoro: yeah
2015-02-04 20:11 TicClick: that's all
2015-02-04 20:12 Ekoro: i think everything is solved now?
2015-02-04 20:12 TicClick: I hope
2015-02-04 20:21 Ekoro: aaaand we're done
2015-02-04 20:21 Ekoro: aimod didn't found anything about resnap and stuff
2015-02-04 20:21 Ekoro: updated
2015-02-04 20:21 TicClick: cool
Kyubey
Looks good.
TicClick
General
  1. Use this background as it's a correct 16:9 one http://puu.sh/fvCBZ/e92264c646.jpg
Easy
Please make the spacing consistent by picking a spacing multiplier once and for all; all notes in the very beginning are spaced out differently. You tend to use 1.3x mostly, so..
  1. 00:20:939 (2) - move it up and right a bit, so that it forms a single curve with (1): http://puu.sh/fvDK5/809665e979.jpg (or you could just move the whole selection 00:11:886 (1,1,2,1) - down a bit instead)
Rain
See my remark on Easy about the same multiplier.
Topic Starter
Ekoro

TicClick wrote:

General
  1. Use this background as it's a correct 16:9 one http://puu.sh/fvCBZ/e92264c646.jpg done
Easy
Please make the spacing consistent by picking a spacing multiplier once and for all; all notes in the very beginning are spaced out differently. You tend to use 1.3x mostly, so.. With all those new red sections, it must have changed spacing multiplier, so now it's corrected.
  1. 00:20:939 (2) - move it up and right a bit, so that it forms a single curve with (1): http://puu.sh/fvDK5/809665e979.jpg (or you could just move the whole selection 00:11:886 (1,1,2,1) - down a bit instead) moved next parts instead ; fixed
Rain
See my remark on Easy about the same multiplier. done + changed slightly a part, as i told you in irc
thanks for the mod~
TicClick
Cool!
Topic Starter
Ekoro
huge thanks, TicClick ! /o/

i'm not forgetting Kyubey's bubble, thank you ♥
FGSky
t'as enfin rank un truc gg
Musty
Grats Ekoro!!
DaxMasterix
Support this bcz touhou and calm song.
osu need a lot more of beautiful songs instead of stupids high BPM songs, sometimes the calm and the peace make a beatmap more visible to learn the purpose of the mapping
Congratz and thanks for mapping this!
Aka
you didnt remind me.... . . =w=
Ichigaki
E E, wow)
Pappy
Why every timing point have unchecked "omit first bar line"? :o looks strange

Anyway congratz on rank Ekoro, nice map! o3o/
Kyubey

Pappy wrote:

Why every timing point have unchecked "omit first bar line"?
Because this is not a taiko map and mapper shouldn't care about other mods.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply