Rate on a scale of 1 to 5 (Read post before answering)
5 - Love them! 20%  20%  [ 52 ]
4 35%  35%  [ 92 ]
3 26%  26%  [ 67 ]
2 9%  9%  [ 25 ]
1 - Hate them! 7%  7%  [ 20 ]
Total votes : 256
User avatar
osu! Alumni
922 posts
Offline
Something new I'm going to try to see what techniques in mapping players like and don't like.

Round 1: 'back and forth' beats

Image

Something a bit general to start off with. This is usually 3 or more beats arranged so that the 3rd beat and onward alternate from where 1 and 2 were located. Many maps have this in one form or another, usually arranged horizontally or vertically.

I have a bunch of other techniques in mind, but if there's a technique you would like to see in a future poll, I will take nominations provided you give me:
1. A name for the technique (it can be an official name or one you make up)
2. An accurate description of the technique (or alternatively, a screenshot of the technique)
3. A ranked map that has the technique so I can see it in action.
Viva la Cobra!

Image

Currently pending:
Beyonce feat. Jay-Z - Crazy in Love (+19)
Ikaruga - Chapter 1 (Ideal) (+17)
User avatar
Slider Savant
115 posts
Offline
rated 4 beacause i personally rather like an alternative version of that tech,on wich circles appears farther and farther during the combo.

Ex: MAKI - I~jan! Yuujou (hard) by nharox at 1:50:246
Image
User avatar
Administrator
7,080 posts
Offline
I gave 'back and forth' a 4/5. They're nice, but I hate them in streams. I'm still trying to get better and 180 degree direction changes in streams XP

My favorite usage of this, though, is when there's a pattern like: Left, middle, top, middle, right, middle, bottom, middle in a + pattern. Those are always cool~
Derekku Chan wrote:
My favorite usage of this, though, is when there's a pattern like: Left, middle, top, middle, right, middle, bottom, middle in a + pattern. Those are always cool~

E.g. Cross Time. I love them too.

I'm not sure what to vote because I don't think the scale is well-defined. I guess I will vote it a three, because I like this being used at times (e.g. Cross Time) but it's not something which can fit in ever map (or even half the maps) well. It's also not as easy to read as other patterns (e.g. zig-zags).

EDIT: OP, please allow votes to be changed. Thanks!
User avatar
osu! Alumni
4,451 posts
Offline
These are a fun pattern when used right.
Image
Osu! Skins: Taiko Drum Master | Elite Beat Osu
Storyboards: Taiko/ChiBA Storyboard (w/awp) | SMB1 Medley Storyboard | Braid Storyboard | PW/EBA Storyboard (w/m980)
All the maps in my graveyard are up for grabs, PM me if you're a good mapper and want to take over one of them
(╯‵Д′)╯彡┻━┻

ルイージハン
User avatar
osu! Alumni
922 posts
Offline
strager wrote:
EDIT: OP, please allow votes to be changed. Thanks!

Done.
Viva la Cobra!

Image

Currently pending:
Beyonce feat. Jay-Z - Crazy in Love (+19)
Ikaruga - Chapter 1 (Ideal) (+17)
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
3,505 posts
Offline
Voted 2.

I like it when it's used appropriately, but I hate it when it's spammed or put in randomly. Also anyone who uses it with 1/4s of 120+ BPM is a jerk. I can't move my mouse like that. XP

Really fun when it's a slider end, a beat to the side, then the next one under the slider end. Ex. Hirari. People keep on getting confused by that kind of trick. <3

P.S. I don't consider what Derek described "back and forth" beats. I consider them in a different category: "back to the center". It's a variation, but it plays much differently, differently enough for me to consider it a different thing. Example of this is Biggest Dreamer's Normal, you should see it around the start of the chorus IIRC.

I do use this occasionally, BTW. Mainly where it feels right. On the occasions where I do use it, it's usually only like once in that entire map.
[img]http://puu.sh/Grie[/img]
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
2,042 posts
Offline
*Points at kanbu*
3
Image
Ekaru wrote:
P.S. I don't consider what Derek described "back and forth" beats. I consider them in a different category: "back to the center". It's a variation, but it plays much differently, differently enough for me to consider it a different thing. Example of this is Biggest Dreamer's Normal, you should see it around the start of the chorus IIRC.

To make a full "+" four back-forths have to be used.

I think it's well qualified as being the same technique.
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
3,505 posts
Offline
strager wrote:

I think it's well qualified as being the same technique.


You don't really go back and forth, though. You keep on returning to the center. That's why it's said it's a variation. It's taking that technique and using it in a creative way. Hence, "Back to the center" instead of "Back and forth".
[img]http://puu.sh/Grie[/img]
Ekaru wrote:
It's taking that technique and using it in a creative way.

So I guess we agree it's the same technique?
Rhythm Incarnate
2,695 posts
Offline
It's tough to vote on small techniques like this.

So I'll vote on potential.

steams should never pull multiple 180 turns btw.
User avatar
osu! Alumni
2,065 posts
Offline
I rated 4. I don't use it too much, but I like it.

1. Emm... kiou2's sliders?
2. Image
3. Boozehound [Kiou2's Normal] or any kiou2's map.
User avatar
Rhythm Incarnate
3,505 posts
Offline
strager wrote:
Ekaru wrote:
It's taking that technique and using it in a creative way.

So I guess we agree it's the same technique?


I never said it was a different technique, I said it was a variation. I consider back and forth going back and forth and back and forth, while "back to the center" is where you keep on going back to the center, but the hit circle other than the center is in a different spot each time.

One is boring when it goes on for more than a beat or two, one isn't. It's a different usage and it's different enough for me to count it as something different.

EDIT:

1. Half-backing
2. Two hit circles are one beat apart. Another hit circle a half-beat after the second circle is situated between those two.
3. http://osu.ppy.sh/s/6301 <-- Hard uses this a lot.

While we're on this, why not suggest something similar to it, but quite different?
[img]http://puu.sh/Grie[/img]
Etna's are well known and would be a nice candidate for community rating.
Reply 36 posts jump | 1, 2, 3  next

Users browsing this forum: None


Jump to: