forum

TERRA - Catharsis Garden

posted
Total Posts
43
show more
Shulin
General:

- Find a new mp3? ~ I think a better quality mp3 would make the map awesome, plus you could turn the hitsound volume to max. It's no so bad lol.

Normal:

I enjoyed this.

00:14:037 (4) - Custom whistle should probably be on the start of this slider since its on every other one before it.
00:18:022 (1) - ^ Because it sounds odd without it.
00:42:022 (5) - Custom whistle seems out of place on the very last repeat.
00:50:022 (4) - New combo imo (following the lyrics), remove new combo from 00:51:014 (1) - if you take this suggestion.

Gameplay is great, no problems there imo.

Hard:

~ BG color to black on this difficulty.

Some of the slider shapes here do feel a little random:

00:10:068 (3) - Looks out of place.
00:11:091 (6) - ^ - At least try and make these to look alike lol they cover the same distance on the timeline.
00:20:006 (4) - Place the start of this on the start point of 00:18:083 (2) -
00:33:045 (4) - Looks ugly?
01:07:029 (3) - This was is random, I'd redraw this one.

Nice no major issues, good gameplay :D

~ Star
Topic Starter
ouranhshc

Shulin wrote:

General:

- Find a new mp3? ~ I think a better quality mp3 would make the map awesome, plus you could turn the hitsound volume to max. It's no so bad lol.

Normal:

I enjoyed this.

00:14:037 (4) - Custom whistle should probably be on the start of this slider since its on every other one before it.done
00:18:022 (1) - ^ Because it sounds odd without it.done
00:42:022 (5) - Custom whistle seems out of place on the very last repeat.done
00:50:022 (4) - New combo imo (following the lyrics), remove new combo from 00:51:014 (1) - if you take this suggestion.done

Gameplay is great, no problems there imo.

Hard:

~ BG color to black on this difficulty.done

Some of the slider shapes here do feel a little random:

00:10:068 (3) - Looks out of place.done
00:11:091 (6) - ^ - At least try and make these to look alike lol they cover the same distance on the timeline.fixed
00:20:006 (4) - Place the start of this on the start point of 00:18:083 (2) -nah
00:33:045 (4) - Looks ugly?its "was" ugly
01:07:029 (3) - This was is random, I'd redraw this one.fixed

Nice no major issues, good gameplay :D

~ Star
Yay
Jarby
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Lokamp
Normal
00:36:006 (2) - end it with finish
01:22:022 (3) - new combo
01:36:099 (1,2,3,4) - end these sliders with finish

Hard
01:08:022 (6) - end it with whistle
01:41:060 (4) - finish on this slider's start and end

Another lovely map well-packed means another star for you ;3
Wizard Of Orz

ouranhshc wrote:

im srry but im really not liking it though. im probably not going to use it
lol
ShokuMasterLord
Suggestions:
Hard:
00:19:913 (3) try making 4 closer to 3.
01:39:451-01:41:759 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) pretty, but move them towards the center; they're too far away.

Normal:
Looks cramped. Perhaps if you changed it to a higher ud or a lower circle size.
00:59:451(5) not sure if this is intentional but the stack would go on the five to match up with the vocals.

Very nice job.
Here's a star.
AngelHoney
nice map~

star :) :)

---------------------------------------

hard

01:00:083 (4) - 01:00:836 to 01:00:836?

01:01:014 (5) - 01:01:143 to 01:01:451?

01:05:060 (3) - repeat to this slider ?

00:18:022 (1,2,3,4) - 0.5*bpm?

01:14:083 (1,2,3,4) - 0.5*bpm?

01:34:052 (1,2,3,4) - 0.5*bpm?
Crazy Jay
wow,it's really an awesome map,I like it.>w<~
[Normal]
nice

[Hard]
00:14:374(3,4,5) - how about change it like this?
00:51:143(1,2,3) - how about add a note at 00:50:990

Star~~~
Topic Starter
ouranhshc

AngelHoney wrote:

nice map~

star :) :)

---------------------------------------

hard

01:00:083 (4) - 01:00:836 to 01:00:836?wut.

01:01:014 (5) - 01:01:143 to 01:01:451?wut.

01:05:060 (3) - repeat to this slider ?done

00:18:022 (1,2,3,4) - 0.5*bpm?nah

01:14:083 (1,2,3,4) - 0.5*bpm?nah

01:34:052 (1,2,3,4) - 0.5*bpm?nah


Crazy Jay wrote:

wow,it's really an awesome map,I like it.>w<~
[Normal]
nicethx XD

[Hard]
00:14:374(3,4,5) - how about change it like this?[attachment=0:251a1]example.jpg[/attachment:251a1]done
00:51:143(1,2,3) - how about add a note at 00:50:990done

Star~~~
ShaggoN
Blue: Sugestion. Should take good effects.
Green: Notification or cosmetic issue. May, but don't have to be fixed.
Yellow: Should be fixed.
Red: Have to be fixed.

[Normal]
  1. 00:04:052 (3,4) - Little spacing issue
[Hard]
  1. 00:02:083 (1) - Move it one grid down to make line with 2 and 3. Looks better imo.
Awesome job. I love hitsound work. Starr'd
Lybydose
Offset feels a bit late, try -15ms

Normal:

The section from 00:30:048 to 00:37:056 follows a rhythm that isn't really very intuitive (at least for "normal"). The whistle placement also makes the whole thing seem wrong. This also happens later in the song around 01:20:094 and 01:26:048. You're setting the whistles to sync up with the lyrics, but the map is not following the lyrics, so it ends up sounding strange.

01:12:068 (1) - extend this by 1/2 to the red tick

Hard:

Much better now with the increased OD.

01:24:022 (6) - This slider is kind of strange. It sounds better if you end it at 01:24:022 to follow the vocals (and maybe put a custom whistle on it?)
01:27:056 - maybe add a circle?

hitsound suggestions for hard:

00:18:022 (1,2,3,4,5) - The whistles sound better me if placed on the 1, 3, and 5 start points, instead of the 2 and 4.
01:34:052 (1,2,3,4) - the whistles sound out of place here
01:36:099 (1) - maybe place a whistle here to go with the rest of the pattern
01:40:068 (1) - ^

You might want to make an easier difficulty too.
arien666
[Normal]
00:05:29(4,5) - They're close with (3)'s end than other's. Maybe you need to check them :3
01:09:29(7,8) - ^ but (6)'s end

[Hard]
00:08:97(2) - [Suggestion] How about move a little up to align with (1)'s end?
00:45:74(4) - A little stack issue :3 [Suggestion] How about move a little down?
00:48:05(3) - [Suggestion] How about move 1 grid down?
00:48:82(6) - [Suggestion] How about move 1 grid left?
00:56:97(2) - [Minor suggestion] How about align with 00:56:35(1)'s end?
01:28:66(1,2,3,4) - [Suggestion] How about make line pattern with (1)'s end,(2),(3),(4)'s start?

:3...
TERRA song XD
Good map and good luck for you XD

Here's my star :3
Aoitenshi
This is a very well done beatmap, STAR!
Xgor
Here is mine :D (Change the name of the difficulty if you want)
Download: TERRA - Catharsis Garden (ouranhshc) [Xgoeasy].osu

I couldn't find anything wrong with the other diffs and i loved how action packed Hard are! :D
*star*
0_o
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Card N'FoRcE
- General:
  • KIAI section is really long. I suggest KIAI from 00:57:605 to 01:17:297 and from 01:27:143 to the end.
    If you are not willing to follow that suggestion, at least fix the beginning of the KIAI section: it should start at 00:57:605
- Xgoeasy:
  • .Opinions:
    Please capitalize the E in the name of the difficulty :P
- Normal:
  • .Opinions:
    Map is good, but everything in the last part is 1/1 D:
- Hard:
  • .Suggestions:
    00:14:35 (3) - missing hitsound at the beginning?
    00:47:074 (1) - ok, it's a new combo, but i still think that it would be better to move it farther :P
Good job ^^
Star'd
Mafiamaster
Xgor~
Add Xgor to the tags in this difficulty.

Normal~
00:02:83 - Remove new combo.
00:03:29 (3) - New combo.
00:04:06 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:04:52 (4) - New combo.

Kiai seems a bit long as stated by Card N'FoRcE.
Please reduce the length of your Kiai Time on all difficulties.

Edit: Bubbled!
Topic Starter
ouranhshc
thank you mafia
Andrea
I can't rank maps for the first week, So I have to reject your request. Sorry :(
Topic Starter
ouranhshc

osuplayer111 wrote:

I can't rank maps for the first week, So I have to reject your request. Sorry :(
its ok. it got bubbled while it was in your queue
ztrot
ranked
Please sign in to reply.

New reply